UK and Europe · Public discussion

help with frame size

Started by pingin · · Last activity · 11 posts · 572 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
UK and Europe
Published
7 March 2005
Last activity
8 March 2005
Original author
pingin
Posts
11
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
572
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–11 of 11
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hi all,

    I'd like to buy a Marin bike. I live in France but unfortunately Marin
    is not really distributed here so I'm going to buy one from abroad - so
    I need to buy it without actually trying. This is not ideal I realise
    so I'm hoping that someone can help me diminish the risk factor of
    buying blind.

    Here's a link to the bike:
    http://www.marin.co.uk/marin-2005/bikedetail.php?ModNo=2515

    and here's a copy-paste of the frame geometry:

    13" 15" 17" 18.5" 20"
    Head Angle 70° 70° 70° 70° 70°
    Seat Angle 73° 73° 73° 73° 73°
    Top Tube 521 mm 533 mm 552 mm 572 mm 584 mm
    BB Height 292 mm 292 mm 292 mm 292 mm 292 mm
    Stand Over 705 mm 730 mm 762 mm 794 mm 826 mm
    Wheel Base 1029 mm 1041 mm 1060 mm 1080 mm 1092 mm
    Chain Stay 425 mm 425 mm 425 mm 425 mm 425 mm
    Seat Post 27.2 mm 27.2 mm 27.2 mm 27.2 mm 27.2 mm

    I'm 173cm tall and have relatively short legs - from groin to floor in
    barefeet is about 78cm. I think I need to choose either the 15" frame
    or the 17" frame but am not sure which one. The guy in the shop seems
    to think that 17" would be best but knowing that I'd rather be more
    hunched forward when I ride what size frame do you think I should go
    for.

    thanks in advance,

    David

  2. pingin <[email hidden]> wrote:

    : I'd like to buy a Marin bike. I live in France but unfortunately Marin
    : is not really distributed here

    I know this is what we always say, but why not get one you can try first?
    There's loads of decent (and decently priced) french brands you could try.

    Arthur

    --
    Arthur Clune PGP/GPG Key: http://www.clune.org/pubkey.txt
    Don't get me wrong, perl is an OK operating system, but it lacks a
    lightweight scripting language -- Walter Dnes

  3. pingin said:

    Hi all,

    I'd like to buy a Marin bike. I live in France but unfortunately Marin
    is not really distributed here so I'm going to buy one from abroad - so
    I need to buy it without actually trying.

    Is it worth it buying blind? These days given the cost of a cheap
    airline ticket at the right time of the week is so low it would be worth
    popping over here, trying them out and taking your purchase back with you.

    Its very difficult to size a bike from a catalogue because the
    measurements are not standardised and other factors such as top tube
    length come into whether it fits or not; quite often you are better
    buying by top tube length and using a long/short seat post on a mountain
    bike.

    Tony

  4. Hi Arthur,

    Thanks for your answer.
    I have looked. I just want a reasonably light, stiff bike with no
    suspension, decent components and 26" wheels, preferably with road
    friendly tyres. I'm happy paying up to about 600 euros. Do you know of
    any French bike in particular that fits this spec? The only thing
    French I found that comes close to that spirit is the Decathalon
    "triband" but the Marin is I think a better, more versatile bike so a
    better investment long term.

    Dave

  5. pingin said:

    Hi Arthur,

    Thanks for your answer.
    I have looked. I just want a reasonably light, stiff bike with no
    suspension, decent components and 26" wheels, preferably with road
    friendly tyres. I'm happy paying up to about 600 euros. Do you know of
    any French bike in particular that fits this spec? The only thing
    French I found that comes close to that spirit is the Decathalon
    "triband" but the Marin is I think a better, more versatile bike so a
    better investment long term.

    The Specialized range is quite good in that price range and widely
    available in Europe. There are also some good French makes around
    (maybe a bit more expensive). Join a local MTB forum and see what
    people recommend.

    Tony

  6. pingin <[email hidden]> wrote:
    : "triband" but the Marin is I think a better, more versatile bike so a
    : better investment long term.

    Not if it doesn't fit.

    --
    Arthur Clune PGP/GPG Key: http://www.clune.org/pubkey.txt
    Don't get me wrong, perl is an OK operating system, but it lacks a
    lightweight scripting language -- Walter Dnes

  7. Tony Raven said:

    Is it worth it buying blind? These days given the cost of a cheap
    airline ticket at the right time of the week is so low it would be


    worth

    Quoted message said:

    popping over here, trying them out and taking your purchase back with


    you.

    Quoted message said:


    Its very difficult to size a bike from a catalogue because the
    measurements are not standardised and other factors such as top tube
    length come into whether it fits or not; quite often you are better
    buying by top tube length and using a long/short seat post on a


    mountain

    Quoted message said:

    bike.

    Tony

    Hi Tony,

    You're probably right but I'm not sure it's all that cheap. I think
    with airport taxes and public transport on both sides, it would be
    harder to do it same day for less than 100 euros. Then usually with
    planes you have to pay extra for carrying a bike so it might end up
    adding significantly to the final cost of the bike. But in the long
    run, maybe it's worth it for the peace of mind...

    David

  8. Tony Raven said:

    Join a local MTB forum and see what
    people recommend.

    You know, you're probably right. I'll try that.
    cheers,
    David

  9. pingin said:

    You're probably right but I'm not sure it's all that cheap. I think
    with airport taxes and public transport on both sides, it would be
    harder to do it same day for less than 100 euros. Then usually with
    planes you have to pay extra for carrying a bike

    Easy - just cycle back! 😉

    --
    jc

    Remove the -not from email

  10. Arthur Clune said:

    Not if it doesn't fit.

    lol

  11. Yes, the specialised MTBs are nice. The Hardrock XC Comp sort of caught
    my eye- 500 euros so it's in my price range:
    http://www.specialized.com/SBCBkModel.jsp?spid=9599&JServSessionIdroot=iksk05089b.j27005
    Does it seem like good value?

    I followed your advise and posted to a MTB forum. They were very
    friendly people and helpful too!
    (http://www.webtt.com/place/marche/list.php?f=1)

    No one seems to have heard of any French bikes like this on the market
    which sort of confirms my experience.

    Some one did point me to the Cannondale 'Bad Boy" which is in the same
    style but well beyond my budget (it costs a 1000 euros).

    There is the Decathalon Triband but it's not for sale now (they may be
    renewing the product). I don't like the design too much (bit flashy)
    but it's good value for money.

    The other suggestion was to buy a hardtail and swap out the fork with
    the warning that this might not be as straightforward as it sounds for
    some technical reason that I don't really understand.
    I'm may end up just buying a low-end hardtail, swapping out the tyres
    and keeping the front suspension - it's not going to kill me and it
    might come in useful for those occasional potholes :-)

    Thanks for the advice

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.