Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Headlight Recommendations

Started by Jay Beattie · · Last activity · 105 posts · 1,970 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
3 August 2007
Last activity
18 August 2007
Original author
Jay Beattie
Posts
105
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,970
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 41–60 of 105
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. aka Frank Krygowski said:
    Tom \'Johnny Sunset\' Sherman said:


    Yes, a hub dynamo and a battery high power halogen would work, but the
    wiring gets cumbersome since the light needs to be mounted on the boom
    in front of one's feet, with the switch on the handlebars.

    Wow. I'd have thought that a dedicated recumbent rider would be used
    to the extra fiddling it takes to mount "ordinary bike" accessories on
    his machine!

    Yehbut, I'm lazy. 😉

    --
    Tom Sherman - Holstein-Friesland Bovinia
    The weather is here, wish you were beautiful

    --
    Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

  2. aka Frank Krygowski said:
    Tom \'Johnny Sunset\' Sherman said:
    aka Frank Krygowski said:

    On Aug 6, 10:52 pm, "Tom \"Johnny Sunset\" Sherman"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:
    > [email hidden] aka Frank Krygowski wrote:
    >> ...
    >> Of course, the current amount of light works extremely well for the
    >> vast majority of the world's nighttime cyclists. It's only the non-
    >> cycling countries - like the US - where many people think they need to
    >> look like a supernova.
    > I want to look like a motorcycle to motorized traffic, and I want the
    > light output of a motorcycle headlight when descending at motorcycle
    > type speeds.
    Sorry, but if you don't plan on using motorcycle-duty wheels, tires
    and brakes, it's not very sensible to say you need a motorcycle
    headlight.


    To the contrary, if the motorists think I am a motorcycle, they will
    assume I am going at a typical motorcycle speed and not cut me off. If
    they think bicycle, they will think I am going less than 10 mph and cut
    me off. Happens quite often. 🙁

    Those sorts of statements always amaze me. When I ride at night,
    motorists always give me more consideration, not less. I've been
    amazed many times by motorists that wait, and wait, and wait for me to
    pass before turning left across my path, or pulling out from a stop
    sign, when they obviously could have safely done so much earlier.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Bicycles are all about efficiency - about having exactly the
    appropriate level of capability for the job. That's why the rubber on
    our tires isn't half an inch thick, even though our thin tires get
    some flats. That's why our spokes are less than a millimeter thick,
    not 3 or 4 millimeters. That's why your bike's frame weighs less than
    5 pounds, not 25 pounds or more. Why should a cyclist violate this
    principle regarding lights?
    You're not on a motorcycle. Unless you're _extremely_ unusual, you
    don't approach intersections at 50 mph, and need to warn motorists at
    stop signs 300 feet away. You don't do 70 on the freeway, or on
    winding country roads. You simply don't need a headlight that is
    appropriate for those conditions.


    Every ride in a hilly area on a fast lowracer or fully-faired recumbent
    at night? Motorcycle type speeds are easily obtained going downhill, and
    a 3W dynamo light is not going to cut it.

    Well, no, I haven't. The only really low machine I have is a trike
    built on a low racer pattern. Frankly, it's not something I enjoy
    riding.

    If you really do attain speeds of, say, 25+ mph at night with any
    regularity, you'll probably need more than a good generator light.
    But even then, something at moped level should do it. You're still
    not on a crotch rocket, or even a touring motorcycle.

    Quoted message said:

    Now if you are talking about riding around the city at normal cycle
    speeds (15-40 kph), yes, a good hub dynamo and light with decent optics
    is adequate if you allow for stupid motorists cutting you off when
    pulling out of cross-streets and driveways.

    Again, that's literally never been a problem. I've been cut off a few
    times by motorists who didn't see me in daylight. Twice in one
    memorable day, in fact - and astonishingly, both apologized
    profusely.

    Since it's never happened in darkness, and since instead I've gotten
    spontaneous compliments on my nighttime conspicuity, I feel sure my
    lighting/reflector system is doing its job.

    I have been cut off that way many times when riding a bicycle, both in
    daylight and darkness.

    Of course, I have had the same thing happen when driving a medium duty
    commercial truck that would crush a Hummer, so there is no fool-proof
    solution.

    --
    Tom Sherman - Holstein-Friesland Bovinia
    The weather is here, wish you were beautiful

    --
    Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

  3. SMS said:
    Tom 'Johnny Sunset' Sherman said:
    SMS aka Steven M. Scharf said:

    ...
    I don't dislike or like them. I have some dynamo lights. They are
    fine for use in certain circumstances, certainly in bicycle-friendly
    places, like the Netherlands, they are often sufficient....

    What is the outlook for fuel cell powered lights? I don't care for any
    of the lights currently on the market, as they are either limited in
    output or runtime. 🙁

    No they're not, you just have to be willing to haul around enough
    batteries to get the run-time and output you need.

    Look at what RC airplanes use if you want to know what the currently
    available lightest, highest output power source is. Right now, it's
    Li-Po batteries. I haven't seen any bicycle lights with Li-Po yet,
    though Li-Ion is more and more common.

    Personally, I'd be willing to have a more powerful dynamo than the
    commonly available 3W, and somewhat less available 6W models. A 12W
    dynamo would be sufficient to power satisfactory lights for most
    commuters, and on a commute the extra commute time might not be such a
    big deal. Even 9W might be sufficient.

    I've been riding with Li-po batteries for at least two years now. At 63%
    of the weight of NiMh it's the way to go. Not much difference in price
    these days too.

    Dorfus

  4. On 6 Aug., 19:00, SMS <[email hidden]> wrote:

    SMS skrev:

    Quoted message said:

    North Carolina Bicycle Coalition
    http://www.humantransport.org/bicycledriving/library/lights/lights.htm
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    ...a cyclist operating at 15 mph can see well enough with less than 600
    candlepower (e.g. 12 watt halogen), and a cyclist operating at 7.5 mph
    can see far enough in with less than 150 candlepower (e.g. 3 watt
    halogen). The light provided by a bicycle headlamp may be focused into a
    narrow beam for maximum range, or may be spread out for better
    peripheral vision. A three watt lamp can be focused into a beam suitable
    for high speed cycling on the darkest roads, but will not give much
    illumination of turns. North Carolina Bicycle Coalition

    The numbers quoted doesn't make sense. They seem to claim that a 3
    watt halogen lamp (like a dynamo driven headlight) only gives a meager
    150 candelas. But the German magazine "Aktive Radfahren" 1-2/05 (the
    guys who also does the respected "Tour" magazine) made an thorough
    test of 7 dynamo headlights and 7 battery operated headlights. My
    choice of dynamo frontlight, the "B&M Lumotec Oval Senso Plus" was
    measured to 13,5 lux. The battery operated Cateye EL-500G was also
    measured to 13,5 lux at 10 meters distance, but the Cateye alledgedly
    gives out more than 1000 candelas? How come a 3 watt halogen
    headlight, who your "expert" claims gives out 150 candela, is just as
    strong as a 1000 candela headlight? Furthermore I know the Cateye 500G
    model quite well, and on paper it may be measured as bright as my B&M
    2,4 watt halogen headlight, but it is only bright in a small spot,
    while my halogen light casts a generous flood light over a large area,
    so in practise, the dynamodriven headlight is vastly superior.

    In the test, no headlight operated with internal battery could beat
    the best dynamo driven headlight.

    Quoted message said:

    Sacramento Area Bicycle Advocates
    (http://www.sacbike.org/articles/article.php?mode=display&lognum=17)
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    "If you want to cycle at low speeds in areas with street lights, other
    ambient lighting, or when there's a full moon on a cloudless night, a
    low wattage light is OK. If you actually want to see obstacles in darker
    areas, you need a more powerful light, from 10 to 30 watts or more.

    That "expert" has never tried a hubdynamo lightning system for sure,
    and doesn't even seem to have tried to ride on a unlit road, because,
    as you allready know, "low" wattage systems are really good in pitch
    black conditions, as another of your "experts" also says.
    I am not a fast commuter, and rarely does more than 35 km/h, but I
    can go full speed down a unlit packed gravel road with lots of
    potholes without any problems with my dynamolight.

    I have absolutely no respect for your so called "experts", who doesn't
    seem to have any accredited education relevant for being bicycle
    lights expert, or quote any source at all to back up their claims. The
    facts just flies in the face of their claims.

    --
    Regards
    Peter S.

  5. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Jay Beattie said:

    Hey, when its foggy, raining, dark -- and I'm sliding down some goat
    trail on my way home through the hills, I want as much f****** light
    as I can get. I'm old. My eyesight sucks. I don't care if it is too
    much light in some metaphysical sense.

    Assuming you mean that you're riding offroad, you'll find that generator
    lights are not good in that setting. Battery powered lights work much
    better off road because light output is not affected by riding speed.

    One issue about eyesight is night vision. Many people have poor night
    vision. An overly bright headlight can actually worsen night vision by
    overlighting close objects. Few if any really bright headlights have
    good optics for cycling. IMHO B&M Lumotec and Schmidt E6 have the best
    optics for use as a cycling light- the beam is brighter at the top which
    shines further down the road, resulting in a long, evenly illuminated
    pool of light and avoiding overlighting things up close.

  6. On Aug 7, 6:36 pm, Crescentius Vespasianus <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I have a EL530 bought for one bike I'm building, the regulated output is
    nice but I don't know I like the beam shape (a round tight center spot
    with wide spill). But as the EL-500 is discontinued I suppose half that
    decision is already made. The EL500 was the best cheapie headlight
    around a year ago.

    ------------------
    Is the el-530 brighter than the 500?
    Can you put the spot farther out with
    the 530 than you can the 500? As you
    know if you put the spot on the 500 too
    far out you don't see any illumination.

    The EL-530's spot is brighter than the EL-500, but the spot is a tiny
    round dot in comparison to the already small EL-500 pattern. However,
    the two go well together, e.g. with the 530's spot pointed just beyond
    the two "cat ears" in the 500's pattern. Given the choice though, I'd
    rather have two EL-500 than one of each (as I do now) or two EL-530.
    If I could have only one, I'd choose the EL-500.

    DougC, where did you get an EL-530 with regulated output? Is it a
    special, Euro version? Europe gets all the cool stuff :-(.

  7. Tom 'Johnny Sunset' Sherman said:

    To the contrary, if the motorists think I am a motorcycle, they will
    assume I am going at a typical motorcycle speed and not cut me off. If
    they think bicycle, they will think I am going less than 10 mph and cut
    me off. Happens quite often. 🙁

    That is precisely what I've found while commuting. I was constantly
    getting cut off with low-power lights, with vehicles exiting parking
    lots and driveways, and turning left in front of me. They just don't
    expect a bicycle to be going even 20 mph. With bright lights, especially
    the sealed beams on my commute bike (due to the large diameter), they yield.

    Quoted message said:

    Now if you are talking about riding around the city at normal cycle
    speeds (15-40 kph), yes, a good hub dynamo and light with decent optics
    is adequate if you allow for stupid motorists cutting you off when
    pulling out of cross-streets and driveways.

    40kph is 25mph, and is far too fast to not outrun 3W lights no matter
    what the power source. A vehicle turning in front of a bicycle is
    expecting you to be riding 5-10 mph because that's the speed they ride
    when out on the Huffy. 40kph is not "normal".

    In any case, the original poster is clear on what he's looking
    for--bright lights that will run for several hours. There are several
    options, all involving trade-offs of cost, weight, size, run-time, and
    lamp life.

    Steve
    "http://bicyclelighting.com"

  8. Jay Beattie said:

    Hey, when its foggy, raining, dark -- and I'm sliding down some goat
    trail on my way home through the hills, I want as much f****** light
    as I can get. I'm old. My eyesight sucks. I don't care if it is too
    much light in some metaphysical sense.

    Night vision declines with age, it's true. But it's not just about
    illuminating the road, it's about how vehicles perceive you when they
    see you approaching. On routes that riders are familiar with they
    probably could get by with 3W lights in terms of road illumination, but
    where a big safety issue occurs is how vehicles behave as you approach.
    Are you constantly yielding to vehicles that perceive you as a slow
    moving bicycle, or do they yield because they perceive you as something
    else? There's a huge difference in motorist behavior when you use bright
    lights.

    Quoted message said:

    I also don't know about modern generator lights -- mabye they're
    bright, but most people (including me) don't want to drop $400+ to
    find out (based on Peter White's prices for rim, spokes, hub, light).
    If I could test drive one of these things, I might consider it --
    except, again, I use two bikes -- one with a disc, so I can't just
    flip the wheels. -- Jay Beattie.

    Just buy multiple $400 systems! Actually, it's amazing how cheap those
    internal hub generators are when they are included in the bicycle from
    the bicycle manufacturer, though probably not much worse than other
    parts and accessories. Attend the Taipei International Cycle Show some
    time and get an idea of the very low prices that accessory manufacturers
    charge distributors for accessories. Bicycle shops also have good
    margins on accessories, unlike on complete bicycles.

    Dahon charges $130 (street) for their dynamo wheel. I may get one for my
    Dahon folder as I often use it as my "around town" bicycle.

    You can buy low-end dynamo lighting systems from
    "http://www.yellowjersey.org/lolite.html" and mid-range from
    "http://www.yellowjersey.org/dynamos.html". Not as nice as what Peter
    White sells, but much cheaper.

    Steve
    "http://bicyclelighting.com"
    Earth's Independent Source for Unbiased Bicycle Lighting Information

  9. Tom 'Johnny Sunset' Sherman said:
    aka Frank Krygowski said:

    ...
    Of course, the current amount of light works extremely well for the
    vast majority of the world's nighttime cyclists. It's only the non-
    cycling countries - like the US - where many people think they need to
    look like a supernova.

    I want to look like a motorcycle to motorized traffic, and I want the
    light output of a motorcycle headlight when descending at motorcycle
    type speeds.

    One thing I've found is that larger diameter headlights are also useful,
    not just extreme brightness.

    Relatively low wattage headlights, like the Malibu 14W LV504 (see
    http://www.nordicgroup.us/s78/images/img_0281.jpg) give the impression
    of a non-bicycle, even though they are a lot lower wattage than the
    typical high performance system. I often only use one lamp, and I may
    just change the setup to a single lamp, as 14W is really sufficient.
    These lamps are also available in 11 watt and 25 watt, and are very
    inexpensive and very light. The large reflector increases the efficiency
    as well, though they are only available in "flood". For my needs they're
    fine but I rarely go more than 25 mph while commuting.

    For $35 you can buy a lamp (Home Depot), a sealed-lead-acid battery
    (allelectronics.com), and a charger (harborfreight.com). Add a bit of
    wire, a fuse and holder, and a switch, and you're at around $40. Add a
    very bright xenon flashing tail light, and you're up to $50 (plus a
    couple of hours work) for a very good commute system. The lamp is so
    light that it's fine on even a plastic reflector bracket.

  10. In article <[email hidden]>,

    SMS said:
    Tom 'Johnny Sunset' Sherman said:

    To the contrary, if the motorists think I am a motorcycle, they
    will assume I am going at a typical motorcycle speed and not cut me
    off. If they think bicycle, they will think I am going less than 10
    mph and cut me off. Happens quite often. 🙁

    That is precisely what I've found while commuting. I was constantly
    getting cut off with low-power lights, with vehicles exiting parking
    lots and driveways, and turning left in front of me. They just don't
    expect a bicycle to be going even 20 mph. With bright lights,
    especially the sealed beams on my commute bike (due to the large
    diameter), they yield.

    My experience is the opposite. Drivers are far more aware of me and are
    far likelier to wait than they are during the day. Come to think of it,
    I've never had any driver pull out in front of me and cut me off at
    night. There are, of course, fewer opportunities as there are fewer
    drivers out after dark.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Now if you are talking about riding around the city at normal cycle
    speeds (15-40 kph), yes, a good hub dynamo and light with decent
    optics is adequate if you allow for stupid motorists cutting you
    off when pulling out of cross-streets and driveways.

    40kph is 25mph, and is far too fast to not outrun 3W lights no matter
    what the power source.

    Oh [censored]. Which orifice do you pull this stuff out of? I routinely
    exceed 35 mph on descents with a 3W B&M Lumotec lamp and have no trouble
    like this. I can see plenty far down the road.

    Quoted message said:

    A vehicle turning in front of a bicycle is
    expecting you to be riding 5-10 mph because that's the speed they
    ride when out on the Huffy. 40kph is not "normal".

    Depends on who you ride with, I guess.


  11. Quoted message said:

    I have a EL530 bought for one bike I'm building, the regulated output is
    nice but I don't know I like the beam shape (a round tight center spot
    with wide spill). But as the EL-500 is discontinued I suppose half that
    decision is already made. The EL500 was the best cheapie headlight
    around a year ago.


    ------------------
    Is the el-530 brighter than the 500?
    Can you put the spot farther out with
    the 530 than you can the 500? As you
    know if you put the spot on the 500 too
    far out you don't see any illumination.

  12. Tim McNamara said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Jay Beattie said:

    Hey, when its foggy, raining, dark -- and I'm sliding down some goat
    trail on my way home through the hills, I want as much f****** light
    as I can get. I'm old. My eyesight sucks. I don't care if it is too
    much light in some metaphysical sense.

    Assuming you mean that you're riding offroad, you'll find that generator
    lights are not good in that setting. Battery powered lights work much
    better off road because light output is not affected by riding speed.

    One issue about eyesight is night vision. Many people have poor night
    vision. An overly bright headlight can actually worsen night vision by
    overlighting close objects. Few if any really bright headlights have
    good optics for cycling. IMHO B&M Lumotec and Schmidt E6 have the best
    optics for use as a cycling light- the beam is brighter at the top which
    shines further down the road, resulting in a long, evenly illuminated
    pool of light and avoiding overlighting things up close.

    I want a fuel cell that can power something like this for several nights
    use without refueling: <http://www.piaa.com/Lamps/Lamp-pages/600hid.html>.

    --
    Tom Sherman - Holstein-Friesland Bovinia
    The weather is here, wish you were beautiful

    --
    Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

  13. "Tom "Johnny Sunset" Sherman" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I want a fuel cell that can power something like this for several nights
    use without refueling: <http://www.piaa.com/Lamps/Lamp-pages/600hid.html>.

    I want world peace :-)

    (at least yours stands some chance of happening at some point - but it'll be
    a while yet...)

    cheers,
    clive

  14. SMS said:
    Tom 'Johnny Sunset' Sherman said:

    To the contrary, if the motorists think I am a motorcycle, they will
    assume I am going at a typical motorcycle speed and not cut me off. If
    they think bicycle, they will think I am going less than 10 mph and cut
    me off. Happens quite often. 🙁

    That is precisely what I've found while commuting. I was constantly
    getting cut off with low-power lights, with vehicles exiting parking
    lots and driveways, and turning left in front of me. They just don't
    expect a bicycle to be going even 20 mph. With bright lights, especially
    the sealed beams on my commute bike (due to the large diameter), they yield.

    And again, I've literally never been cut off while riding at night.
    Daytime has been different, and at least one daytime incident required
    extreme evasion on my part to prevent a crash. But nighttime? Not
    once - and I've done bike commuting at night since 1978, plus
    occasional recreational rides and touring.

    Here's a trick you might try if you spot an impatient-looking driver
    approaching. ("Impatient" shows up in their speed, and in behaviors
    like late braking for a stop sign.) Simply wiggle your handlebars a
    bit side to side, quickly but slightly. The motion's the same as a
    "rock dodge" but not nearly so radical.

    As long as your headlamps are fastened to the handlebars or forks (not
    the bike's frame) this will flash your headlight in the driver's eye,
    to one degree or other.

    Understand, I seldom need to bother with this trick. But perhaps when
    I've used it, it's helped prevent the cut-offs you guys experience.

    - Frank Krygowski

  15. Clive George said:

    "Tom "Johnny Sunset" Sherman" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I want a fuel cell that can power something like this for several
    nights use without refueling:
    <http://www.piaa.com/Lamps/Lamp-pages/600hid.html>.

    I want world peace :-)

    (at least yours stands some chance of happening at some point - but
    it'll be a while yet...)

    With more and more functions being crammed into cell phones (to the
    point the phone is secondary), batteries are not going to cut it in the
    future. Similarly, the computer laptop would greatly benefit from fuel
    technology. These markets (unlike bicycle lights) are huge enough to pay
    for a lot of fuel cell R&D.

    --
    Tom Sherman - Holstein-Friesland Bovinia
    The weather is here, wish you were beautiful

    --
    Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

  16. Tim McNamara said:

    My experience is the opposite. Drivers are far more aware of me and are
    far likelier to wait than they are during the day. Come to think of it,
    I've never had any driver pull out in front of me and cut me off at
    night. There are, of course, fewer opportunities as there are fewer
    drivers out after dark.

    I definitely agree that at night the drivers are far likelier to wait,
    but it's because in the daytime they _know_ you're a bicycle, but at
    night, they just see a light coming and they have to judge the speed of
    the approaching light. When you have reasonably bright lights, even just
    10-15W, they are unsure whether it's a bicycles or something else. With
    low-power lights of 1-3W, they realize that it's a bicycle and they
    believe that bicycles are always going as slow as they ride.

    I'm sure it varies by region of the world as well. In the U.S., you
    definitely don't want to be riding 25mph at night with only 3 watt
    lights, while in the more civilized countries of western Europe it's
    probably adequate.

  17. Jay Beattie said:

    The days are getting shorter, which reminds me that I need to replace
    my headlight. Are there any new lights on the market that are worth
    looking at? I need something bright, but I don't need a super long
    burn time. A few hours is good enough. -- Jay Beattie.

    I don't know if you're into "rolling your own," but you can buy a
    self-contained HID lamp for from TrailTech (13W power consumption), see
    "http://trailtech.net/single_hid_mr11.html", a 14.8V Li-Po battery from
    "http://prodigybatteries.com/productlist/" and a Li-Po charger, and
    still be well under the cost for a commercial HID or dynamo lighting
    system. Three hours would need something like the 5AH battery. Of course
    the Li-Po battery is only needed if weight is a big issue, you can
    always use a heavier SLA battery for about 1/8th the cost of a Li-Po
    battery of similar capacity.

    Remember that you can get close to HID efficiency by simply
    over-voltaging a standard MR16 or MR11 lamp, the downside is reduced
    lamp life, but lamps are pretty inexpensive if you don't go running to a
    bike shop to buy them at $20 each.

    A very good system would be a 14.8V (four cell) Li-Po battery, a set of
    QH-7CC driving lights
    ("http://store.novatechgadgets.com/quhaofralioq.html"😉, and some 10W
    MR16 lamps to replace the 50W lamps
    ("http://www.harringtonlights.com/Specialty_Glass/mr16_low_wattage.htm"😉.

    Also, remember to not confuse watts with lumens, as the relationship has
    changed a lot over the years, and is dependent not only on power, but on
    optics and lamp efficiency. The lumens per watt of a 20% over-voltaged
    MR16 is actually greater than that of a commercial HID systems with the
    smaller lamps. Optics make a difference, and the precision matched
    reflector/bulb of the MR16 and MR11 lamps are the best option for
    bicycle lights (which is why most high-end bicycle lights use them).
    With a separate bulb and reflector, the bulb is not precisely
    positioned, which wastes power (even turning the bulb can change the
    efficiency).

    It all depends on how much you want to spend, how much weight you want
    to carry, how bright you need the lights to be, and how much work you
    want to do yourself.

    Steve
    "http://bicyclelighting.com"
    Earth's Independent Source for Unbiased Bicycle Lighting Information

  18. SMS said:
    Tim McNamara said:

    My experience is the opposite. Drivers are far more aware of me and are
    far likelier to wait than they are during the day. Come to think of it,
    I've never had any driver pull out in front of me and cut me off at
    night. There are, of course, fewer opportunities as there are fewer
    drivers out after dark.

    I definitely agree that at night the drivers are far likelier to wait,
    but it's because in the daytime they _know_ you're a bicycle, but at
    night, they just see a light coming and they have to judge the speed of
    the approaching light. When you have reasonably bright lights, even just
    10-15W, they are unsure whether it's a bicycles or something else. With
    low-power lights of 1-3W, they realize that it's a bicycle and they
    believe that bicycles are always going as slow as they ride.

    All very nice in theory. But as I've explained, I've seen them wait
    for me much longer in at night than in daylight. In some cases,
    they've waited amazingly long times. And they've _never_ cut me off
    at night. That's with my 3 Watt generator headlights.

    Quoted message said:


    I'm sure it varies by region of the world as well. In the U.S., you
    definitely don't want to be riding 25mph at night with only 3 watt
    lights, while in the more civilized countries of western Europe it's
    probably adequate.

    Of course, I do live in the U.S.

    - Frank Krygowski

  19. Crescentius Vespasianus said:


    Quoted message said:

    I have a EL530 bought for one bike I'm building, the regulated output
    is nice but I don't know I like the beam shape (a round tight center
    spot with wide spill). But as the EL-500 is discontinued I suppose
    half that decision is already made. The EL500 was the best cheapie
    headlight around a year ago.


    ------------------
    Is the el-530 brighter than the 500? Can you put the spot farther out
    with the 530 than you can the 500? As you know if you put the spot on
    the 500 too far out you don't see any illumination.

    There is a comparison chart, of sorts, at
    "http://www.cateye.com/sites/cateye/upload/product_charts/LightPOPfront.pdf".

    You really want to be comparing lumens, not candlepower, for lighting.
    There is a good explanation of the difference at
    "http://www.stkildacycles.com.au/products_lightsSafety.htm".

    Even though many people still use watts for comparison, and I slip into
    that myself occasionally, it's really inaccurate especially with HID
    lamps. Also, the LED lights tend to have high candlepower ratings, but
    low lumen ratings, due to their inherent characteristics, which of
    course is why they're comparing candlepower on the CatEye site.

    The EL-5xx series is really for "being seen". Four AA batteries aren't
    going to power any sufficiently bright light for very long.

    One of the big advantages of incandescent lamps is that with good optics
    and reflectors you can really boost the lumen output. This is why all
    the high-end lighting systems use the precision matched MR type of bulb
    and reflector.

    Steve
    "http://bicyclelighting.com"
    Earth's Independent Source for Unbiased Bicycle Lighting Information

  20. "SMS" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    One of the big advantages of incandescent lamps is that with good optics
    and reflectors you can really boost the lumen output. This is why all the
    high-end lighting systems use the precision matched MR type of bulb and
    reflector.

    Do these MR bulbs produce a beam optimised for riding, or something simpler?

    cheers,
    clive

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.