General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Cooking with biodiesel.

Started by Ian Stirling · · Last activity · 9 posts · 684 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
23 May 2006
Last activity
25 May 2006
Original author
Ian Stirling
Posts
9
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
684
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–9 of 9
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

  2. Ian Stirling said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

    I believe the flash point is way too low. I also dunno what the stuff
    tastes like.

    Bob

  3. Ian Stirling schrieb:

    Quoted message said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    Researchers from the University of Hohenheim (Germany) have
    recently developed a stove (named Protos) that runs on vegetable oil.
    If I understand the article correctly, the secret is
    a tube that vaporized the oil before it is burned.

    http://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/mensch/0,1518,413807,00.html
    http://www.uni-hohenheim.de/i3v/00217110/01525041.htm

    Goran Jovanovic from the Oregon State University invented
    a tiny reactor ("about the size of a credit card"😉 that turns
    vegetable oil into biodiesel.

    http://www.forbes.com/work/feeds/ap/2006/04/19/ap2681244.html
    http://www.mccookgazette.com/story/1152821.html

    Regards,
    Joachim

  4. In article <[email hidden]>,

    zxcvbob said:
    Quoted message said:

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

    I believe the flash point is way too low. I also dunno what the stuff
    tastes like.

    The flash point is somewhere between 210 and 570 degrees F (100-300
    degrees C), depending on the organic source of the oil and the
    purity of the refined fuel. I've heard that it tastes awful. But at
    least it's non-toxic!

    sd

  5. Ian Stirling said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

    I'd be most concerned with the methanol group coming off during
    metabolism. It's a CH3-COO-R, right? It might cause some damage.

    Biodiesel is also a great solvent. (I used some to remove marker
    stains.) No telling what that great solvent will do to the cells
    lining your mouth and esophagus...

    Biodiesel also smells pretty funny - not at all like vegetable oil.
    (At least, the stuff that I make... 😉

    Oh, and it's VERY flammable. Much, much, much more so than vegetable
    oil.

  6. Quoted message said:


    Ian Stirling said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

    I'd be most concerned with the methanol group coming off during
    metabolism. It's a CH3-COO-R, right? It might cause some damage.

    Biodiesel is also a great solvent. (I used some to remove marker
    stains.) No telling what that great solvent will do to the cells
    lining your mouth and esophagus...

    Biodiesel also smells pretty funny - not at all like vegetable oil.
    (At least, the stuff that I make... 😉

    Oh, and it's VERY flammable. Much, much, much more so than vegetable
    oil.

    of course its different. its the methyl ester of some single straight
    chain alkane, rather than the glycerine ester of three straight chain
    alkanes.

    consider methyl decanoate versus tridecanoic glycerolate. (my
    apologies to UIPAC).

    considering taste? i'd go for the TDG as the tasty one...

  7. zxcvbob said:
    Ian Stirling said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?

    I believe the flash point is way too low. I also dunno what the stuff
    tastes like.

    Bob

    Some time ago, during a backpacking trip, my dinner bowl became
    contaminated by the nonvolatile residue left behind after some spilled
    cooking fuel (white gas?) evaporated away. It tasted like soap, even
    at very low concentration. I can't imagine how horrible food would
    taste if it had been fryed in biodiesel.

    Dave

  8. In sci.chem beav said:
    Quoted message said:


    Ian Stirling said:

    Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.

    The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.

    Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?


    <snip>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Biodiesel also smells pretty funny - not at all like vegetable oil.
    (At least, the stuff that I make... 😉

    Oh, and it's VERY flammable. Much, much, much more so than vegetable
    oil.

    Quoted message said:

    of course its different. its the methyl ester of some single straight
    chain alkane, rather than the glycerine ester of three straight chain
    alkanes.

    consider methyl decanoate versus tridecanoic glycerolate. (my
    apologies to UIPAC).

    considering taste? i'd go for the TDG as the tasty one...

    Thanks all - somehow I'd become confused on the chemistry, and thought
    that the methanol was merely a sort-of-catalyst, that ended up
    contaminating the drained off glycerine, and was not present in the
    product.

    Though I note that ethanol can be used in place of it - with much
    nastier process control and conditions though.
    May be a bonus in some outlets if it is metabolised 🙂

  9. Ian Stirling said:
    In sci.chem beav said:
    Quoted message said:

    Ian Stirling wrote:
    > Cooking in oil that has been used a long time is unhealthy, due to the
    > amount of free fatty acids that build up in the oil.
    >
    > The process of making biodiesel removes these free fatty acids, and
    > converts them to a form that can be removed by washing the oil.
    > Washed biodiesel has no free methanol, near zero FFA, and no NaoH.
    >
    > Can you then, instead of putting the biodiesel in a vehicle, simply
    > replace it back in the deep fryer, and cook with it?


    <snip>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Biodiesel also smells pretty funny - not at all like vegetable oil.
    (At least, the stuff that I make... 😉

    Oh, and it's VERY flammable. Much, much, much more so than vegetable
    oil.

    Quoted message said:

    of course its different. its the methyl ester of some single straight
    chain alkane, rather than the glycerine ester of three straight chain
    alkanes.

    consider methyl decanoate versus tridecanoic glycerolate. (my
    apologies to UIPAC).

    considering taste? i'd go for the TDG as the tasty one...

    Thanks all - somehow I'd become confused on the chemistry, and thought
    that the methanol was merely a sort-of-catalyst, that ended up
    contaminating the drained off glycerine, and was not present in the
    product.

    Though I note that ethanol can be used in place of it - with much
    nastier process control and conditions though.
    May be a bonus in some outlets if it is metabolised 🙂

    Excess methanol ends up in the glycerin, along with traces of soap, and
    the sodium ends up down there too but I don't know in what form (perhaps
    as soap.) The process uses excess alcohol to encourage it to go to
    completion. Large processors recover the waste methanol; it's easier to
    distill out than is ethanol.

    The chemicals in methyl ester biodiesel are considered safe by the FDA,
    and I believe they have some use as food additives. Tests with rats
    show that methyl biodiesel is nontoxic. That doesn't mean it's good for
    cooking, but you are unlikely to poison yourself.

    Bob

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.