cole mecray said:
.... My post was based on my own
experience and the experience of other people that I know.
But there's a problem with that:
Quoted message said:I am a triathlete and marathon runner and there is no way I could
train the way I do without eating carbs.
Marathon training is different from other levels of training -
The first runner after the battle of marathon died because of
his run. Thus any opinions based on what works for
marathoners are utterly irrelevant and useless if extended
to folks not doing marathon training.
Sure, marathon runners eat plenty of carbs. So what. It
does not apply at all to folks not training for marathons and
tends to be counterproductive.
Quoted message said:It's simply not a good long term option for me.
For *you*. Correct. Don't generalize unless that generalization
makes sense. Feel free to generalize to other marathoners,
and for that matter to athletes in other sports that are based on
fatal activities rendered non-lethal by way of specialized
training regimens.
Quoted message said:I have lost 50lbs, and am under 5% body fat.
For normal humans that level of body fat is not healthy.
For folks trying to exit obesity it's irrelevant and advice aimed
at going from normal weight ranges to to level is worse than
irrelevant.
Quoted message said:I am also a personal trainer and I do recommend that overweight people
control their carb intake and do a few weeks of low carbs to help with
insulin resistance.
Right. Low carb works to the normal weight ranges. It works
for folks who've built up to century bike rides as level but who
still stay under 100 grams per day, but even the century bike
ride level needs to drive folks to up their carbs.
Quoted message said:In addition, my feeling about some of the technical points you posted
is as follows:
Your body will only store fat to the extent that you are consuming
calories in excess of your body's needs.
Calories work moderately well as an approximation, but storing
excess fat is based on the hormones that drive it not on exact
calorie counts.
Quoted message said:If you are lethargic, you
are probably low blood sugar and your body needs more calories at that
particular moment in time.
True.
Quoted message said:Combining good quality carbs with foods
high in protein should slow down the insulin response and allow your
body to process the foods efficiently.
Where "good quality carbs" generally equals veggies form the low
carb list and are thus low carb.
Quoted message said:I have been successful on a diet high in protein and healthy carbs
that is low in fat.
Consistant with being a marathoner.