General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Soft Shell Crabs

Started by D.Currie · · Last activity · 12 posts · 253 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
2 June 2006
Last activity
15 June 2006
Original author
D.Currie
Posts
12
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
253
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–12 of 12
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell crabs
    once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were about
    the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really supposed
    to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be softer? Is
    it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to have
    resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    --
    Donna

  2. D.Currie said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell crabs
    once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were about
    the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really supposed
    to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be softer? Is
    it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to have
    resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    --
    Donna

    Anytime I have has softsheel crads they have been tempura fried. A bit
    crunching but nothing like shrimp shells IMO.

    Jessica


  3. Quoted message said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell


    crabs

    Quoted message said:

    once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were about
    the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really


    supposed

    Quoted message said:

    to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be softer?


    Is

    Quoted message said:

    it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes a


    difference?

    Quoted message said:


    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to have
    resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    --
    Donna


    How hard the sells are depends on how long it's been since the [censored] shed
    it's shell. If you get them right after the shedding, then it's very soft...
    after a while, the new shell starts to get harder, and at some point you
    can't eat it. I've had them where you couldn't detect much shell, and have
    had them like you are describing. In the latter case,you just need to eat
    around the hard stuff. I still like them though

    Larry T

  4. Jessica V. said:


    Anytime I have has softsheel crads they have been tempura fried. A bit
    crunching but nothing like shrimp shells IMO.

    Jessica

    Have you ever had shrimp-in-their-shells tempura?

    -bwg

  5. "D.Currie" wrote >

    Quoted message said:


    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell
    crabs once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were
    about the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to
    eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really
    supposed to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be
    softer? Is it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes
    a difference?

    No, Donna, if the crab you ate was chewy, like shrimp shells, then you had
    what is called a "paper shell". To be an actual soft crab, it is harvested
    immediately it sheds its shell - within an hour or two, the shell starts to
    harden. Many seafood restaurants here (and a lot of individuals) keep what
    they call a "sloughing tank", which holds those crabs which are about to
    molt. When they do, they're either cooked as soon as possible or
    quick-frozen.

    Try them again but make sure you're given the real McCoy. They're delicious
    just dipped in a little flour and fried in butter. One of my favorite
    foods!

    Dora

  6. D.Currie said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell crabs
    once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were about
    the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really supposed
    to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be softer? Is
    it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to have
    resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    In my experience, softer than shrimp shells. I'm thinking quality or age
    of the crabs was the issue.

  7. "limey" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:T60gg.790$9c7.527@trnddc06...

    Quoted message said:


    "D.Currie" wrote >

    Quoted message said:


    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell
    crabs once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells were
    about the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I care to
    eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really
    supposed to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to be
    softer? Is it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that makes
    a difference?

    No, Donna, if the crab you ate was chewy, like shrimp shells, then you
    had what is called a "paper shell". To be an actual soft crab, it is
    harvested immediately it sheds its shell - within an hour or two, the
    shell starts to harden. Many seafood restaurants here (and a lot of
    individuals) keep what they call a "sloughing tank", which holds those
    crabs which are about to molt. When they do, they're either cooked as
    soon as possible or quick-frozen.

    Try them again but make sure you're given the real McCoy. They're
    delicious just dipped in a little flour and fried in butter. One of my
    favorite foods!

    Dora

    That makes sense. The guy on TV was saying that they flash freeze them on
    the boats, which is why you never see them fresh unless you're right there
    when they're caught. The one I ate (or tried to eat) definitely had a shell
    of some kind on it. It was quite some time back, and I hadn't wanted to try
    it again if it was going to be the same thing.

    I'm used to dismantling things like lobsters or hard shelled crabs, and I
    peel my shrimp, but that soft-shelled crab was just unpleasant. Too
    complicated to peel like a shrimp, and not hard enough to crack open like a
    lobster, but eating it was just yucky.

    Maybe next time I see it somewhere, I'll give it a try.

    Thanks,

    Donna

  8. "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell
    crabs once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells
    were about the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I
    care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really
    supposed to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to
    be softer? Is it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that
    makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to
    have resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    I ate them once, in a restaurant, about 40 years ago, on a date with some
    long-ago-forgotten lady. I had the same experience as you did. I didn't
    care for them and have never eaten them since, rashly assuming that's the
    way everyone prepared them.

    --
    Untie the two knots to email me

    A politician thinks of the next election;
    a statesman, the next generation.

    James Freeman Clarke

  9. Here's a link to the recipe in question if anyone is hungry or curious:
    http://tlc.discovery.com/fansites/takehomechef/recipes/episode111.html

    I really like the show and def want to try some of what Curtis is
    cookin!

    Ken Knecht said:

    "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell
    crabs once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells
    were about the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I
    care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really
    supposed to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to
    be softer? Is it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that
    makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to
    have resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    I ate them once, in a restaurant, about 40 years ago, on a date with some
    long-ago-forgotten lady. I had the same experience as you did. I didn't
    care for them and have never eaten them since, rashly assuming that's the
    way everyone prepared them.

    --
    Untie the two knots to email me

    A politician thinks of the next election;
    a statesman, the next generation.

    James Freeman Clarke

  10. Quoted message said:

    Here's a link to the recipe in question if anyone is hungry or curious:
    http://tlc.discovery.com/fansites/takehomechef/recipes/episode111.html

    I really like the show and def want to try some of what Curtis is
    cookin!

    Ken Knecht said:

    "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Anyone seen the Take Home Chef on TLC? Is it just me, or does he seem
    nervous? But I digress.

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell
    crabs once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing. The shells
    were about the same texture as shrimp shells, which aren't something I
    care to eat.

    So now I'm wondering...are the shells on soft shelled crabs really
    supposed to be that chewy? Like shrimp shells? Or are they supposed to
    be softer? Is it a preparation thing, or the quality of the crabs that
    makes a difference?

    And by the way, the computer issues that were kept me busy seem to
    have resolved themselves. Now I just have to catch up on my reading.

    I ate them once, in a restaurant, about 40 years ago, on a date with some
    long-ago-forgotten lady. I had the same experience as you did. I didn't
    care for them and have never eaten them since, rashly assuming that's the
    way everyone prepared them.

    Crabs Benedictine

    "The story goes that the monks in some monastery of the Benedictine
    order in France discovered in the course of their meditations and
    experiments on refinements of the calm pleasures of the refectory, that
    crabs as well as chickens might be milk fed, and since that happy day
    full many a tender young crustacean has been torn from its seaweed bed,
    to be drowned luxuriously in rich custard or eggnog sauce as a prelude
    to immolation on the gridiron.

    The ancient recipe of the brothers of the black cowl prescribes a bath
    of milk and eggs for the selected young soft shell crabs that are to be
    treated in the Benedictine manner. The crabs are washed, but not
    dressed or killed, and then they are placed in a deep bowl and immersed
    in a rich mixture of beaten eggs and milk, and left to enjoy or lament
    their peculiar fate for at least three hours. If the bowl is full and
    the victim lively, a heavy cover should be provided to guard against a
    break for liberty.

    After the ablution the crabs are drained and dressed as usual; the
    pulpy substance is torn from the undersides of the shell points, and the
    apron stripped from the lower shell. Then they are dredged lightly in
    flour seasoned with salt and pepper, dipped in well beaten eggs, covered
    with finely sifted bread crumbs and fried to a golden brown in a kettle
    of hot oil or lard. Drain on absorbent paper and serve at once in a
    nest of crisp fried curled parsley (sprigs of clean parsley, dried,
    dipped into a light batter sprig by sprig, plunged into hot deep fat and
    removed at once) dotted here and there with small lemon or lime quarters.

    This writer knows little enough of the physiology of crabs, but is
    satisfied by repeated experiences and demonstrations, that they do
    imbibe enough of the egg and milk to retain an appreciable quantity in
    their tissues; and he has evolved some refinements in the honoured
    tradition of the epicurean friars as follows:

    Crabs Epicurean Friars Style

    Instead of using merely eggs and milk as indicated in Crabs Benedictine
    a rich, unsweetened eggnog bath is prepared as follows:

    One pint of French Cognac, 1/2 pint of Jamaica rum, 1/2 cup each of
    applejack (apple brandy) and peach brandy, 12 fresh eggs, separated, 2
    quarts milk, or equal parts milk and thin cream or undiluted evaporated
    milk, 1 tsp. of salt and freshly grated nutmeg. Beat the yolks until
    light; gradually beat in the French brandy so as to cook the egg yolks;
    then the combined other liquors. Now, gradually beat in the cold milk
    or combined milk and thin cream; lastly, fold in the stiffly beaten egg
    whites flavoured to taste with nutmeg, salt and pepper.

    Instead of rum, you may substitute sherry, madeira, or marsala, using
    no other liquor -- that is, use about 1 pint of either.

    No large quantity of the eggnog is needed if the crabs are packed
    closely in a deep earthenware or enamelled or porcelain vessel. But do
    not use aluminium or copper utensils. Cover with a heavy plate and weight.

    During the usual cleaning operations, the crabs are handled gently,
    without pressure or squeezing, and dredged with seasoned flour as soon
    as possible, then well covered with beaten egg and fresh sifted crumbs
    of bread crusts. The frying basket and the kettle of good cooking oil
    complete the process to perfection, and a Benedictine abbot could ask
    nothing better than a serving with crisp watercress and quartered lemons.

    In these days of budgets and lightly equipped kitchens and kitchenettes,
    the deep kettle and the wire frying basket are not very common utensils;
    nor is olive oil bought in gallons by American families, unless they
    have learned that there is thrift and health in its use. Crabs,
    however, even for Benedictine or Epicurean Friars fashion, may be cooked
    quite satisfactorily in the frying pan, without immersion, if they are
    sauteed carefully in plenty of butter, oil or fat. Turn and shuffle
    them about deftly with a spatula, to avoid burning and drying, and brown
    them as evenly as possible. Maitre d'Hotel butter, sauce tartare and
    sauce ravigote are the first thoughts for crabs, but for the delicate
    flavour of those fattened on egg and sherry or other wine or cordial or
    liqueur, a simple Maitre d'Hotel butter is the safest thing."

    From a private collection of recipes by a former head chef of the
    Waldorf Astoria hotel, New York City, circa 1920.

    My own experience with these recipes is that while delicious and well
    worth trying they are more of what i would make as a 'party' food, or
    for some special occasion. The former rather than the latter is quite
    good and worth experimenting with.
    ---
    JL

  11. D.Currie said:

    He cooked soft shelled crabs and everyone loved them. I ate soft shell crabs
    once, and didn't like them. It was a texture thing.

    <snip>

    My first taste of soft shell crabs was at Harry's on Hanover Square in
    the Wall
    Street Area of Manhattan. This was about 40 years ago. I recall that it
    was a
    Friday lunch time in late May or early June. The front bar area was
    packed with
    mostly guys who I assume had ended their work week and had no plan to
    return
    to the office. The crab was wonderful and served with a huge pile of
    shoe string
    type fried potatoes.

  12. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Here's a link to the recipe in question if anyone is hungry or curious:
    http://tlc.discovery.com/fansites/takehomechef/recipes/episode111.html

    I really like the show and def want to try some of what Curtis is
    cookin!

    I've copied some of his recipes for later use, and tried one so far.

    I'm a little curious about how much of that show is re-created, though.
    There was one episode where Curtis and the woman walk in, and no one's home.
    But there's a 4-year-old in the house. So either the kid was with her when
    she was shopping and they re-filmed that and hid the kid in the house for
    the walk-in part, or someone was home with the kid and they didn't want to
    use that person in the episode.

    There are other things that seem curious as well, Like one ep where the
    woman and Curtis are peeling some veggies using identical peelers, but the
    woman seems perplexed as to how to use it. So he probably brought them with.
    But on another ep, there's a woman who's trying to peel a carrot with a
    cheese plane.

    And I noticed that everyone seems to have the same roasting pan...so I
    wonder how much of the kitchen stuff really belongs to the people, and how
    much of it Curtis brings with him.

    Donna

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.