Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Friction Shifter cable housing

Started by Peter Howard · · Last activity · 8 posts · 499 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
30 March 2008
Last activity
1 April 2008
Original author
Peter Howard
Posts
8
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
499
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–8 of 8
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I have just fitted friction barcons to one of my bikes. They are a new copy
    of an original Suntour item and they work beautifully. When I first looked
    at the cable housing supplied I thought "This isn't so hot!" because it was
    ordinary spiral wound stuff like brake cable housing. On further reflection,
    I figured out that non-indexed shifters don't need compressionless housing
    because there isn't any precise adjustment of cable length that needs to be
    preserved. That's a plus for me because I don't possess shears that will cut
    compressionless housing. I use a Dremel cutting wheel and it is a tedious
    pain to cut it square.

    Question One: Just to make sure, I'm asking if there should be anything
    special about housing used for non-indexed shifters or can I use the normal
    good quality plastic lined housing I keep in bulk for brake cables?

    April 1st is the date of the Canberra, Australia Sheldon Brown Memorial
    Ride. I can't be there because it's 1500 miles away but I commemorated
    Sheldon in my own way last night by lacing up my first ever pair of bicycle
    wheels. I was armed with a Park tensiometer and spoke key, a Minoura truing
    stand and dish stick and a printed copy of Sheldons wheelbuilding
    instructions. The wheels just fell together almost of their own accord and
    came up true, and on the rear wheel correctly dished and with the expected
    tension differential between DS and NDS. Time will tell, but I feel they're
    pretty good for a first attempt.

    Question Two: The rims are from Velocity and the front one has a slight
    irregularity on the braking surface where the splice is. It's not a step,
    just a slightly raised roughness. This manifests itself as a tick-tick-tick
    every time it goes past the brake shoes. Should I attack this irregularity
    with emery cloth or should I ignore it?

    Peter H.

  2. On Mar 30, 7:11 am, "Peter Howard" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I have just fitted friction barcons to one of my bikes.<snip>


    I'm asking if there should be anything

    Quoted message said:

    special about housing used for non-indexed shifters or can I use the normal
    good quality plastic lined housing ..

    Shimano barcons came with metal (stainless steel?), spiral wound,
    unlined cables. I've set them up with ordinary brake cable, and with
    the stronger cable used for index shifting. You can use either for
    friction shifting.

    Best,
    Larry

  3. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Peter Howard said:

    Question One: Just to make sure, I'm asking if there should be anything
    special about housing used for non-indexed shifters or can I use the normal
    good quality plastic lined housing I keep in bulk for brake cables?

    Friction shifters offer stepless control of derailleur position.
    However positional control is still at the shifter and not at the
    derailleur. If you do not use the constant-length shift-specific cable
    housing, any change in housing length will still deviate your preset
    position, causing the derailleur to "chatter". Granted, that
    misalignment can be easily fixed by micro-shifting the friction shifter
    (unlike indexed systems), but why not use the right housing?

    Quoted message said:

    Question Two: The rims are from Velocity and the front one has a slight
    irregularity on the braking surface where the splice is. It's not a step,
    just a slightly raised roughness. This manifests itself as a tick-tick-tick
    every time it goes past the brake shoes. Should I attack this irregularity
    with emery cloth or should I ignore it?

    Either is fine. My preference would be to sand it smooth (because I
    don't ride much in rain) because I would be annoyed by the noise.

  4. "Peter Howard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Question One: Just to make sure, I'm asking if there should be anything
    special about housing used for non-indexed shifters or can I use the
    normal good quality plastic lined housing I keep in bulk for brake
    cables?


    Brake cable housing is fine. Shifters always used spiral wound housing until
    the advent of indexed gearing.

    Quoted message said:

    Question Two: The rims are from Velocity and the front one has a slight
    irregularity on the braking surface where the splice is. It's not a step,
    just a slightly raised roughness. This manifests itself as a
    tick-tick-tick every time it goes past the brake shoes. Should I attack
    this irregularity with emery cloth or should I ignore it?


    Just ignore it and after a few weeks/months the brake blocks will do the
    smoothing job for you.

    Nick

  5. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Peter Howard said:

    I have just fitted friction barcons to one of my bikes. They are a new copy
    of an original Suntour item and they work beautifully. When I first looked
    at the cable housing supplied I thought "This isn't so hot!" because it was
    ordinary spiral wound stuff like brake cable housing. On further reflection,
    I figured out that non-indexed shifters don't need compressionless housing
    because there isn't any precise adjustment of cable length that needs to be
    preserved. That's a plus for me because I don't possess shears that will cut
    compressionless housing. I use a Dremel cutting wheel and it is a tedious
    pain to cut it square.

    Question One: Just to make sure, I'm asking if there should be anything
    special about housing used for non-indexed shifters or can I use the normal
    good quality plastic lined housing I keep in bulk for brake cables?

    All cable housing is suitable for friction shifters.

    Quoted message said:

    April 1st is the date of the Canberra, Australia Sheldon Brown Memorial
    Ride. I can't be there because it's 1500 miles away but I commemorated
    Sheldon in my own way last night by lacing up my first ever pair of bicycle
    wheels. I was armed with a Park tensiometer and spoke key, a Minoura truing
    stand and dish stick and a printed copy of Sheldons wheelbuilding
    instructions. The wheels just fell together almost of their own accord and
    came up true, and on the rear wheel correctly dished and with the expected
    tension differential between DS and NDS. Time will tell, but I feel they're
    pretty good for a first attempt.

    Congratulations.

    Quoted message said:

    Question Two: The rims are from Velocity and the front one has a slight
    irregularity on the braking surface where the splice is. It's not a step,
    just a slightly raised roughness. This manifests itself as a tick-tick-tick
    every time it goes past the brake shoes. Should I attack this irregularity
    with emery cloth or should I ignore it?

    Take it down with fine emery cloth.
    You will be the happier for it.

    --
    Michael Press

  6. On Mar 30, 6:11 am, "Peter Howard" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Question Two: The rims are from Velocity and the front one has a slight
    irregularity on the braking surface where the splice is. It's not a step,
    just a slightly raised roughness. This manifests itself as a tick-tick-tick
    every time it goes past the brake shoes. Should I attack this irregularity
    with emery cloth or should I ignore it?

    Park rim joint cloth, #500 grit.

  7. On Sun, 30 Mar 2008 15:27:39 -0700, Michael Press <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    All cable housing is suitable for friction shifters.

    My thoughts too.

    The issue I have had is with OD of brake cable housing and shift line
    fittings.

  8. "Peter Howard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...
    had some <snipped> questions.

    Thanks to all for the replies re friction shifter housing. I think I saw a
    general consensus emerging.

    BTW, the problem with roughness at the rim splice causing braking noise
    cured itself in two days with no intervention from me.

    Peter H.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.