General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

mad cow disease.

Started by Paula · · Last activity · 13 posts · 459 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
19 March 2004
Last activity
23 March 2004
Original author
Paula
Posts
13
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
459
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–13 of 13
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. here in the u.k. the health authorities have banned anyone
    who has had a blood transfusion in the last 20 years from
    being a blood donor.there is concern that blood transfusions
    and the variant cjd are linked by the donors themselves
    being carriers..Some recipients of blood including a
    hoemophiliac (spelling may not be correct)have signs of the
    disease.This is giving widespread concerns of blood stocks
    dwindling.Will all this NEVER end.?.

  2. Quoted message said:

    here in the u.k. the health authorities have banned anyone
    who has had a blood transfusion in the last 20 years from
    being a blood donor.

    here in the u.s. I can't donate blood because I lived
    overseas within the last 20 years. I moved back to the u.s.
    from germany in 1997.

    Denny

  3. paula said:

    Will all this NEVER end.?.

    This will end when unscrupulous cow farmers stop using
    downer and mad cows as feed. There is strong evidence that
    cannibalism is bad for any species, and mad cow proves
    that it is not only bad for cows but also humans that eat
    those cows.

    As for the idea that you are safe as long as you do not eat
    cow brains, well, I do not trust that. This whole ordeal has
    taken several turns for the worse in terms of trusting the
    government, medical research, and cow farmers. They earned
    my skepticism.

    Yet I still eat beef... I cannot give up beef. It is
    just too good.

    --
    John Gaughan johngaughan.netjohngaughan.net
    [email hidden]

  4. In article <[email hidden]>,

    John Gaughan said:
    paula said:

    Will all this NEVER end.?.

    This will end when unscrupulous cow farmers stop using
    downer and mad cows as feed. There is strong evidence that
    cannibalism is bad for any species, and mad cow proves
    that it is not only bad for cows but also humans that eat
    those cows.

    As for the idea that you are safe as long as you do not
    eat cow brains, well, I do not trust that. This whole
    ordeal has taken several turns for the worse in terms of
    trusting the government, medical research, and cow
    farmers. They earned my skepticism.

    Yet I still eat beef... I cannot give up beef. It is just
    too good.

    Eat New Zealand beef. No mad cows here. 🙂 (And they're all
    free-range and grass-fed.)

    Miche

    --
    If you want to end war and stuff you got to sing loud. --
    Arlo Guthrie, "Alice's Restaurant"

  5. "John Gaughan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:105nj

    Quoted message said:
    paula said:

    Will all this NEVER end.?.

    As for the idea that you are safe as long as you do not
    eat cow brains, well, I do not trust that. This whole
    ordeal has taken several turns for the worse in terms of
    trusting the government, medical research, and cow
    farmers. They earned my skepticism.

    The problem is, these CNS (central nervous system) parts are
    used in many meat products such as beef stock, beef extract
    & flavorings. They boil the spinal cord with the skeletal
    remains. According to a survey last year by the USDA , about
    one-third of hot dogs ,hamburgers, pizza toppings, taco
    fillers, tested positive for CNS tissue. Prion contamination
    can also occur via the pneumatic guns they use to literally
    blow their brains out.....duh....I guess they won't learn
    till it hits em in the pocketbook. .They've found brain
    parts deep inside some cows.

    Imo, in time we'll discover it was the Mad Ranchers & Mad
    Beef Processors that preceded the Mad Cows.

    <Jon K

  6. John Gaughan said:

    There is strong evidence that cannibalism is bad for any
    species, and mad cow proves that it is not only bad for
    cows but also humans that eat those cows.

    What evidence is this? If a species is free of disease that
    can be spread by contact with or consumption of blood or
    flesh, I can think of no particular scientific drawbacks to
    cannibalism.

    I am having my family for dinner tonight.

    Boron

  7. Jon Leipzig said:


    "John Gaughan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:105nj

    Quoted message said:
    paula said:

    Will all this NEVER end.?.

    As for the idea that you are safe as long as you do not
    eat cow brains, well, I do not trust that. This whole
    ordeal has taken several turns for the worse in terms of
    trusting the government, medical research, and cow
    farmers. They earned my skepticism.

    The problem is, these CNS (central nervous system) parts
    are used in many meat products such as beef stock, beef
    extract & flavorings. They boil the spinal cord with the
    skeletal remains. According to a survey last year by the
    USDA , about one-third of hot dogs ,hamburgers, pizza
    toppings, taco fillers, tested positive for CNS tissue.

    Do you have a citation for that USDA info? All I can find
    that refers to it are referenced through people like Michael
    Gregar who are Vegan/PETA actiivsts.

    Boron

  8. [email hidden] (denny) wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    here in the u.k. the health authorities have banned
    anyone who has had a blood transfusion in the last 20
    years from being a blood donor.

    here in the u.s. I can't donate blood because I lived
    overseas within the last 20 years. I moved back to the
    u.s. from germany in 1997.

    Denny

    when i lived in Germany this last time, anyone knowingly
    going into a local hospital for an op. was advised to have
    some of their own blood on standby in case a transfuion was
    necessary. They were rather worried about giving foreigners
    blood in case of any repercusions. obviously this was no
    good if the hospitalisation was without notice.

  9. Boron Elgar said:

    On Sat, 20 Mar 2004 10:12:59 -0500, "Jon Leipzig"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    The problem is, these CNS (central nervous system) parts
    are used in many meat products such as beef stock, beef
    extract & flavorings. They boil the spinal cord with the
    skeletal remains. According to a survey last year by the
    USDA , about one-third of hot dogs ,hamburgers, pizza
    toppings, taco fillers, tested positive for CNS tissue.

    I remember it being 25%, not 33%. It's still a lot.

    Quoted message said:

    Do you have a citation for that USDA info? All I can find
    that refers to it are referenced through people like
    Michael Gregar who are Vegan/PETA actiivsts.

    This is only one of dozens of reports on the issue.

    fsis.usda.govAMRSurvey.pdf

    This is one that evaluates the data several different
    ways. Not sure if 33% or 25% is correct; I'm sure they're
    both correct.

    -sw

  10. Steve Wertz said:
    Boron Elgar said:

    On Sat, 20 Mar 2004 10:12:59 -0500, "Jon Leipzig"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    The problem is, these CNS (central nervous system) parts
    are used in many meat products such as beef stock, beef
    extract & flavorings. They boil the spinal cord with the
    skeletal remains. According to a survey last year by the
    USDA , about one-third of hot dogs ,hamburgers, pizza
    toppings, taco fillers, tested positive for CNS tissue.

    I remember it being 25%, not 33%. It's still a lot.

    Quoted message said:

    Do you have a citation for that USDA info? All I can find
    that refers to it are referenced through people like
    Michael Gregar who are Vegan/PETA actiivsts.

    This is only one of dozens of reports on the issue.

    fsis.usda.govAMRSurvey.pdf

    This is one that evaluates the data several different
    ways. Not sure if 33% or 25% is correct; I'm sure they're
    both correct.

    -sw

    Actually, the citation you quote, which is quite interesting
    and talks of a survey among a sample of meat producers (34
    in one and 25 in another) certainly indicates that are some
    with CNS tissue in their products, but this says absolutely
    nothing whatsoever about "hot dogs hamburgers, pizza
    toppings, taco fillers." And, realize, too, this is a very
    small sample size and I have no idea of how representative
    of AMR meat production facilities it is.

    Though it is imperative that we are vigilant and steadfast
    in monitoring the food stuffs in this country at all times
    and especially in light of our growing knowledge of
    wasting diseases in animals, it is as important to quote
    statistics and stories accurately and without bias or
    inflammatory exaggeration. Inaccuracy or bias in reportage
    does no one any good.

    Boron

  11. "Boron Elgar" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message new

    Quoted message said:
    Jon Leipzig said:


    "John Gaughan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:105nj

    Quoted message said:

    paula wrote:
    > Will all this NEVER end.?.

    As for the idea that you are safe as long as you do not
    eat cow brains, well, I do not trust that. This whole
    ordeal has taken several turns


    for

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    the worse in terms of trusting the government, medical
    research, and


    cow

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    farmers. They earned my skepticism.

    The problem is, these CNS (central nervous system) parts
    are used in many meat products such as beef stock, beef
    extract & flavorings. They boil


    the

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    spinal cord with the skeletal remains. According to a
    survey last year by the USDA , about one-third of hot
    dogs ,hamburgers, pizza toppings, taco fillers, tested
    positive for CNS tissue.

    Do you have a citation for that USDA info? All I can find
    that refers to it are referenced through people like
    Michael Gregar who are Vegan/PETA actiivsts.

    Well, yes and no. I posted this in another group some time
    ago. Didn't include the ref. I know I have it, but it's on
    my crashed HDrive.

    Found this one, remarkably similar, but I distinctly recall
    my orig- source claimed it was a USDA study, not a vague ref
    to a "gov't survey".

    cspinet.orgsaferbeef.html

    Potentially risky:

    Meat products that might contain brain, spinal cord, or
    central nervous system tissue. These include cow brains,
    head cheese, neck bones, cheek meat, and ox-tail from
    cattle. Products that contain beef extracted by "advanced
    meat recovery" (AMR) machines that squeeze out the last bits
    of meat from cow carcasses. A 2002 government survey found
    that one in three samples of this reclaimed meat was
    contaminated with spinal cord and other central nervous
    system tissue. AMR beef may be used in some hot dogs, taco
    fillings, pizza toppings, sausages, and beef jerky made from
    ground or chopped meat. Manufacturers are not required to
    identify AMR beef on food labels.

  12. Boron Elgar said:

    Actually, the citation you quote, which is quite
    interesting and talks of a survey among a sample of meat
    producers (34 in one and 25 in another) certainly indicates
    that are some with CNS tissue in their products, but this
    says absolutely nothing whatsoever about "hot dogs
    hamburgers, pizza toppings, taco fillers."

    It's common knowledge that AMR products are used in these
    items. You can find this reference for yourself. I'm done
    doing your homework.

    -sw

  13. "Boron Elgar" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    messag

    Quoted message said:

    On Sat, 20 Mar 2004 15:43:58 -0600, Steve Wertz
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:

    is as important to quote statistics and stories accurately
    and without bias or inflammatory exaggeration. Inaccuracy
    or bias in reportage does no one any good.


    Imo, it's only important if you assume you know which
    sources of info are accurate/unbiased. Do you trust the
    USDA?? (trivia: the No.2 person & the PR wench came to the
    USDA from the Cattlemen's Ass'n.)

    sidenote: A major wire service, UPI, had been trying for
    months to get verification from the USDA that 20,000 cattle
    had been tested. Seems to me, it's be easily obtainable if
    it were documented.

    ps: from all my MC reading (still on my crashed HD), I no
    longer believe the feed is the causitive agent. The
    same feed supposedly responsible for the major outbreak
    in the UK, had been exported to many other countries
    for decades.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.