General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

High energy lightweight foods ?

Started by Rob G · · Last activity · 40 posts · 363 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
16 April 2007
Last activity
27 April 2007
Original author
Rob G
Posts
40
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
363
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 40
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. The collective's input is requested please.

    Recently retired with 50+ Munros to do. As kids we would trek into
    the hills without much thought to how much we were carrying, but those
    days are long gone and with some of the more remote hills having long
    access, backpacking in with a tent etc. is going to be necessary.

    I was mightily relieved to find that a complete summer backpack
    weighed in only a few pounds more than my winter day sack, but I would
    like some opinions on lightweight high energy foods, both main meal
    and through the day.

    Thanks

    Rob

  2. Rob G wrote

    Quoted message said:

    like some opinions on lightweight high energy foods, both main meal
    and through the day.

    Dried banana chips, especially. Dried fruit in general.
    Take plenty of water though.

    Big plate of pasta the night before.

    8 pints and a huge mixed grill afterwards, simply because
    you can :-D

    Chris

  3. Rob G said:

    I would
    like some opinions on lightweight high energy foods, both main meal
    and through the day.

    Well dehydrated food is the obvious choice for main meals. It's so light you
    can carry a lot of it.

    As for snacks, I'd recommend dried fruit and nuts. Not that light but a high
    energy to weight ratio, and much healthier than bars of chocolate or sweets.

    Paul
    --
    http://www.wilderness-wales.co.uk

  4. As per other posts, dried fruit is good (try mixing in nuts, seeds and
    chocolate drops to make it more interesting). If you fancy something
    a bit more satisfying, try malt loaf, fig rolls, jaffa cakes and
    Nutrigrain Elevenses bars (I'm not so bothered about healthy eating
    when I'm clocking up lots of miles and ascent!). Also have some
    Kendall mint cake handy (chocolate coated for preferences) and eat a
    chunk five minutes before hitting a steep climb - you'll be surprised
    how much of a boost it gives you!

    My biggest hint though would be beef jerky - somehow it gives you a
    lift disproportionate to it's energy content, especially when you're
    feeling knackered and miserable - also it doesn't repeat on you all
    day, unlike pepperami! (incidentally, apparently a pepperami contains
    "106% pork", which by my reckoning means it should be bigger than it
    looks,,,

    I'd also recommend some crisps on a hot day - providing you've got
    plenty of water.

    Cheers

    Anth

    Please link to: http://www.wheresthepath.com/index.htm

  5. Chris Gilbert said:

    Big plate of pasta the night before.

    I once read that loading up on carbs only worked if you did it for
    several days in advance of needing it, as the body takes time to adjust
    to dealing with that kind of food. The article said that at least three
    days in advance were required, and that you should take plenty of water
    during those days in order to enable your body to correctly process and
    store this form of energy.

    Any ideas on the validity of this? It seemed to work well for me for
    the 2004 Grindleford Gallop, but perhaps it was just the pasta from the
    night before rather than the week-long pasta/water regimen.

    Quoted message said:

    8 pints and a huge mixed grill afterwards, simply because
    you can :-D

    Oh yes! And because you deserve it!

    --
    Chris

  6. On 16 Apr, 23:38, "www.wheresthepath.co.uk" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    As per other posts, dried fruit is good (try mixing in nuts, seeds and
    chocolate drops to make it more interesting). If you fancy something
    a bit more satisfying, try malt loaf, fig rolls, jaffa cakes and
    Nutrigrain Elevenses bars (I'm not so bothered about healthy eating
    when I'm clocking up lots of miles and ascent!). Also have some
    Kendall mint cake handy (chocolate coated for preferences) and eat a
    chunk five minutes before hitting a steep climb - you'll be surprised
    how much of a boost it gives you!

    My biggest hint though would be beef jerky - somehow it gives you a
    lift disproportionate to it's energy content, especially when you're
    feeling knackered and miserable - also it doesn't repeat on you all
    day, unlike pepperami! (incidentally, apparently a pepperami contains
    "106% pork", which by my reckoning means it should be bigger than it
    looks,,,

    I'd also recommend some crisps on a hot day - providing you've got
    plenty of water.

    Cheers

    Anth

    Please link to:http://www.wheresthepath.com/index.htm

    Thanks for the suggestions, guys.

    Can I keep the thread going a bit please ?

    I'm intrigued by the beef jerky. It would seem from the write up on a
    googled site that it is just eaten in strips as you are on the hoof
    (!). But can it also be used as the basis for a cooked dish?

    The other thing I was hoping I would get from the thread is
    recommendations for specific dehydrated foods. There were good ones
    and bad ones 30 years ago and I'm sure that still exists. The usual
    call without experience is to buy the higher priced ones but that may
    not necessarily be the best option.

    Another thing I explored was what was the basis of the rehydrating
    salts - mixture of salt, baking powder and sugar (again several
    googled sites have recipes) but does anyone know if you can get
    powdered flavorings as the logical thing to do is to just add a
    teaspoon to a mug each time you stop at a burn. Or does someone know
    that this is not a good idea ?

    Rob

  7. Rob G said:

    Can I keep the thread going a bit please ?

    Quoted message said:

    The other thing I was hoping I would get from the thread is
    recommendations for specific dehydrated foods.

    I recommend Vesta meals. They're very filling and use real freeze dried meat
    rather than the soya protein that you find in many other dried meals.

    I also recommend cous-cous, very quick to make (just pour on boiling water
    and wait a few minutes - saves a lot of fuel) and very high in energy. Good
    for breakfast to give you an energy boost to start your day. Of course, like
    Phil Cook, you can prepare it in a more exotic way if you wish.

    Those cheap packets of noodles are also very quick to make, just pour on
    boiling water and wait a few minutes, no need to simmer.

    A lot of dried meals recommend simmering for maybe 12 or 20 minutes. This
    wastes a lot of fuel and isn't necessary. Just bring them to the boil, then
    cover and turn the stove off. Wait for the appropriate amount of time and
    you'll find that it's ready to eat. If it has cooled down too much, you can
    always turn the stove back on and give it a short heat boost. Saving fuel is
    a very important consideration in my opinion. The whole point of carrying
    dried food is to save weight, but if you spend a lot of time simmering
    you'll end up having to carry more weight in fuel.

    Same principle applies for making cups of tea or coffee. While these are
    good morale boosters, too many cups will drain your fuel.

    Soups are good to carry too, particularly those 1 pint soups. Very light and
    they make a lot. Okay, it's mostly liquid, but it helps to fill you up. You
    can bread of course, but lately I've switched to carrying rice cakes to add
    to soup. Okay, they're bulky, but they're almost as light as air.

    Another thing worth carrying is instant mash (not Smash though, that's too
    bulky). Good as an emergency reserve, and also as a soup thickener.

    Paul
    --
    http://www.wilderness-wales.co.uk

  8. Rob G said:

    I would
    like some opinions on lightweight high energy foods, both main meal
    and through the day.

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero but I find Vesta
    Curries light to carry, jolly tasty and a morale booster when I'm
    cold. I just put both sachets in and boil the lot up together. I
    should think there's energy in the rice.

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view. Also I write this with trepidation in the expectation
    that a host of people are about to tell me I'm a fool and taking a
    Vesta onto a hill is nigh on suicide!

  9. toad said:

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero

    I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    dehydrated meals.

    Quoted message said:

    but I find Vesta
    Curries light to carry, jolly tasty and a morale booster when I'm
    cold. I just put both sachets in and boil the lot up together. I
    should think there's energy in the rice.

    Of course there is. If dehydrated meals had no nutritional value people
    would starve after a few days. Obviously this isn't the case. Clearly dried
    food is not the healthiest food on the planet, but it'll keep you alive and
    well fed for a few days, or even more than a few. And it's probably better
    for you than some of the junk that people regularly eat. You can go back to
    eating healthy when you get home. A few days living off dried food won't
    kill you.

    Quoted message said:

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view.

    Not any more. I've always recommended them. Best tasting dried food I know
    of.

    Paul
    --
    http://www.wilderness-wales.co.uk

  10. toad said:
    Rob G said:

    I would
    like some opinions on lightweight high energy foods, both main meal
    and through the day.

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero but I find Vesta
    Curries light to carry, jolly tasty and a morale booster when I'm
    cold. I just put both sachets in and boil the lot up together. I
    should think there's energy in the rice.

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view. Also I write this with trepidation in the expectation
    that a host of people are about to tell me I'm a fool and taking a
    Vesta onto a hill is nigh on suicide!

    I'm amazed they're still available. They bring back nostalgic
    memories of being a student in the late 70s in a hall of residence
    with just a baby Belling counter-top cooker to use. Paella was my
    favourite - the curries were ok, as was one of the "Chinese" options
    (not the one that had noodles requiring deep-frying tho).

    I only day-walk, so I can afford to carry what I like to eat. Imho,
    nothing beats a Mars bar on a summit, so I always have one of one size
    or another. (They have a similar calories/weight ratio to dried
    fruit.) A banana skin is a damned nuisance to have to carry out, so I
    only have one at the start of a walk and carry apples or grapes or the
    like for a refreshing snack. Along with those go a butty or two and
    always, always, some flapjack. Oats are excellent fuel, and I try to
    make some porridge for breakfast when I'm out for a day in the cold.

    [Oops, forgot to mention the emergency chocolate :-)]

  11. Paul Saunders said:
    toad said:

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero

    I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    dehydrated meals.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    but I find Vesta
    Curries light to carry, jolly tasty and a morale booster when I'm
    cold. I just put both sachets in and boil the lot up together. I
    should think there's energy in the rice.

    Of course there is. If dehydrated meals had no nutritional value people
    would starve after a few days. Obviously this isn't the case. Clearly dried
    food is not the healthiest food on the planet, but it'll keep you alive and
    well fed for a few days, or even more than a few. And it's probably better
    for you than some of the junk that people regularly eat. You can go back to
    eating healthy when you get home. A few days living off dried food won't
    kill you.

    Quoted message said:

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view.

    Not any more. I've always recommended them. Best tasting dried food I know
    of.

    Yes, I hadn't spotted your post recommending Vesta's when I made mine
    so I put a bit of a negative spin on assuming I was about to get
    soundly shouted down for suggesting them. I'd have to agree with all
    your points.

    I found your point on boiling too long and wasting fuel quite
    interesting too. I take no care at all with my fuel use yet it's on of
    the heaviest things I carry.

  12. John Laird said:

    On Apr 18, 11:32 am, toad <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view. Also I write this with trepidation in the expectation
    that a host of people are about to tell me I'm a fool and taking a
    Vesta onto a hill is nigh on suicide!

    I'm amazed they're still available.

    They said last year in a blaze of publicity that they'd stopped doing
    them in the UK, but the last few times I've bought them I've had no
    problems getting hold of them at all.

    Quoted message said:

    They bring back nostalgic
    memories of being a student in the late 70s in a hall of residence
    with just a baby Belling counter-top cooker to use. Paella was my
    favourite -

    Paella is tasty _but_ IIRC the beef curry is the largest quantity per
    sachet so I always get that.

  13. Paul Saunders said:

    I also recommend cous-cous, very quick to make (just pour on boiling water
    and wait a few minutes - saves a lot of fuel) and very high in energy. Good
    for breakfast to give you an energy boost to start your day. Of course, like
    Phil Cook, you can prepare it in a more exotic way if you wish.

    Huh, Wassat!

    Mmmmm. Cous-cous. Before you go crumble half a veggie stock cube, and
    a few porcini mushrooms into the stuff. Add some dried mixed herbs and
    a good grind of black pepper then put it in a 500ml container that
    Co-op luxury ice cream came in. At your campsite finely slice half an
    onion and fry it in a little olive oil. Then add about 750 ml of
    water, bring to the boil and add half the pot of cous-cous mix. Give
    it a good stir, turn off the gas and put the lid on. Wrap it in your
    fleece or spare hat to keep it warm. Wait ten minutes (that's the hard
    part) add good drizzle of oil and give it a good stir. Delish! The
    other half or the container will do another meal. You could have it
    for breakfast but I prefer my morning repast to be porrige a la
    ecossaise; half milk, half water and salt. No sugar, no golden syrup.
    :-|

    Quoted message said:

    Another thing worth carrying is instant mash (not Smash though, that's too
    bulky). Good as an emergency reserve, and also as a soup thickener.

    Yes, you need to get the stuff made only of real potato. Mr Mash is
    one brand http://intersnack.co.uk/index.php?/products/mrmash/
    --
    Phil Cook, last hill: Heron Pike via Nab Scar.

  14. Paul Saunders said:
    Rob G said:

    Can I keep the thread going a bit please ?
    The other thing I was hoping I would get from the thread is
    recommendations for specific dehydrated foods.

    I recommend Vesta meals. They're very filling and use real freeze dried meat
    rather than the soya protein that you find in many other dried meals.

    I also recommend cous-cous, very quick to make (just pour on boiling water
    and wait a few minutes - saves a lot of fuel) and very high in energy. Good
    for breakfast to give you an energy boost to start your day. Of course, like
    Phil Cook, you can prepare it in a more exotic way if you wish.

    Those cheap packets of noodles are also very quick to make, just pour on
    boiling water and wait a few minutes, no need to simmer.

    A lot of dried meals recommend simmering for maybe 12 or 20 minutes. This
    wastes a lot of fuel and isn't necessary. Just bring them to the boil, then
    cover and turn the stove off. Wait for the appropriate amount of time and
    you'll find that it's ready to eat. If it has cooled down too much, you can
    always turn the stove back on and give it a short heat boost. Saving fuel is
    a very important consideration in my opinion. The whole point of carrying
    dried food is to save weight, but if you spend a lot of time simmering
    you'll end up having to carry more weight in fuel.

    Same principle applies for making cups of tea or coffee. While these are
    good morale boosters, too many cups will drain your fuel.

    Soups are good to carry too, particularly those 1 pint soups. Very light and
    they make a lot. Okay, it's mostly liquid, but it helps to fill you up. You
    can bread of course, but lately I've switched to carrying rice cakes to add
    to soup. Okay, they're bulky, but they're almost as light as air.

    Another thing worth carrying is instant mash (not Smash though, that's too
    bulky). Good as an emergency reserve, and also as a soup thickener.

    Paul
    --http://www.wilderness-wales.co.uk

    Many thanks Paul and others

    Vesta packs bring back memories; never used for through-the-week
    cooking when a student but often enough when packing at the weekends.
    That was 40 years ago and I was hoping that someone would tell me if
    they were acceptable still.

    One particular memory is living off them for several weeks on end in
    remote Turkey and finding that whatever we did the sulphur dioxide
    preservative did nasty things for one's wind generation !!! We were
    all about as bad as one another so it didn't matter who you were
    sharing a tent with.

    Rob

  15. toad said:
    John Laird said:
    toad said:

    I should warn that I'm the only person I know who shares the 'Jolly
    tasty' view. Also I write this with trepidation in the expectation
    that a host of people are about to tell me I'm a fool and taking a
    Vesta onto a hill is nigh on suicide!

    Quoted message said:

    I'm amazed they're still available.

    They said last year in a blaze of publicity that they'd stopped doing
    them in the UK, but the last few times I've bought them I've had no
    problems getting hold of them at all.

    They're probably in that aisle in the supermarket to which I pay no
    attention. Aka the Pot Noodle zone.

    A quick Google turned up a US import site (so obviously lots of ex-
    pats reliving their yoof), and the fact that the brand may have been
    part of Brooke Bond, or Unilever. No one actually claims to still
    make them ! Another top Google hit was Greenpeace who listed Vesta
    meals in an article on GM soya.

    Officially, they are now Ambient Ready Meals. So now you know.

    I'll get me coat...

  16. toad said:

    I found your point on boiling too long and wasting fuel quite
    interesting too. I take no care at all with my fuel use yet it's on of
    the heaviest things I carry.

    I've made a 'cosy' for my Titanium Kettle using 2 layers of radiator
    insulation foam/foil, with a lid made of the same. I bring the water to
    the boil and put in red lentils and bulgar wheat, and bring back to the
    boil. I then turn off the stove and put the kettle into the cosy, and
    forget about it for 10-20 mins - or even 40 mins if I'm busy with my
    tent. I then stir in a packet soup for flavouring (leek and potato is a
    favourite). Even after as long as 40 mins, it's still too hot to eat.
    It's also handy to leave the kettle in the cosy when eating, to keep
    warm and prevent burning of the hands. The cosy is one of the most
    useful cooking accessories I have - and I wouldn't be without it!

    Jim Ford

  17. Paul Saunders said:
    Quoted message said:

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero

    I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    dehydrated meals.

    Interesting logic.

    Judith

  18. Judith said:
    Paul Saunders said:
    Quoted message said:

    I would think the nutritional value is close on zero

    I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    dehydrated meals.

    Interesting logic.

    Perfectly logical for carnivores :-)

    I've always wondered why vegetarians want to eat facsimilies of meat
    products.
    --
    Phil Cook, last hill: Heron Pike via Nab Scar.

  19. Phil Cook said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > I would think the nutritional value is close on zero

    I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    dehydrated meals.

    Interesting logic.

    Perfectly logical for carnivores :-)

    I've always wondered why vegetarians want to eat facsimilies of meat
    products.

    So have I, and I generally don't.

    "Meat" can include a nice juicy bit of muscle, or a slither of scrotum
    or eye-lid. Yummy. That /must/ be better than a veggie meal.

    Judith

  20. On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 17:30:00 +0100, Phil Cook
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    |!Judith wrote:
    |!
    |!>On Wed, 18 Apr 2007 11:43:10 +0100, "Paul Saunders"
    |!><[email hidden]> wrote:
    |!>
    |!>>> I would think the nutritional value is close on zero
    |!>>
    |!>>I disagree, they use real freeze dried meat, so it must be better than most
    |!>>dehydrated meals.
    |!>
    |!>Interesting logic.
    |!
    |!Perfectly logical for carnivores :-)
    |!
    |!I've always wondered why vegetarians want to eat facsimilies of meat
    |!products.

    Because for 100,000 years or so humans and our ancestors were omnivores and
    ate cooked meet when they could get it because it is a High Energy Food as
    compared with vegetables, grains etc. So our taste buds are designed to
    like cooked meat. Vegetarianism is a relatively modern phenomenon only
    some few thousand years old in India, even more modern in the UK/West.
    --
    Dave Fawthrop <sf hyphenologist.co.uk> 165 *Free* SF ebooks.
    165 Sci Fi books on CDROM, from Project Gutenberg
    http://www.gutenberg.org/wiki/Main_Page Completely Free to any
    address in the UK. Contact me on the *above* email address.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.