hasa r1 2010 or 2010 claud bulter roubaix? or vinceza

[spotzen]

am getting back to road cycling and am looking for input as to which is the better buy? prices are close enough to not matter but interested if any1 has riden either of these bikes? I already use a giant upland for commuting and want something lighter for distance riding but has been awhile since I had to purchase a road bike.
any thoughts / comments welcome

thanks