General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

How do you define "Cooking from Scratch"?

Started by maxine in ri · · Last activity · 15 posts · 464 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
18 March 2006
Last activity
20 March 2006
Original author
maxine in ri
Posts
15
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
464
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–15 of 15
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    How 'bout you?

    maxine in ri

  2. On 18 Mar 2006 13:07:47 -0800, "maxine in ri" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Same here. I use cans for things I can't easily make myself (olives
    are a wonderful example), but mostly, it's raw ingredients (no, I
    don't grind my own flour or make my own pasta -- I still think of
    flour and dried pasta as ingredients, not convenience foods in the way
    that canned soup, for instance, is) to start with.

    serene

  3. maxine in ri said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    How 'bout you?

    maxine in ri

    Ok, my definition is that I use whole, raw and as natural ingredients as
    possible. I cook from scratch when I do homecanning so IMO those food
    items while processed are still from scratch. I'd say I by minimally
    processed foods as you mentioned then use them in meals at home.

    cooking - I really shy away from the microwave but that is because I
    didn't grow up with it and still don't really like it so you can't
    really judge it by me. I like the bbq, burners, or oven myself.

    cheese - I make yogurt and have been doing so for quite some time but
    yogurt cheese always messes up. I don't know what I'm doing wrong. I
    would like to make my own cheese but now is not the right time.

    bread - I make all the bread and bread products we eat. It is usually
    multigrain but I use unbleached flour sometimes for other types of
    bread. I think I would averagage 2 loave a week for the 2 of us then a
    special loaf if we have company. Leftover bread is turned into croutons
    or bread crumbs.

  4. "serene" wrote>

    maxine in ri said:


    Quoted message said:


    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Same here. I use cans for things I can't easily make myself (olives
    are a wonderful example), but mostly, it's raw ingredients >
    serene

    I cook mostly from scratch, except for such things as canned stewed or diced
    tomatoes. At breakfast, though, I cheat if I'm making pancakes and use good
    old Aunt Jemima mix. it's too early in the day to fool around with separate
    ingredients.

    Somehow, using too many prepared items in cooking takes away the fun.

    Dora

  5. On Sat, 18 Mar 2006 16:44:37 -0500, "limey" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:


    "serene" wrote>

    maxine in ri said:


    Quoted message said:


    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Same here. I use cans for things I can't easily make myself (olives
    are a wonderful example), but mostly, it's raw ingredients >
    serene

    I cook mostly from scratch, except for such things as canned stewed or diced
    tomatoes. At breakfast, though, I cheat if I'm making pancakes and use good
    old Aunt Jemima mix. it's too early in the day to fool around with separate
    ingredients.

    Would it work for you to mix up your own pancake mix? It's pretty
    simple, a lot cheaper, and you can control the ingredients.

    serene

  6. In article <[email hidden]>,

    maxine in ri said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    Nope, but I just finished eating a Smart Ones lasagna frozen dinner that
    I nuked here in my office before I go to the gym! I was famished!

    Quoted message said:

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    Maxine, I agree with your definition of scratch cooking, where in my
    mind, its using mostly unprocessed ingredients. Heating up a frozen
    dinner may be cooking in the literal definition, but it is not cooking
    from scratch, by any means.

    Than again, cooking from scratch does not imply a quality result. For
    example, I could take a piece of fish, and some herbs and spices and
    come up with something that tastes totally dreadful even though what I
    might have cooked included all unprocessed ingredients.

  7. "maxine in ri" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    For me it involves cooking things starting from the most basic components
    that are practical. Just about the only canned veggies I use are tomatoes,
    when fresh aren't available in the same quality and after the ones in my
    freezer are gone. I'll use canned tomato paste, too. And canned artichoke
    hearts, olives, things like that.

    I bake my own bread, but I don't grind the grains. Sometimes I make pasta.
    It depends. I buy things like crackers and graham crackers. I've got panko
    bread crumbs that I bought.

    Some things don't seem to be practical or worthwhile to make at home --
    ketchup, for example. I bought corned beef already "corned." I don't smoke
    my own ham or sausages.

    It also depends on how much of a highlight a particular ingredient is in the
    overall meal plan. Sometimes I make my own tortillas, but I've got a good
    local source, so quite often I buy them. Desserts aren't a big thing around
    here. Sometimes I'll make a dessert, but right now I've got a couple boxes
    of Girl Scout cookies around. don't remember the last time we had boxed
    cookies, though -- probably last Girl Scout season. There's always some kind
    of fresh fruit available for dessert, if we want it. My pie crusts are hit
    and miss, so sometimes I'll buy the pre-made crusts if I'm making a pie.
    Depends on what else is going on. I might bake cookies, but I'll buy the
    chocolate chips.

    It also depends on how readily available an ingredient is. I don't like the
    local Italian sausages, and I've seldom seen fresh Polish sausage, so I make
    my own. I can't find good pita bread, so I make that. I can't find gyros
    meat, so I make that. I recently made batches of ravioli and pierogi and
    froze them.

    Depends also on how much of a thing I use and how practical it is to make in
    small quantities. I buy jelly, but I use maybe one jar a year. There are
    probably a lot of other things like that. I buy cheese, but it's "real"
    cheese.

    I've also got a couple of recipes that call for canned products, and when I
    make them, I use the canned goods if I want them to come out the way I'm
    used to. I might try another recipe now and then, but if I'm making
    something that I've eaten since childhood, it's just not the same without
    the canned cream of mushroom soup, or whatever. But I'm more likely to use
    those canned goods as in ingredient in a recipe than served as-is. So I
    might use a jarred salsa in a recipe, but make my own for dipping.

    And there are times when I crave boxed mac 'n cheese. Mostly when I'm
    feeling a little sick. If I'm sicker, I want Mrs. Grass's chicken noodle
    soup.

    Sometimes I'll buy Safeway's soups. The tomato basil is pretty good. There
    are other things that I'll buy now and then. About once a year, we'll have
    Marie Callendar's pot pies. If I'm making burgers on the grill, I might buy
    potato chips, and now and then I buy Cheetos. I'm definitely not fanatic
    about not using prepared foods, but I probably use less than most of my
    neighbors.

    Donna

  8. maxine in ri said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?


    Almost all of the meat, fish and vegetables I buy are raw and organic.
    We eat hardly any grains or sugar so baking isn't an issue. There are
    things which I don't want to make like cheese, wine, tomato paste,
    mustard, smoked fish partly because I doubt if it'd be worth the effort
    and partly because I doubt I'd do it well. But I do make mayonnaise,
    tapenade, taramasalata. The cooking I do is mostly fairly simple, I
    buy the best food I can and do as little as possible to it. If I want
    something really complicated I'll go to a restaurant where they have a
    kitchen brigade to handle recipes with 25 ingredients and 20 steps!

  9. "maxine in ri" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Well, that would be from scratch, but it isn't necessary to do all of that to cook
    from scratch by my definition.

    Quoted message said:


    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    Nope, not really.

    Quoted message said:


    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    Heating isn't cooking, it's heating....hence the word, heating.

    Quoted message said:

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    How 'bout you?

    maxine in ri

    I'm with you. Cooking from scratch, to me, means making it yourself...not growing it
    necessarily, but preparing it. When it's already prepared for you, you're not really
    cooking are you?
    I do alot of things myself, but there are other things that I don't have the time
    for, or that I like from somewhere else. I don't make yogurt, but then, I don't eat
    it either 😉 I do make bread, cakes, cookies, muffins, etc from scratch. I make
    stocks, soups, gravies, sauces, et al from scratch as well. I do use jarred spaghetti
    sauce sometimes, with my own twist on it, because, frankly, I like it! 🙂 Now, I add
    alot of stuff to the jarred red sauce, like meat (beef and pork), pepperoni, grated
    onion, some herbs...but I don't consider that from scratch. I do make pasta from
    scratch, but not always. Luckily for me, there's some tasty pasta to be had from
    Little Italy!
    But, I digress.
    If you have to prep ingredients, it's likely from scratch 🙂

    kimberly

  10. "maxine in ri" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    That would qualify but it is not really possible to live that way if you
    want to eat a wide range of foods prepared in a range of styles. There are
    few places in the world where you can grow (for example) tomatos all year
    round, does this mean you can only serve tomatos in summer? OK you could
    preserve your own tomatos (I do) but such are poor fare in salad.

    Also there are ingredients that require skills, equipment and raw
    ingredients that you can hardly have in every home. I know people who
    pickle their own olives and make their own salami but who makes their own
    soy sauce?

    Quoted message said:

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    I don't think a dish like that qualifies but it could still be reasonably
    tasty and somewhat nutritious.

    Quoted message said:

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    No but I might do it if I had no fresh ingredients or time available and the
    commercial product was a good one.

    Quoted message said:

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Seems fair

    Quoted message said:

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    I have the same aspiration and the acres of pasture to make it possible!
    Clearly very few people could manage this.

    A suggestion: trying to determine what people mean by "cooking from
    scratch" seems quite pointless. As we have seen "scratch" varies widely
    according to the circumstances. Another way to look at the same issue is to
    ask:

    (1) Do you desire to eat and to serve nutritious and appealing food?
    (2) How much time and money are you prepared to spend towards that goal?

    If all the denizens of RFC answered 'yes' to (1) [I approve of motherhood
    too] there would still be quite a range of answers to (2) as we all have
    different resources.

    David

  11. If God had wanted us to cook from scratch, She wouldn't have invented
    Betty Crocker . . .
    ;-)

    Having said that, I'm somewhere in the middle. I cook for 12 to 20+
    folks at work, but I live alone.
    Aside from scrambled eggs, grilled cheese etc. it's mostly Stouffer's
    at home.
    At work I don't bat an eye about using boxed scalloped potatoes - if I
    have enough boxes in the pantry - but I can make 'em from scratch
    "scratch" too.

    Lynn from Fargo

  12. Anthony said:
    maxine in ri said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Almost all of the meat, fish and vegetables I buy are raw and organic.
    We eat hardly any grains or sugar so baking isn't an issue. There are
    things which I don't want to make like cheese, wine, tomato paste,
    mustard, smoked fish partly because I doubt if it'd be worth the effort
    and partly because I doubt I'd do it well. But I do make mayonnaise,
    tapenade, taramasalata. The cooking I do is mostly fairly simple, I
    buy the best food I can and do as little as possible to it. If I want
    something really complicated I'll go to a restaurant where they have a
    kitchen brigade to handle recipes with 25 ingredients and 20 steps!

    That's the same as me - although I have smoked my own fish (caught by my
    husband) a couple of times - still getting used to the smoker. Oh, and
    the house is still stuffed with homemade 'wine' from a few years back.
    There's a reason it's not been drunk yet 😉 - it tastes like diesel!

    Jo

  13. Henhouse said:
    Anthony said:
    maxine in ri said:

    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Almost all of the meat, fish and vegetables I buy are raw and organic.
    We eat hardly any grains or sugar so baking isn't an issue. There are
    things which I don't want to make like cheese, wine, tomato paste,
    mustard, smoked fish partly because I doubt if it'd be worth the effort
    and partly because I doubt I'd do it well. But I do make mayonnaise,
    tapenade, taramasalata. The cooking I do is mostly fairly simple, I
    buy the best food I can and do as little as possible to it. If I want
    something really complicated I'll go to a restaurant where they have a
    kitchen brigade to handle recipes with 25 ingredients and 20 steps!

    That's the same as me - although I have smoked my own fish (caught by my
    husband) a couple of times - still getting used to the smoker. Oh, and
    the house is still stuffed with homemade 'wine' from a few years back.
    There's a reason it's not been drunk yet 😉 - it tastes like diesel!

    Jo

    I haven't tried smoking but would like to buy a smoker. DFIL got me
    hooked on smoked salmon, wonderful stuff! We haven't made homemade wine
    since our rootbeer adventure. They ended up being mini bombs - not
    nice. One of our relatives makes homemade wine that isn't too bad.
    There are a couple of places where you can go to make your own wine.
    They have all the equipment and can help you out. I wouldn't mind
    trying that but I'd be scared it would come out like diesel as you say.

  14. ~patches~ wrote on 19 Mar 2006 in rec.food.cooking

    Quoted message said:
    Henhouse said:
    Anthony said:

    maxine in ri wrote:

    > Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    > creating edible food?


    Ifin you get a itchin to cook, Scratch it?

    --
    -Alan

  15. maxine in ri said:


    Is it growing all your own organic ingredients, processing them, and
    creating edible food?

    Is it opening a few cans, mixing them together, putting the result in
    the microwave for 20 minutes?

    How about heating up a frozen commercial entree?

    I'd like to hear how individuals here define it, and I'll start off
    with my take:

    Taking mostly foods that are minimally processed (fresh or frozen
    produce, uncooked, unseasoned animal protein, basic elements of baking,
    dairy products from the store, drynoodles and other grain products)
    combining and processing them with heat or cold or time, to make the
    food I serve to my family and friends.

    I use Canned and jarred goods, but not too often, or as a minor element
    in the cooking (canned tuna, or olives for example).

    Lately,I've been baking bread and making yogurt, and would like to
    learn enough to make my own cheeses,fresh ones first, then aged ones as
    resources present themselves.

    How 'bout you?

    maxine in ri

    That's about what I do, for the most part.

    Kate

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.