Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Something we knew already (overweight commuters)

Started by eddiec · · Last activity · 46 posts · 3,057 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
19 January 2006
Last activity
24 January 2006
Original author
eddiec
Posts
46
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
3,057
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 46
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Fat chance of losing weight for commuting drivers
    drive.com.auarticle.aspx

    Julie Robotham, Medical Editor
    The Sydney Morning Herald
    Thursday January 19 2006

    Driving to work can make you fat, says NSW research that estimates for the first time the proportion of people overweight because of car dependence.

    People who took their cars to work were 13 per cent more likely to be overweight or obese than those who walked, cycled or used public transport, regardless of their income level, the survey of 6810 employed people found. The further people had to drive each day, the greater their weight increase.

    The study was the first in the world specifically to examine the effects of different types of commuting on weight, said Chris Rissel, the director of the Health Promotion Unit of Sydney South- West Area Health Service. The findings were consistent with previous US research that looked at the number of hours people spent in their cars, finding the chance of being overweight increased 6 per cent for each additional hour they spent behind the wheel, associate Professor Rissel said.

    The NSW study revealed that even short, regular car trips significantly reduced people's opportunity to get sufficient exercise in the course of their working week.

    "Movement is cumulative. It is incremental physical activity during the day," Professor Rissel said. "Still, about half the population don't get [sufficient exercise]." Adults should aim to take about 10,000 steps a day, he said, and even a short walk to the bus stop or train station could help them achieve this.

    Overall, 49 per cent of the workers in the health survey were overweight or obese, and two-thirds drove their car to work. Seven per cent walked, 2 per cent cycled and 6 per cent worked at home.

    The findings are due to be published this week in the International Journal of Obesity.

  2. I thought this was going to be a thread about big fat bicycle commuters, with paniered commuting bikes, fully loaded to hilt with laptops, lunches, clothes, work, kitchen sink, weetbix, booties!

  3. I only see a few overweight people cycling.
    None of the bicycle commuters I come across would be regarded as fat, although I have seen a few chubbie public transport commuters.

    I've noticed some wierd set ups with some cycle-commuters though.
    Stuff like a am/fm radio duct taped to the 'bars blaring out Radio National, and spray jackets in January. Cardbroad mudguards pop up every now & again. Very worn/torn T-shirts.
    and yes, the waft of stinky riding gear from some die 'ards.

  4. Marx SS said:


    I've noticed some wierd set ups with some cycle-commuters though.
    Stuff like a am/fm radio duct taped to the 'bars blaring out Radio National, and spray jackets in January. Cardbroad mudguards pop up every now & again. Very worn/torn T-shirts.
    and yes, the waft of stinky riding gear from some die 'ards.

    Ive seen that guy!! he rides a lot along the foreshore bike path, usually see him when I am running, has to be him though... radio taped to the handle bars! and it is always on Radio National..... and he is ALWAYS wearing the spray jacket!

    I think he uses my dads old philosophy... SWEAT IT OUT... he used to go running with a garbage under his track suit, back in England, so he would sweat more!!

  5. MikeyOz said:

    Ive seen that guy!! he rides a lot along the foreshore bike path, usually see him when I am running, has to be him though... radio taped to the handle bars! and it is always on Radio National..... and he is ALWAYS wearing the spray jacket!

    I think he uses my dads old philosophy... SWEAT IT OUT... he used to go running with a garbage under his track suit, back in England, so he would sweat more!!

    He doesnt have a huge dolphin torch taped on there as well does he?
    I reckon i have seen plenty of overweight cyclists along beach rd stretching that lycra to its limits..

  6. Quoted message said:

    People who took their cars to work were 13 per cent more likely to be
    overweight

    I'm surprised it's only 13%.

  7. coowoowoo said:
    MikeyOz said:

    Ive seen that guy!! he rides a lot along the foreshore bike path,
    usually see him when I am running, has to be him though... radio taped
    to the handle bars! and it is always on Radio National..... and he is
    ALWAYS wearing the spray jacket!

    I think he uses my dads old philosophy... SWEAT IT OUT... he used to go
    running with a garbage under his track suit, back in England, so he
    would sweat more!!

    He doesnt have a huge dolphin torch taped on there as well does he?
    I reckon i have seen plenty of overweight cyclists along beach rd
    stretching that lycra to its limits..

    Everyone has to start somewhere. When I see an overweight cyclist* I
    hope they keep it up, as they may just end up a lot healthier and less
    out of shape.

    * many would suggest that I am one of them! But, I'm really a sprinter
    🙂

  8. Jules said:
    Quoted message said:

    People who took their cars to work were 13 per cent more likely to be
    overweight

    Quoted message said:

    I'm surprised it's only 13%.

    13% more likely than the 50% of the population who are overweight. That
    would be 56.5% of drivers are overweight.

    Theo

  9. MikeyOz said:

    I thought this was going to be a thread about big fat bicycle commuters,
    with paniered commuting bikes, fully loaded to hilt with laptops,
    lunches, clothes, work, kitchen sink, weetbix, booties!

    I resemble that!
    --
    Cheers | ~~ __@
    Euan | ~~ _-\<,
    Melbourne, Australia | ~ (*)/ (*)

  10. coowoowoo said:

    I reckon i have seen plenty of overweight cyclists along beach rd
    stretching that lycra to its limits..

    Exercise is just part of it, diet counts for a lot. Eighty / twenty in
    favor of diet I believe.
    --
    Cheers | ~~ __@
    Euan | ~~ _-\<,
    Melbourne, Australia | ~ (*)/ (*)

  11. eddiec said:

    The findings are due to be published this week in the International
    Journal of Obesity.

    WTF does the world need a magazine about obesity? Is there
    anyone on the planet who doesn't know why people get fat, and
    what they should do about it?

    --
    Home page: http://members.westnet.com.au/mvw

  12. I think something along the lines of the "African women don't get fat:
    the refugee diet" is appropriate here.

    Rich people get fat, die. Do I care? No.

    Michael Warner said:
    eddiec said:

    The findings are due to be published this week in the International
    Journal of Obesity.

    WTF does the world need a magazine about obesity? Is there
    anyone on the planet who doesn't know why people get fat, and
    what they should do about it?

    --
    Home page: http://members.westnet.com.au/mvw

  13. I must admit, most of the funniest people I know are overweight.

    Some skinny people can be so vindictive & [censored].

  14. neuroinf said:

    Rich people get fat, die. Do I care? No.

    Don't you worry that you might win Lotto one day and become rich?

    At least you won't need to worry about your friends sponging off you.

    Theo

  15. neuroinf said:

    I think something along the lines of the "African women don't get fat:
    the refugee diet" is appropriate here.


    Or as a colleague of mine put it, `you don't see fat people in concentration camps, do you?'

    Quoted post said:


    Rich people get fat, die. Do I care? No.


    What about poor people?

    Fact: the lower the socio-economic group the higher the likelihood of obesity. The higher the socio-economic group the lower the liklihood of obestity.

  16. EuanB said:

    Or as a colleague of mine put it, `you don't see fat people in concentration camps, do you?'

    What about poor people?

    Fact: the lower the socio-economic group the higher the likelihood of obesity. The higher the socio-economic group the lower the liklihood of obestity.

    Now this is something i have never quite figured out.. The lower socio- economic groups in theory should have less money to bandy about. In order to be overweight they must be consuming more sugary drinks and junk food. This of course requires a lot more money then buying fresh fruit/veg and drinking water etc.
    So, why are they more likely to be overweight?

  17. coowoowoo said:

    Now this is something i have never quite figured out.. The lower socio- economic groups in theory should have less money to bandy about. In order to be overweight they must be consuming more sugary drinks and junk food. This of course requires a lot more money then buying fresh fruit/veg and drinking water etc.
    So, why are they more likely to be overweight?

    think it might have something to do with, buying cheap, highly processed, pre-packaged food, no nutrition, no good for you what so ever, and probably not very motivated to do much exercise... I guess are a couple of things... lets face it, it gets more and more expensive to buy truely fresh healthy food, I buy the food from the market every weekend, meat, chicken etc... and goddam it, it never gets cheaper!

  18. MikeyOz said:

    I thought this was going to be a thread about big fat bicycle commuters, with paniered commuting bikes, fully loaded to hilt with laptops, lunches, clothes, work, kitchen sink, weetbix, booties!

    I thought it was going to be about me :o .

  19. In aus.bicycle on Fri, 20 Jan 2006 13:17:45 +1100

    MikeyOz said:


    coowoowoo said:

    Now this is something i have never quite figured out.. The lower socio-
    economic groups in theory should have less money to bandy about. In
    order to be overweight they must be consuming more sugary drinks and
    junk food. This of course requires a lot more money then buying fresh
    fruit/veg and drinking water etc.
    So, why are they more likely to be overweight?

    think it might have something to do with, buying cheap, highly
    processed, pre-packaged food, no nutrition, no good for you what so
    ever, and probably not very motivated to do much exercise... I guess

    Or not have the chance.

    A shop assistant on her feet for a 12 hour shift isn't going to then
    go jogging, can't afford a gym membershitp or have the time to go, and
    probably doesn't live that close to work.

    A cleaner might work a 12 hour shift too, and is also not likely to
    live close to work, plus might be moving more but not aerobically
    useful movement.

    Both will be doing hard but not fat-burning work and be too tired to
    spend another hour tiring themselves more.

    Also, fresh fruit and veg is not as available in poor neighbourhoods
    as you might believe. Depends on where - most ethnic areas are
    relatively well supplied, but when I tried to get decent stuff in
    Blacktown I scurried back to (very asian) campsie where processed is
    the exception not the norm. Big shopping centres have fruit and veg,
    but often quite restricted and looking good but not tasting good.

    If you work long hours in a [censored] job then more hours shopping and
    cooking and exercising's not high on the list.

    Zebee

  20. Michael Warner said:
    eddiec said:

    The findings are due to be published this week in the International
    Journal of Obesity.

    WTF does the world need a magazine about obesity?

    Simple, then you can claim to be a legitimate researcher, register a
    charity and get peeps to send you tax deductable donations to fund your
    research and never have to work again, other than a few journal articles
    that are noticable light on amount of data. Well, that is the way they
    do it in other medical fields.

    Quoted message said:

    Is there anyone on the planet who doesn't know why people get fat,
    and what they should do about it?

    Surprisingly, the answer is probably yes. aka when you start to look for
    real data to support a lot of medical beliefs, it can be rather scarce,
    plus TT, ACA, etc really need more "medical researchers" to add weight
    to their fluffing.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.