On 6 Aug., 19:00, SMS <[email hidden]> wrote:
SMS skrev:
Quoted message said:North Carolina Bicycle Coalition
http://www.humantransport.org/bicycledriving/library/lights/lights.htm
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
...a cyclist operating at 15 mph can see well enough with less than 600
candlepower (e.g. 12 watt halogen), and a cyclist operating at 7.5 mph
can see far enough in with less than 150 candlepower (e.g. 3 watt
halogen). The light provided by a bicycle headlamp may be focused into a
narrow beam for maximum range, or may be spread out for better
peripheral vision. A three watt lamp can be focused into a beam suitable
for high speed cycling on the darkest roads, but will not give much
illumination of turns. North Carolina Bicycle Coalition
The numbers quoted doesn't make sense. They seem to claim that a 3
watt halogen lamp (like a dynamo driven headlight) only gives a meager
150 candelas. But the German magazine "Aktive Radfahren" 1-2/05 (the
guys who also does the respected "Tour" magazine) made an thorough
test of 7 dynamo headlights and 7 battery operated headlights. My
choice of dynamo frontlight, the "B&M Lumotec Oval Senso Plus" was
measured to 13,5 lux. The battery operated Cateye EL-500G was also
measured to 13,5 lux at 10 meters distance, but the Cateye alledgedly
gives out more than 1000 candelas? How come a 3 watt halogen
headlight, who your "expert" claims gives out 150 candela, is just as
strong as a 1000 candela headlight? Furthermore I know the Cateye 500G
model quite well, and on paper it may be measured as bright as my B&M
2,4 watt halogen headlight, but it is only bright in a small spot,
while my halogen light casts a generous flood light over a large area,
so in practise, the dynamodriven headlight is vastly superior.
In the test, no headlight operated with internal battery could beat
the best dynamo driven headlight.
Quoted message said:Sacramento Area Bicycle Advocates
(http://www.sacbike.org/articles/article.php?mode=display&lognum=17)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"If you want to cycle at low speeds in areas with street lights, other
ambient lighting, or when there's a full moon on a cloudless night, a
low wattage light is OK. If you actually want to see obstacles in darker
areas, you need a more powerful light, from 10 to 30 watts or more.
That "expert" has never tried a hubdynamo lightning system for sure,
and doesn't even seem to have tried to ride on a unlit road, because,
as you allready know, "low" wattage systems are really good in pitch
black conditions, as another of your "experts" also says.
I am not a fast commuter, and rarely does more than 35 km/h, but I
can go full speed down a unlit packed gravel road with lots of
potholes without any problems with my dynamolight.
I have absolutely no respect for your so called "experts", who doesn't
seem to have any accredited education relevant for being bicycle
lights expert, or quote any source at all to back up their claims. The
facts just flies in the face of their claims.
--
Regards
Peter S.