I'd have to say, it looks to have failed the 'smell' test.
Considering the "I'll know it when I see it" standard of pass/fail, I'm
surprised they even bothered to hear the case, much less rule against
Tyler.
When you consider that they'd been in contact w/Tyler all summer and
had warned him of blood irregularities, it seems so unlikely that he'd
actually flaunt it by going ahead w/ monthly 100cc booster transfusions
(as one expert alleged it looked like he must have done).
Looks like he got screwed.