Electronic Groupset Durability: How Long Do They Last?

[DeREk Clark]

Whats the point of even calling electronic groupsets durable when they cant even withstand a few seasons of regular use without starting to malfunction? Ive seen guys who barely ride 500 miles a year and their Di2 or EPS systems are already on their third or fourth replacement. And dont even get me started on the prices of these things - youd think theyd last at least a decade without needing a rebuild or replacement. But no, its like the manufacturers are intentionally designing them to fail so they can sell more units.

So, I want to know: whats the real lifespan of these electronic groupsets? Are they really as fragile as they seem, or are there some secret tips and tricks to making them last longer than a few years? And dont give me any of that proper maintenance nonsense - Im talking about real-world use, not some idealized scenario where the bike is cleaned and serviced after every ride.

 

[roadie_joe]

I'd expect at least a few weeks out of an electronic group set. They aren't built as well as the mechanical groups, and have buttons and gizmos so more to go wrong. Yes if you get a couple of weeks, you're doing well.

 

[allenpg]

While it's true that electronic groupsets can be pricey and may require occasional maintenance, it's important to remember that their durability has improved significantly over the years. Proper maintenance and care can extend the lifespan of these components. Additionally, electronic groupsets often offer advantages such as precise and consistent shifting, which can enhance your overall cycling experience. If you're concerned about cost, you might consider investing in a more affordable mechanical groupset while you build up your mileage and experience. Remember, the best groupset for you depends on your personal riding needs and budget.

 

[roadie_joe]

I disagree, they are the opposite to what you suggest, they are very much a consumable item with all their buttons a gizmos. 2-3 weeks is about the average lifespan, more if you ride less. Mechanical on the other hand will last 10 to 25 years without the need for any maintenance and it also shifts smoother, faster and more reliable. Do yourself a favor and avoid electronic anything.

 

[allenpg]

Your experience with electronic groupsets seems vastly different from mine and many others. While I can't speak to your specific situation, it's generally accepted that modern electronic groupsets are designed for longevity and improved performance, not as disposable items. Maintenance is a part of cycling, regardless of the groupset. If your electronic groupsets are failing within weeks, I'd suggest looking into potential causes or perhaps reaching out to the manufacturer. Your perspective on mechanical groupsets may hold true for some cases, but it's not a universal truth. The best groupset, as I mentioned before, depends on individual riding style and budget.