Ed prochak said:Is there a discussion group on the runners world web site? Presumably it's moderated? (hate to see
you leave here, but if you want clean discussions it might be an option worth considering.)
RW has some good discussion groups, esp. for trail/ultra for some things (slow sometimes also),
which may not be applicable for this person. For me, it's a nice in between for r.r and the ultra
list, although I seldom post and only read about half the topics (I hate browser-based forums). I'm
not sure that it's moderated, but you have to register to post (not to read).
One of the big differences there is they have everything split into a different groups - beginners,
training, injuries, nutrition, training, masters, high school, marathon, etc. That is, it looks like
the beginners are left to flounder on their own or maybe some kind, more experienced souls visit
occasionally. I think the groups lack cross-fertilization of ideas by doing that. OTOH, it does
provide a friendlier environment for certain types of discussions.
I far prefer r.r for most things because you get a better mix of ideas - and filters work wonders.
Newsreaders are faster than browsers, at least for me. And search capabilities are much superior
here via google. Some types of questions I'm more likely to ask in RW trail forum since they have
more experience in certain things there, and there's more Alaskans there.
Quoted message said:
try putting together the votes for creating a moderated group. (Key is finding volunteers with the
time and skill to moderate.)
FWIW, there's a moderated and unmoderated mt bike ng. The unmoderated is far more active and seems
to have the hard-core mt bikers, although I don't visit the moderated one much any more - once I
found the other. With the moderated, if the moderator is out of town, it may take days for posts to
appear, but that might be an artifact of that particular group.
Quoted message said:
Funny is that what has begun to annoy me more are the crossposted threads that are totally OFF
TOPIC: things about Iraq or eating disorders, or others. Groups are named by topic for a reason!
I just hit "ignore thread" at the first sign of one of those.
Dot
--
"Success is different things to different people" -Bernd Heinrich in Racing the Antelope