Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Which of these calipers is better?

Started by Sir Ridesalot · · Last activity · 7 posts · 412 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
17 January 2007
Last activity
17 January 2007
Original author
Sir Ridesalot
Posts
7
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
412
Views / 30 days
4

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–7 of 7
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hi there.

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.

    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:

    1) Dia Compe 500

    or

    2) Exage Motion

    or

    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected

    Both these calipers wil fit the bicycle in question.

    Thank you very much.

    Peter

  2. Sir Ridesalot said:

    Hi there.

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.

    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:

    1) Dia Compe 500

    or

    2) Exage Motion

    or

    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected

    Both these calipers wil fit the bicycle in question.

    Thank you very much.

    Peter

    Addendum:

    OOps! I forgot to mention the brake levers I will be using with either
    calpers will be Campy Mirage Ergos 2001 model.

    I am thinking about having cantilever braze-ons added to the seatstays
    of this bicycle so the road calipers are a temporary measure.

  3. Sir Ridesalot said:
    Sir Ridesalot said:

    Hi there.

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.

    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:

    1) Dia Compe 500

    or

    2) Exage Motion

    or

    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected

    Both these calipers wil fit the bicycle in question.

    Thank you very much.

    Peter

    Addendum:

    OOps! I forgot to mention the brake levers I will be using with either
    calpers will be Campy Mirage Ergos 2001 model.

    IIRC, the Exage Motion is a dual pivot caliper; if so, it will be a
    better match for your brifters.

    Quoted message said:

    I am thinking about having cantilever braze-ons added to the seatstays
    of this bicycle so the road calipers are a temporary measure.

    Dual pivots work better with your brifters than do cantilevers.

  4. Ozark Bicycle said:
    Sir Ridesalot said:
    Sir Ridesalot said:

    Hi there.

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.

    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:

    1) Dia Compe 500

    or

    2) Exage Motion

    or

    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected

    Both these calipers wil fit the bicycle in question.

    Thank you very much.

    Peter

    Addendum:

    OOps! I forgot to mention the brake levers I will be using with either
    calpers will be Campy Mirage Ergos 2001 model.

    IIRC, the Exage Motion is a dual pivot caliper; if so, it will be a
    better match for your brifters.

    Quoted message said:

    I am thinking about having cantilever braze-ons added to the seatstays
    of this bicycle so the road calipers are a temporary measure.

    Dual pivots work better with your brifters than do cantilevers.

    Thanks.

    The Exage Motion calipers are the older single pivot type. So are the
    Dia Compe 500.

    If I do get braze ons for cantilevers it will be for clearance of the
    brakes in mud and snow.

    Peter

  5. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Sir Ridesalot said:

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.
    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:
    1) Dia Compe 500
    2) Exage Motion
    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected


    OOps! I forgot to mention the brake levers I will be using with either
    calpers will be Campy Mirage Ergos 2001 model.
    I am thinking about having cantilever braze-ons added to the seatstays
    of this bicycle so the road calipers are a temporary measure.

    Ozark Bicycle said:

    IIRC, the Exage Motion is a dual pivot caliper; if so, it will be a
    better match for your brifters.
    Dual pivots work better with your brifters than do cantilevers.

    Really? Why? I can't agree with that.
    My vote's with #3 - no significant difference

    p.s. BR-A350/BR-A450 are sidepulls, not DP
    --
    Andrew Muzi
    www.yellowjersey.org
    Open every day since 1 April, 1971

  6. A Muzi said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Sir Ridesalot wrote:
    > I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    > to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    > are the better calipers. They are both lower end.
    > Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    > Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:
    > 1) Dia Compe 500
    > 2) Exage Motion
    > 3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected
    OOps! I forgot to mention the brake levers I will be using with either
    calpers will be Campy Mirage Ergos 2001 model.
    I am thinking about having cantilever braze-ons added to the seatstays
    of this bicycle so the road calipers are a temporary measure.

    Ozark Bicycle said:

    IIRC, the Exage Motion is a dual pivot caliper; if so, it will be a
    better match for your brifters.
    Dual pivots work better with your brifters than do cantilevers.

    Really? Why? I can't agree with that.
    My vote's with #3 - no significant difference

    p.s. BR-A350/BR-A450 are sidepulls, not DP

    Yes, and my reply was based on the erroneous memory of Exage Motion
    calipers being dual pivot (hence the qualifier, "IIRC" - which I
    obviously did not). So, we agree, "no significant difference".

    Quoted message said:

    --
    Andrew Muzi
    www.yellowjersey.org
    Open every day since 1 April, 1971

  7. Sidepulls brakes usually provide better mudguard clearance than dual pivot
    brakes.

    "Sir Ridesalot" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi there.

    I have two sets of brake calipers I can use on my bicycle. I would like
    to put the most effective ones onto my bicycle but am not sure which
    are the better calipers. They are both lower end.

    Given they were to be used with identical brake blocks, such as Kool
    Stop Salmon, which calipers do you think would be most effective:

    1) Dia Compe 500

    or

    2) Exage Motion

    or

    3) Not much difference in stopping power to be expected

    Both these calipers wil fit the bicycle in question.

    Thank you very much.

    Peter

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.