"JMW" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:Steve Freides said:Steve said:I'm as uneducated as they come where weights and gym equipment are
concerned. I want to buy a weight bench or SOME sort of weight
training
equipment that will take up very little space in my cramped
apartment
and still afford me a reasonable workout. I considered getting a
used
soloflex machine, but they're too big. I need something small. I
just
don't know whether anything out there takes up so little space while
still affording a real workout. Maybe this just isn't realistic.
Any thoughts?
Yes, buy a kettlebell, the kettlebell book, and the kettlebell DVD.
If
you're into competition powerlifting or having a big bench press, this
won't do, but if you're after excellent strength and conditioning,
it's
just the ticket and it'll cost you about $150. For that money or
less,
you can also choose dumbbells and see http://www.stumptuous.com and
get
good dumbbell-only workouts there, but kettlebells are fun, take very
little space, travel easily in a car, and offer a wider variety of
exercises than a dumbbell.
Your prejudices are showing.
Yes, absolutely, but if you want to get into semantics here, "prejudice"
means to pre-judge or otherwise form an opinion without sufficient
knowledge or facts, which is not what I'm doing. I've experienced many
kinds of weights, I've lifted enough to collect three age-group deadlift
world records in AAU powerlifting, and I've formed a judgement, not a
pre-judgement, based on my experiences. Kettlebells aren't the only
things I train with - my online training log shows exactly what I do
every day - but for someone like the OP here, looking for an effective
workout in a small space, the kettlebell starter package DragonDoor
sells (one kb, one dvd, one book) is, based on what I know and what I've
experienced, an excellent idea.
Quoted message said:I'm sure if I was feeling creative, I
could come up with just as many novel movements to use with dumbbells
as Pavel can dream up for kettlebells.
Yes and no. There are movements that one can do with all three -
barbell, dumbbell, kettlebell - with relatively minor differences, and
there are movements where the form of the weight really does make a
difference. There is, e.g., nothing I can think of that gets you ready
to lift heavy stones, strongman style, that you can do with any of the
three implements I listed. Some things are pretty specific. The
kettlebell swing is _the_ basic kettlebell movement, and it doesn't work
as well with anything else. You can do swings with a dumbbell but it is
really not the same, and I have yet to meet a single person who has done
both who disagrees. And you can get a great workout, increasing overall
strength, explosiveness, helping with weight loss, etc., by doing
nothing except swinging a kettlebell every day.
Quoted message said:And kettlebells come in one
weight per kettlebell. Dumbbell handles weigh five pounds and can be
increased by plates up to about 80 pounds in five-pound increments.
Yes, this is a disadvantage of kettlebells, I agree. I own several
Olympic barbells and a pile of weights, and I use them daily. I own
several kettlebells and I use them daily as well. I also own both 1"
and Olympic dumbbell handles and they sit for months at a time untouched
in the corner of my basement. If I had $50, I'd get an adjustable
dumbbell set. If I had $150, I'd get the kettlebell starter kit. If I
had more money and more room, I'd get, in this order, an Olympic 300 lb.
starter set, rubber floor mats, the kettlebell starter kit, and a power
rack. The kettlebell starter kit isn't my first choice, an Olympic
weight set is, but if space is limited, it moves to the head of the
list.
My training log may be seen here for anyone interested.
http://www.kbnj.com/log.htm
-S-
http://www.kbnj.com