ACAHF "misrepresentation" # 2

Quoted message said:

Subject: ACAHF "misrepresentation" # 2
From: [email hidden]
Date: 3/13/2004 3:03 AM Pacific Standard Time
Message-id: <[email hidden]>

From: Mark ([email hidden]) Subject: Re: Dr. Sandra
Cabot Date: 2004-03-04 19:56:26 PST

Quoted message said:

RB might like to tackle this question: Just where did
"Dr." Cabot get her medical degree, since the University
of South Australia (her supposed alma mater) doesn't even
offer one?

Mark, MD (a real doctor, with a real medical degree and
real board certification)

---------------

Mark, that was another of the misreps (the first being the
"Ex-doc" myth).

How funny that Mr Acahf expects us to believe that the Doc
could have studied in the 1970s at a University that did
not even exist until the '90s.

Do you begin to see how the story has been played out?

Aus had only a few main Unis until recently, with one main
one in each State. The University of Adelaide _was_, by
default, the university for the State of South Australia.
As well, the new one has no great prestige, it has not been
around long enough: as has been noted, it does not even
have a Medical School.

There are other misreps also.

Toby Joe.

Mark MD is one of the *GANG*

Jan

Quoted message said:

From: Mark ([email hidden]) Subject: Re: Dr. Sandra
Cabot Date: 2004-03-04 19:56:26 PST

Quoted message said:

RB might like to tackle this question: Just where did
"Dr." Cabot get her medical degree, since the University
of South Australia (her supposed alma mater) doesn't even
offer one?

Mark, MD (a real doctor, with a real medical degree and
real board certification)

---------------

Mark, that was another of the misreps (the first being the
"Ex-doc" myth).

How funny that Mr Acahf expects us to believe that the Doc
could have studied in the 1970s at a University that did
not even exist until the '90s.

There's your problem, Toby. I don't expect people to
believe that at all. But on the web page
liverdoctor.comaboutdrcabot.aspOpen ↗ it says, and
I quote, "Dr Cabot graduated with honours in Medicine
and Surgery from the University of South Australia in
1975". Dr Cabot expects people to believe it. I know
that it is not true.

You now need to reword what you wrote so that it says : "How
funny that Dr Cabot expects us to believe that the Doc could
have studied in the 1970s at a University that did not even
exist until the '90s".

I don't think it's funny. I think it's lying.

Quoted message said:

Do you begin to see how the story has been played out?

Aus had only a few main Unis until recently, with one main
one in each State. The University of Adelaide _was_, by
default, the university for the State of South Australia.
As well, the new one has no great prestige, it has not been
around long enough: as has been noted, it does not even
have a Medical School.

Yet at liverdoctor.comaboutdrcabot.aspOpen ↗ it says :
"Dr Cabot graduated with honours in Medicine and Surgery
from the University of South Australia in 1975".

Do you begin to see how the story has been played out?

Quoted message said:

There are other misreps also.

There certainly are. One of the most glaring is that at the
top of the web page at
liverdoctor.comaboutdrcabot.aspOpen ↗ it says "Sandra
Cabot MD" yet there is no evidence anywhere that Dr Sandra
Cabot MB,BS has ever qualified for the degree of "MD",
either in the US (where it is equivalent to MB,BS) or
elsewhere where it is a postgraduate research degree.

Quoted message said:

Toby Joe.

--
Peter Bowditch
The Millenium Project ratbags.comrsolesOpen ↗
The Green Light ratbags.comgreenlightOpen ↗
and The New Improved Quintessence of the Loon with added Vitamins and C-Q10 ratbags.comloonOpen ↗
To email me use my first name only at ratbags.com

Quoted message said:

From: Peter Bowditch [email hidden]
Date: 3/13/2004 5:22 PM Pacific Standard Time
Message-id: <[email hidden]>

Peter with NO medical qualificaions, squawks again.

<snip>

Quoted message said:

I don't think it's funny. I think it's lying.

This is LYING.

There are THREE lies in the Three dead children story. All
RHREE about the Ben Kolb tragedy.

These are your EXACT words:

Some proponents of "alternative medicine" have tried to make
an issue out of Ben's death, apparently on the basis that a
mistake made by real doctors somehow has something to do
with children dying because pretend doctors treat them with
snake oil.

These are mine:

So far you haven't been able to copy and paste where you got
that idea.

And you can't, can you Peter?

So that is LIE # 1.

Then you stated:

You can read about Ben
athttp://www.krupnicklaw.com/site/press/healing.htm This
site belongs tot he lawyers who represented Ben's parents at
the time. The attitude ofthe parents' lawyers stands in
stark contrast to the way "

(My words below)

So far you haven't been able to copy and paste WHERE or WHO
had this stark contrast.

And you can't, can you Peter?

So that is LIE # 2

You also stated:

"alternative medicine" supporters attempt to demonise the
people who made a tragic mistake.

(My words below)

So far, you haven't been able to copy and paste who
demonized anyone.

And you can't, can you Peter?

So that is LIE # 3

Here is WHAT I posted:

From: Jan ([email hidden]) Subject: Re: A Lesson from
Ben Newsgroups: misc.health.alternative View: Complete
Thread (21 articles) | Date: 2002-01-02 11:01:59 PST

<snipping to the *only* thing said about the doctor>

Yes. They did the right thing and my heart goes out to the
doctor, and all those involved. The parents in turn also
did the right thing and dropped the lawsuit. I was indeed
very sad for everyone. This is why I started my post with
this sentence.

This post is NOT intended to go after any *ONE* individual.

NO demonizing whatsoever.

Jan

"Jan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
"]news:[email hidden]...

Quoted message said:

Quoted message said:

From: Peter Bowditch [email hidden] Date:
3/13/2004 5:22 PM Pacific Standard Time Message-id:
<[email hidden]>

Peter with NO medical qualificaions, squawks again.

===============
Why don't you address the CONTRADICTIONS and lies of this
Cabot person instead of attacking the poster? Do you kill
the post man because he brings you bad news?
--
Kim Please note, I don't wish to get involved in any
personal conflicts between the posters here. I'm simply
looking for answers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Well Toby.....what do you think of our *newbie* now? Believe
me man, she's on here just to be a troublemaker and has lied
about her agenda for coming on here from the beginning.
Those of us that have been here awhile know the patterns and
can see what's up and/or coming much better than true
newbies such as yourself. Trust us......she's a plant.

"Kim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:TPWdneZewp9lQ87dRVn-
[email hidden]...

Quoted message said:

"Jan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:20040313225644.24913.00001383@mb-
m26.aol.com...

Quoted message said:

Quoted message said:

From: Peter Bowditch [email hidden] Date:
3/13/2004 5:22 PM Pacific Standard Time Message-id:
<[email hidden]>

Peter with NO medical qualificaions, squawks again.

===============
Why don't you address the CONTRADICTIONS and lies of this
Cabot person instead of attacking the poster? Do you kill
the post man because he

brings

Quoted message said:

you bad news?
--
Kim Please note, I don't wish to get involved in any
personal conflicts between the posters here. I'm simply
looking for answers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Jan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
"]news:[email hidden]...

Quoted message said:

I see you are busy posting, why don't you prove your many
claims??????

Check out Clarks and Cabots websites for proof of any claims
you saw. :-) I need say no more. Is your blood pressure up
yet Jan? Are you feeling the headache yet? The adrenaline
rush? LOL!!!
--
Kim Please note, I don't wish to get involved in any
personal conflicts between the posters here. I'm simply
looking for answers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~