General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

questions about boiling potatoes

Started by Dh Ld · · Last activity · 36 posts · 2,676 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
3 April 2004
Last activity
17 May 2004
Original author
Dh Ld
Posts
36
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,676
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 21–36 of 36
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. "Stephanie Stowe" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:


    "Wayne Boatwright" <[email hidden]>
    wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "Stephanie Stowe" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:


    <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...
    > Hi again,
    >
    > Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes? I
    > used to do it back when microwaves weighed a hundred
    > pounds and cost a hundred dollars, but for the past
    > several years have been microwaving them. I do
    > remember cooking them with the skins on, and that it
    > often got the water dirty, plus it was a hot and
    > irritating experience to get the skins off when they
    > finally got done. It also took a long time. Is it
    > better and faster to skin them first, or do they get
    > all mushy or something without the skins on? How about
    > cutting them up....is there a down side to that or is
    > it about the same result in a shoter period of time?
    >
    > Thanks for any help! David

    If the potatoes are to be used for potato salad, then
    they really need to be cooked in the skin. Otherwise,
    chop 'em up and boil them. If you cut them up, you will
    use less energy and time in their cooking.

    S

    Why? If the right potatoes are used and are sliced or
    cubed uniformly, I find it much easier to peel first for
    potato salad. In fact, the pieces of potato cook are more
    evenly cooked.

    Wayne

    I like the flavor the skins add.

    S

    Hey, whatever floats your boat! <G> As I said in an
    another post, I do like the skins, but not when mixed with
    a mayo-based dressing. I like them both ways depending on
    how I use them.

    Cheers, Wayne

  2. (Stephanie=A0Stowe)WROTE:

    Hi again, Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes?
    I used to do it back when microwaves weighed a hundred
    pounds and cost a hundred dollars, but for the past several
    years have been microwaving them. I do remember cooking them
    with the skins on, and that it often got the water dirty,
    plus it was a hot and irritating experience to get the skins
    off when they finally got done. It also took a long time. Is
    it better and faster to skin them first, or do they get all
    mushy or something without the skins on? How about cutting
    them up....is there a down side to that or is it about the
    same result in a shoter period of time? Thanks for any help!
    David If the potatoes are to be used for potato salad, then
    they really need to be cooked in the skin. Otherwise, chop
    'em up and boil them. If you cut them up, you will use less
    energy and time in their cooking.
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    ---
    response: This post bought back nightmares when I was
    working at a local coney island with b/f where we had to
    boil 500 pounds of potatoes with skins on then peel cool
    then run through a slicing machine-hand manual- for american
    fries. This amount was just for the Sunday crowd. I did a
    few Hail Mary's when the owner kids switch over to those
    bags of precooked sliced american fries-just lightly grill
    them- that even tasted better not counting less labor costs
    and toll on my hands.

  3. Wayne Boatwright said:

    UK potatoes, of course, as I've never seen and probably
    never will see them where I live in Arizona. Doubtful,
    too, if I were inclined, that I could even begin to
    grow potatoes here. Sure sounds like a variety I would
    like to try.

    Quoted message said:

    I rarely peel spuds at all, and never little new ones or
    jacket spuds. I can eat all types, but peeling them, or
    scraping new ones, brings my hands out in itchy red
    blotches, then stains them a grubby brown.

    Definitely all good reasons to leave the peels on!

    Wayne

    We do seem to have a wider variety of names spuds here, both
    the big 'do everything' types of generic red and white
    types, as well as things like charlottes, King Edwards,
    Maris Piper, Jersey Royals, and some nice ones that get
    imported fro Egypt just at the time when local potatoes are
    reaching the end of their best seasons and the new ones are
    not quite affordable.
    --

    Lady Catherine, Wardrobe Mistress of the Chocolate Buttons
    diceyhome.free-online.co.ukdiceyhome.free-online.co.uk Click on Kate's Pages
    and explore!

  4. Kate Dicey <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:
    Wayne Boatwright said:

    UK potatoes, of course, as I've never seen and probably
    never will see them where I live in Arizona. Doubtful,
    too, if I were inclined, that I could even begin to grow
    potatoes here. Sure sounds like a variety I would like
    to try.

    Quoted message said:

    I rarely peel spuds at all, and never little new ones
    or jacket spuds. I can eat all types, but peeling them,
    or scraping new ones, brings my hands out in itchy red
    blotches, then stains them a grubby brown.

    Definitely all good reasons to leave the peels on!

    Wayne

    We do seem to have a wider variety of names spuds here,
    both the big 'do everything' types of generic red and
    white types, as well as things like charlottes, King
    Edwards, Maris Piper, Jersey Royals, and some nice ones
    that get imported fro Egypt just at the time when local
    potatoes are reaching the end of their best seasons and
    the new ones are not quite affordable.

    Yes, you have an enviable variety! My favorite US potato for
    general use is the Yukon Gold, pretty color and great
    flavor. My favorite for potato salad or other uses where a
    firmer potato is desired is the Red Bliss.

  5. When mashing spuds I use a potato ricer not only do I not
    bother peeling them as the skin gets left behind. But the
    texture is lighter and fluffy. But gotta admit I would wash
    em.... cant imagine not washing em!

    Quoted message said:

    Hi again,

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes? I used
    to do it back when microwaves weighed a hundred pounds and
    cost a hundred dollars, but for the past several years
    have been microwaving them. I do remember cooking them
    with the skins on, and that it often got the water dirty,
    plus it was a hot and irritating experience to get the
    skins off when they finally got done. It also took a long
    time. Is it better and faster to skin them first, or do
    they get all mushy or something without the skins on? How
    about cutting them up....is there a down side to that or
    is it about the same result in a shoter period of time?

    Thanks for any help! David

  6. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes?

    If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed potatoes, have
    you ever tried making them WITH the skins? I first had these
    at a terrific outdoor chuckwagon supper in the Tetons. I
    think the skins add a lot of flavor. Naturally, a good
    scrubbing prior to boiling them is in order, and I cut mine
    into about 4 to 8 large chunks, but I don't peel them. When
    they are just fork tender, I drain them and mash as usually
    (butter, salt, white pepper, hot milk). Try them and see if
    you don't enjoy the change of pace. Anyway, the skins are
    where all the good nutrients are, right??

  7. [email hidden] :

    || If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed potatoes,
    || have you ever tried making them WITH the skins?
    ||
    This is a common way of mashing potatoes in the area where I
    grew up. And that was many years ago 😉
    --

    Cynical - me?

  8. "Calypso985" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes?

    If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed potatoes, have
    you ever tried making them WITH the skins? I first had
    these at a terrific outdoor


    chuckwagon

    Quoted message said:

    supper in the Tetons. I think the skins add a lot of
    flavor. Naturally,


    a

    Quoted message said:

    good scrubbing prior to boiling them is in order, and I
    cut mine into


    about 4

    Quoted message said:

    to 8 large chunks, but I don't peel them. When they are
    just fork tender,


    I

    Quoted message said:

    drain them and mash as usually (butter, salt, white
    pepper, hot milk).


    Try

    Quoted message said:

    them and see if you don't enjoy the change of pace.
    Anyway, the skins are where all the good nutrients
    are, right??

    I agree that skin-on mashed spuds can be great - but the
    "nutrients are in the skin" claim is a myth.

    --
    Peter Aitken

    Remove the [censored] from my email address before using.

  9. august said:

    [email hidden] :

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed potatoes,
    have you ever tried making them WITH the skins?


    This is a common way of mashing potatoes in the area where
    I grew up.

    mmm.. fibre.

    I remember the first time I was served roast pumpkin with
    the skin on at a relatives house ( my mother would skin our
    pumpkin ). I was 15 and horrified. My aunt told me to "eat
    it", and I was suprised at how much more delicious pumpkin
    was with skin on. I would never roast a pumpkin without skin
    now... yummm...

  10. [email hidden] :

    || august wrote:
    || > [email hidden] :
    || >
    || >>> If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed
    || >>> potatoes, have you ever tried making them WITH the
    || >>> skins?
    || >>>
    || > This is a common way of mashing potatoes in the area
    || > where I grew up.
    ||
    || mmm.. fibre.
    ||
    || I remember the first time I was served roast pumpkin
    || with the skin on at a relatives house ( my mother would
    || skin our pumpkin ). I was 15 and horrified. My aunt told
    || me to "eat it", and I was suprised at how much more
    || delicious pumpkin was with skin on. I would never roast
    || a pumpkin without skin now... yummm...

    Yes - pumpkin with the skin on is so much tastier!

    I love a QLD blue or a butternut roasted with my lamb, yum.

    Have you tried thin slices brushed with Olive Oil and then a
    few minutes under the griller (turn and repeat?) Sweet
    potato as well. Delish!

    --

    Cynical - me?

  11. august said:

    [email hidden] :

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    I remember the first time I was served roast pumpkin
    with the skin on at a relatives house ( my mother would
    skin our pumpkin ). I was 15 and horrified. My aunt
    told me to "eat it", and I was suprised at how much
    more delicious pumpkin was with skin on. I would never
    roast a pumpkin without skin now... yummm...

    Yes - pumpkin with the skin on is so much tastier!

    I still scowled as I ate it, though secretly planning on
    telling my mum how much nicer Aunty Flo made it ! <g>

    Quoted message said:

    I love a QLD blue or a butternut roasted with my
    lamb, yum.

    Have you tried thin slices brushed with Olive Oil and then
    a few minutes under the griller (turn and repeat?) Sweet
    potato as well. Delish!

    Yummi.

    --
    10-16-26

  12. (Calypso985) said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes?

    If you are boiling the spuds to make mashed potatoes, have
    you ever tried making them WITH the skins? I first had
    these at a terrific outdoor chuckwagon supper in the
    Tetons. I think the skins add a lot of flavor. Naturally, a
    good scrubbing prior to boiling them is in order, and I cut
    mine into about 4 to 8 large chunks, but I don't peel them.
    When they are just fork tender, I drain them and mash as
    usually (butter, salt, white pepper, hot milk). Try them
    and see if you don't enjoy the change of pace. Anyway, the
    skins are where all the good nutrients are, right??

    I always leave the skins on -- they add flavor, and
    nutrition (so I hear!)

    Never cut them, though, because they absorb more water and
    seem mushier.

    Cook's Illustrated sez: Mix the butter in first, then the
    liquid because they will stay fluffier if the butter is in
    first. Otherwise the liquid will tend to make them soggy.

  13. On Sat, 03 Apr 2004 16:24:07 GMT, I needed a Bable Fish to understand
    [email hidden] :

    Quoted message said:

    Hi again,

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes? I used
    to do it back when microwaves weighed a hundred pounds and
    cost a hundred dollars, but for the past several years have
    been microwaving them. I do remember cooking them with the
    skins on, and that it often got the water dirty, plus it
    was a hot and irritating experience to get the skins off
    when they finally got done. It also took a long time. Is it
    better and faster to skin them first, or do they get all
    mushy or something without the skins on? How about cutting
    them up....is there a down side to that or is it about the
    same result in a shoter period of time?

    Thanks for any help! David

    While reading this thread, I have heard of various types of
    potato, that I have no knowledge of. Basically I knew of
    Regular potato (you know, various sizes brown, good for
    baking) and the general red / new potato, small round and
    lots of fun. So, anyone know of a decent location to get the
    Lowdown of what is what all about potato?

    Your time and insight are appreciated.

  14. Lewzephyr <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    On Sat, 03 Apr 2004 16:24:07 GMT, I needed a Bable Fish to
    understand [email hidden] :

    Quoted message said:

    Hi again,

    Can anyone share some tips about boiling potatoes? I used
    to do it back when microwaves weighed a hundred pounds and
    cost a hundred dollars, but for the past several years
    have been microwaving them. I do remember cooking them
    with the skins on, and that it often got the water dirty,
    plus it was a hot and irritating experience to get the
    skins off when they finally got done. It also took a long
    time. Is it better and faster to skin them first, or do
    they get all mushy or something without the skins on? How
    about cutting them up....is there a down side to that or
    is it about the same result in a shoter period of time?

    Thanks for any help! David

    While reading this thread, I have heard of various types
    of potato, that I have no knowledge of. Basically I knew
    of Regular potato (you know, various sizes brown, good for
    baking) and the general red / new potato, small round and
    lots of fun. So, anyone know of a decent location to get
    the Lowdown of what is what all about potato?

    Your time and insight are appreciated.

    From Harry & David...

    For all practical purposes, potatoes fall into two easy
    categories — baking potatoes and boiling potatoes. There’s
    also a middle ground, but we’ll get to that in a minute.

    Probably the chief difference between the two types is the
    amount and nature of starch each contains. Baking potatoes
    are relatively high in starch and it is called amylose
    starch. Boiling potatoes are low in starch and it is
    called amylopectin. This pectin (just as with fruit for
    jams) is what holds the potato together when boiling or in
    soup and stews.

    Baking potatoes

    These are also called starchy potatoes. They tend to be long
    and have a coarse, cork-like skin. They are high in starch,
    with a dry, mealy texture. But, they turn light and fluffy
    when cooked.

    They are ideal for baking, mashing and French fries. They
    are light and fluffy baked, light and creamy mashed, and
    frankly, the only potato worth frying.

    Some of the names you’ll see them under in the supermarket
    are Russet Burbank, Russet Arcadia, Norgold Russet,
    Goldrush, Norkotah, Long White (or White Rose or California
    Long White), and Idaho.

    Boiling potatoes

    These are also called waxy potatoes. They come in a variety
    of shapes and can be long or round. They have a thin, smooth
    skin and an almost waxy flesh. They are relatively high in
    moisture and sugar, but low in starch.

    They are ideal for soups, casseroles, potato salad,
    roasting, and barbecuing because of their tendency to hold
    their shape. You can mash them, but instead of smooth and
    creamy, the results tend to be thick and lumpy.

    You will find them sold as Round White, Round Red, Yellow
    Potato, Red Potato, Salad Potato, La Soda, Red La Rouge, Red
    Pontiac, Red Nordland, Red Bliss, Yellow Finnish, Ruby
    Crescent, and Australian Crescent.

    Now, there are some potatoes that fall in the middle, in the
    "all- purpose" category, such as the Yukon Gold, Peruvian
    Blue, Superior, Kennebec, and Katahdin. They are moister
    than baking potatoes and will hold together in boiling
    water. They are particularly well-suited to roasting, pan
    frying, and using in soups, stews, and gratins. They can be
    baked, mashed, and fried, but will not produce the same
    results as the bakers.

    And finally, as you must know by now, a new potato is just
    that — an immature, small potato of whatever variety. Red
    potatoes may be the type most often sold, but that does not
    mean that a red potato is a new potato or that a new potato
    is a red potato.

    --
    Wayne in Phoenix

    Big on natural foods?? 82.38% of people die of
    "natural" causes.

  15. Wayne wrote:

    [All snipped]

    Bravo for an excellent rundown!

    --
    Wayne in Phoenix

    Big on natural foods?? 82.38% of people die of
    "natural" causes.

    Most of my food is (and most of my friends are) cultivated.

    Jerry
    --
    Engineering is the art of making what you want from things
    you can get. ¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯-
    ¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯

  16. Jerry Avins <[email hidden]> wrote in news:40a91e1f$0$3047
    [email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Wayne wrote:

    [All snipped]

    Bravo for an excellent rundown!

    Thanks, Jerry! I found the article a while back when I was
    lamenting about the narrow offering of potato varieties in
    my local stores.

    BTW, I like your tagline!

    --
    Wayne in Phoenix

    Big on natural foods?? 82.38% of people die of
    "natural" causes.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.