General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Tr - Munro - Am Basteir

Started by Lindsay · · Last activity · 6 posts · 213 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
2 October 2007
Last activity
4 October 2007
Original author
Lindsay
Posts
6
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
213
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–6 of 6
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Am Basteir

    10 September 2007

    I still had two mountains to climb on Skye for another completion of
    the Munros on the Island and due to bad weather I was unable to climb
    them the previous week so this was a day visit to the Island to try
    and summit Am Basteir.

    I set off from the car park at the Sligachan Hotel on the main road
    north from the mainland to Portree. I walked along the path that
    crossed the Allt Dearg Mor and Allt Dearg Beag by footbridges. This
    is the path used to access the 'tourist route' to Sgurr nan Gillean.
    Higher up the path spit, one being the 'tourist route' and the other
    led to Sgurr nan Gillean's Pinnacle Ridge.

    I followed the Pinnacle Ridge route and met a father and son who were
    intending climbing the Ridge. The father had last climbed this route
    forty years ago. At the foot of the Pinnacle Ridge and above the
    Bhasteir Gorge I cut across to Coire a'Bhasteir following traces of a
    path. Once in the Coire a scree path led to Bealach a'Basteir where
    it was rather cool and windy.

    The next section of this walk needed my full concentration to avoid
    where possible any basalt rock and to select the ideal route.
    Initially this was relatively easy but then the ridge became a bit
    narrower. I was aware there was a couple in front of me with a
    collie dog.

    On approaching the gap in the ridge I could hear the couple who were
    obviously using a rope to cross this obstacle. The friendly collie
    dog approached me which was a bit off putting as it was at head height
    and obviously wanted some attention. At this point I descended to the
    south over some loose stones, which were a bit of a concern, and down
    a couple of ledges to a stone filled gully. I climbed this gully and
    rejoined the route to Am Basteir. It was then only a short walk to
    the summit cairn with a wee scramble near the summit. Here I met the
    couple I saw earlier. One guy was from Dundee and was on his
    penultimate Munro and the other chap, who owned the collie dog, was
    his guide.

    The summit was cloud covered despite the fact that it had occasionally
    lifted clear of the summit as I ascended the mountain. I sat and ate
    my lunch at the summit cairn and the cloud tried to lift and gave me
    glimpses of the Bhasteir Tooth, Sgurr a'Fionn Choire and Sgurr nan
    Gillean.

    I later left the summit and returned to the bealach by the ascent
    route. I found the descent harder because the gully had lots of loose
    stones. I eventually reached the bealach and had views into Lota
    Corrie, Loch Scavaig and the Southern Cuillin Ridge. I then followed
    the route I had taken in the morning back to the Sligachan Hotel after
    a successful although tough day.

    Time taken - 5.25 hours.
    Distance - 11 kilometres.
    Height climbed - 880 metres.

    Photographs taken on this walk can be seen at:
    http://www.caledoniahilltreks.com/gallery07/am_basteir_sept07/index.htm

    Lindsay
    www.caledoniahilltreks.com

  2. Lindsay <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    On approaching the gap in the ridge I could hear the couple who were
    obviously using a rope to cross this obstacle.

    Was this "The Bad Step"? That's where I came unstuck in poor conditions
    with no rope and gave up as I could not find the by-pass route.

    Quoted message said:

    At this point I descended to the
    south over some loose stones, which were a bit of a concern, and down
    a couple of ledges to a stone filled gully.

    This is what I am assuming is the route that by-passes The Bad Step and I
    couldn't find it. Any land marks to look out for?

    Quoted message said:

    I climbed this gully and
    rejoined the route to Am Basteir. It was then only a short walk to
    the summit cairn with a wee scramble near the summit.

  3. bejay be_jayukatkillspam_yahoo_co_uk said:

    Lindsay <[email hidden]> wrote innews:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    On approaching the gap in the ridge I could hear the couple who were
    obviously using a rope to cross this obstacle.

    Was this "The Bad Step"? That's where I came unstuck in poor conditions
    with no rope and gave up as I could not find the by-pass route.

    Quoted message said:

    At this point I descended to the
    south over some loose stones, which were a bit of a concern, and down
    a couple of ledges to a stone filled gully.

    This is what I am assuming is the route that by-passes The Bad Step and I
    couldn't find it. Any land marks to look out for?

    Quoted message said:

    I climbed this gully and
    rejoined the route to Am Basteir. It was then only a short walk to
    the summit cairn with a wee scramble near the summit.- Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    Hi bejay

    Yes this is the route to avoid the bad step. I went almost as far as
    the bad step and then descended left angling away from the summit for
    around 30 metres until I could see a double set of ledges which led to
    the stony gully. These ledges are a bit tricky unless you are a
    climber. The first ledge I had to scamble along before descending to
    the next one. Worth making a mark in the gully (as long as you
    destroy it later) where you descended for the return route. You
    should also return to the ridge when come back from the summit or you
    will end up too low to get back to the bealach.

    Not easy if you are just a walker like myself. Climbers should have
    no problems except for the loose stones and rocks.

    Lindsay
    www.caledoniahilltreks.com

  4. In message <[email hidden]>,
    Lindsay <[email hidden]> writes

    Quoted message said:
    bejay be_jayukatkillspam_yahoo_co_uk said:

    Lindsay <[email hidden]> wrote
    innews:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    On approaching the gap in the ridge I could hear the couple who were
    obviously using a rope to cross this obstacle.

    Was this "The Bad Step"? That's where I came unstuck in poor conditions
    with no rope and gave up as I could not find the by-pass route.

    Quoted message said:

    At this point I descended to the
    south over some loose stones, which were a bit of a concern, and down
    a couple of ledges to a stone filled gully.

    This is what I am assuming is the route that by-passes The Bad Step and I
    couldn't find it. Any land marks to look out for?

    Quoted message said:

    I climbed this gully and
    rejoined the route to Am Basteir. It was then only a short walk to
    the summit cairn with a wee scramble near the summit.- Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    Hi bejay

    Yes this is the route to avoid the bad step. I went almost as far as
    the bad step and then descended left angling away from the summit for
    around 30 metres until I could see a double set of ledges which led to
    the stony gully. These ledges are a bit tricky unless you are a
    climber. The first ledge I had to scamble along before descending to
    the next one. Worth making a mark in the gully (as long as you
    destroy it later) where you descended for the return route. You
    should also return to the ridge when come back from the summit or you
    will end up too low to get back to the bealach.

    Not easy if you are just a walker like myself. Climbers should have
    no problems except for the loose stones and rocks.


    There is an easier way for walkers. This is described in Noel Williams
    excellent Skye Scrambles and involves taking a faint path where the
    ridge starts to steepen. Williams gives this route a Grade 2 and the
    descent down to the ledges just before the Bad Step as Difficult. He
    gives the Bad Step as "at least Severe (harder for those of average
    reach". Before the 1990s the Bad Step was much easier and I did it a
    couple of times without any rock climbing equipment. However sometime in
    the early 1990s there was a rockfall and it became much harder. I
    discovered this in 1996 when I found I couldn't reach the first foothold
    descending to the gap. We had climbing gear with us and placed a sling
    round a knob at the top of the gap. Holding onto this I could lower
    myself until I reached the foothold. We left the sling in place for our
    return along the ridge.
    --
    Chris Townsend

    http://www.auchnarrow.demon.co.uk

  5. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > On approaching the gap in the ridge I could hear the couple who were
    > obviously using a rope to cross this obstacle.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Was this "The Bad Step"? That's where I came unstuck in poor conditions
    with no rope and gave up as I could not find the by-pass route.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > At this point I descended to the
    > south over some loose stones, which were a bit of a concern, and down
    > a couple of ledges to a stone filled gully.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    This is what I am assuming is the route that by-passes The Bad Step and I
    couldn't find it. Any land marks to look out for?

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > I climbed this gully and
    > rejoined the route to Am Basteir. It was then only a short walk to
    > the summit cairn with a wee scramble near the summit.- Hide quoted text -

    There is an easier way for walkers. This is described in Noel Williams
    excellent Skye Scrambles and involves taking a faint path where the
    ridge starts to steepen. Williams gives this route a Grade 2 and the
    descent down to the ledges just before the Bad Step as Difficult. He
    gives the Bad Step as "at least Severe (harder for those of average
    reach". Before the 1990s the Bad Step was much easier and I did it a
    couple of times without any rock climbing equipment. However sometime in
    the early 1990s there was a rockfall and it became much harder. I
    discovered this in 1996 when I found I couldn't reach the first foothold
    descending to the gap. We had climbing gear with us and placed a sling
    round a knob at the top of the gap. Holding onto this I could lower
    myself until I reached the foothold. We left the sling in place for our
    return along the ridge.
    --
    Chris Townsend

    I'm of the opinion that the alternative route is more dangerous,
    though technically easier, than the "bad step" as you are on steep
    mucky slabs. The alternative route isn't at all obvious, even in good
    visibility.
    Since the bad step is only about 12 ft it makes sense to use a short
    rope to help you descend the step in ascent. The step is near the
    summit so you could leave the rope in place for your return, but it
    isn't really needed as the ascent of the bad step is much easier than
    descending it.

    brian johnson

  6. "Ancient Brit" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I'm of the opinion that the alternative route is more dangerous,
    though technically easier, than the "bad step" as you are on steep
    mucky slabs. The alternative route isn't at all obvious, even in good
    visibility.
    Since the bad step is only about 12 ft it makes sense to use a short
    rope to help you descend the step in ascent. The step is near the
    summit so you could leave the rope in place for your return, but it
    isn't really needed as the ascent of the bad step is much easier than
    descending it.


    When the urw group did this a few years ago we used the 'easy' route to the
    summit and climbed the bad step on the way back. It is indeed much easier
    going up than down and a long reach is an advantage.
    http://graham4228.fotopic.net/p14785319.html

    Graham

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.