General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

cant dive

Started by Matthias Pfeife · · Last activity · 10 posts · 1,294 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
13 September 2003
Last activity
13 September 2003
Original author
Matthias Pfeife
Posts
10
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,294
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–10 of 10
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I am at good health and i am an avareg swimmer training 3times a week each about 3-4 km and 1-1.5h
    additionaly i do some running. So: at all i consider myself to be in a "damn good physical
    condition". Since i consider this to be enough to make able to dive 25m which i tend to train more
    or less regular but in about 90 percent i only do some three breast strokes and than feel like
    exploding. Also i dont see any light on the horizon (ie i dont seem to get a better diver).

    Is there some reason from daily life making me not to predestined for diving (like beeing a heavy
    coffe drinker, less sleep which does not really fit on me but sometimes does fit on me).

    awaiting input Matthias Pfeifer, germany

    - Confucius says: If there is necessety to message the author of this lines by email --- you better
    remove a-l-l numbers from mail.

  2. Matthias Pfeifer said:

    I am at good health and i am an avareg swimmer training 3times a week each about 3-4 km and 1-1.5h
    additionaly i do some running. So: at all i consider myself to be in a "damn good physical
    condition". Since i consider this to be enough to make able to dive 25m which i tend to train more
    or less regular but in about 90 percent i only do some three breast strokes and than feel like
    exploding. Also i dont see any light on the horizon (ie i dont seem to get a better diver).

    Is there some reason from daily life making me not to predestined for diving (like beeing a heavy
    coffe drinker, less sleep which does not

    Free diving is a different sport entirely - while good aerobic potential helps, it's the ability to
    resist the urge to breath while making the most efficient swimming motions that is key. Smokers can
    have an edge here because they're accustomed to higher levels of CO2, which is what drives the urge
    to breath. It's not the lack of oxygen.

    If you're pushing off the wall violently to get a head start, try instead to just drop into the
    water and slowly move. I'll take 40-50 seconds to cover that distance when I can do it successfully.

    --
    Jason O'Rourke www.jor.com

  3. I was wondering about this also. Does it help to hyperventilate before diving? How long can you
    resist the urge to breathe before you die? Do you see stars or something when you are passing out
    due to lack of oxygen?

    [email hidden] (Jason O'Rourke) wrote in message
    news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Matthias Pfeifer said:

    I am at good health and i am an avareg swimmer training 3times a week each about 3-4 km and
    1-1.5h additionaly i do some running. So: at all i consider myself to be in a "damn good physical
    condition". Since i consider this to be enough to make able to dive 25m which i tend to train
    more or less regular but in about 90 percent i only do some three breast strokes and than feel
    like exploding. Also i dont see any light on the horizon (ie i dont seem to get a better diver).

    Is there some reason from daily life making me not to predestined for diving (like beeing a heavy
    coffe drinker, less sleep which does not

    Free diving is a different sport entirely - while good aerobic potential helps, it's the ability
    to resist the urge to breath while making the most efficient swimming motions that is key. Smokers
    can have an edge here because they're accustomed to higher levels of CO2, which is what drives the
    urge to breath. It's not the lack of oxygen.

    If you're pushing off the wall violently to get a head start, try instead to just drop into the
    water and slowly move. I'll take 40-50 seconds to cover that distance when I can do it
    successfully.

  4. Jason O'Rourke said:

    Smokers can have an edge here because they're accustomed to higher levels of CO2, which is what
    drives the urge to breath. It's not the lack of oxygen.

    Yeah, right. Where did you pick up this "smoker's edge" theory?

  5. Dory said:

    I was wondering about this also. Does it help to hyperventilate before diving? How long can you
    resist the urge to breathe before you die? Do you see stars or something when you are passing out
    due to lack of oxygen?

    You can go several minutes without dying, but you might need to be revived with AR by someone else.
    For free divers that go to depth, this is a real problem. Coming up the partial pressure of oxygen
    drops and they can pass out (shallow water blackout). But in a pool, that isn't an issue.
    Hyperventilate all you want. Stay relaxed as long as possible, then thrash wildly when you think you
    can stand it anymore. 75ft can be achieved by most - I'm a pretty bad free diver and I can do it 1
    in 3 times or better.

    --
    Jason O'Rourke www.jor.com

  6. Chris said:
    Jason O'Rourke said:

    Smokers can have an edge here because they're accustomed to higher levels of CO2, which is what
    drives the urge to breath. It's not the lack of oxygen.

    Yeah, right. Where did you pick up this "smoker's edge" theory?

    It's pretty clearly spelled out.

    At the performance level we're talking about (25m, less than a minute), no one needs to breathe. We
    think we do, driven by the C02 reflex.

    If instead you want to talk about 5min dives to 100ft, that potential edge has been eliminated.

    --
    Jason O'Rourke www.jor.com

  7. In uk.sport.swimming Jason O'Rourke () said:
    Dory said:

    I was wondering about this also. Does it help to hyperventilate before diving? How long can you
    resist the urge to breathe before you die? Do you see stars or something when you are passing out
    due to lack of oxygen?

    You can go several minutes without dying, but you might need to be revived with AR by someone
    else. For free divers that go to depth, this is a real problem. Coming up the partial pressure of
    oxygen drops and they can pass out (shallow water blackout). But in a pool, that isn't an issue.
    Hyperventilate all you want. Stay relaxed as long as possible, then thrash wildly when you think
    you can stand it anymore. 75ft can be achieved by most - I'm a pretty bad free diver and I can do
    it 1 in 3 times or better.

    According to what I've read, one should be careful about hyperventilating, especially when not being
    watched. Hyperventilation increases carbondioxide removal from bodytissues, but does not actually
    increase the oxygencontent of blood, which means you can't ("shouldn't"😉 actually hold your breath
    any longer, it just feels that way. This can lead to the oxygen content of the blood reaching
    critically low levels before the carbondioxide buildup forces one to breathe, leading to a loss of
    consciousness.

    --
    _ // \X/ -- Michael Shuldman <[email hidden]

  8. Quoted message said:

    You can go several minutes without dying, but you might need to be revived with AR by someone
    else. For free divers that go to depth, this is a real problem. Coming up the partial pressure of
    oxygen drops and they can pass out (shallow water blackout). But in a pool, that isn't an issue.
    Hyperventilate all you want. Stay relaxed as

    Under NO circumstances hyperventilate since this will drop your CO2-content in the blood leading to
    a later urge to breathe which will let you swim underwater longer. However there are no receptors
    which tell you when youir oxygen content is all used up and you will suddenly become unconscious
    without any warning or prior symptoms which is also called the pool-black-out. Your will drown then
    if not watched. Most people think by hyperventilation they can increase their Oxygen content in the
    blood but this is an error since at normal conditions your blood (or better said erytrocytes) are
    already satured by 98% with oxygen, so hyperventilation will not increase this level. Better said,
    hyperventilation is likely to kill you by sudden unconsciousness due to the lack of oxygen!

    Note that the shallow water blackout is something different from the pool-black-out!

    Don't do that and always have a pal staying outside the pool watching you while you dive since when
    you suppress the urge to breathe you can also suffer from sudden unconsciousness!

    Marc

    Quoted message said:


    --
    ***************************************************************************
    * Gravitation can not be held responsible for people falling in love *
    * (Albert Einstein) *
    ***************************************************************************

  9. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Quoted message said:

    Note that the shallow water blackout is something different from the pool-black-out!

    Don't do that and always have a pal staying outside the pool watching you while you dive since when
    you suppress the urge to breathe you can also suffer from sudden unconsciousness!

    Remember again the context - swimming 25m. But I'll accept your warning that pool black outs can
    happen too, and yes, if one is pushing it they shouldn't do it alone. I do think taking 2 or 3
    breaths before the start is safe enough to do.

    --
    Jason O'Rourke www.jor.com

  10. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Don't do that and always have a pal staying outside the pool watching you while you dive since
    when you suppress the urge to breathe you can also suffer from sudden unconsciousness!

    Remember again the context - swimming 25m. But I'll accept your warning that pool black outs can
    happen too, and yes, if one is pushing it they shouldn't do it alone. I do think taking 2 or 3
    breaths before the start is safe enough to do.

    Hey Jason,

    being a life-guard instructor for some years now at the German Life-Saving Federation (DLRG) I have
    also experienced pool black outs whilst swimming 25m under water where I had to pull peeps out of
    the water immediately. I cannot stress this enough to be careful doing diving since people manage to
    suppress the urge to breathe pretty well as they told me afterwards.

    Taking three deep breaths is accepted and should not do any harm. I think more important is
    hyperventilation or the suppression of the urge to breathe which will result in a black out.

    Cheers,

    Marc

    Quoted message said:


    --
    ***************************************************************************
    * Gravitation can not be held responsible for people falling in love *
    * (Albert Einstein) *
    ***************************************************************************

    Marc-Andre Golombeck, Dipl.-Phys.,

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.