Road Cycling · Public discussion

bringing a bike on a plane

Started by Dr. Richard E. Hawkins · · Last activity · 41 posts · 1,511 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
23 March 2005
Last activity
31 March 2005
Original author
Dr. Richard E. Hawkins
Posts
41
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,511
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 41
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll be
    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    It's nothign spectalar; just for commuting a couple of miles each day.
    A Trek 4300 or some such that was the back to school sale a couple of
    years ago; fairly generic mountain bike with quick release front & back.

    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive? I've
    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is close
    to disposable . . .

    A luggage would also have to be transported, which would be an issue.
    If I could pack the bike this way, I could just pack in my old seabag
    and wear it aas a backpack . . .

    hawk
    --
    Richard E. Hawkins, Asst. Prof. of Economics /"\ ASCII ribbon campaign
    [email hidden] 111 Hiller (814) 375-4846 \ / against HTML mail
    Find commentary on law, economics, and X and postings.
    other issues of the day at dochawk.org! / \

  2. Dr. Richard E. Hawkins said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll be
    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive? I've
    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is close
    to disposable . . .

    There are more problems. It is very likely you will be charged $50-$75 --
    each way -- to ship the bike. The box may attract attention because of
    the metal bits, so you may have security problems.

    Better ideas:

    1) Rent. Not real easy to find in Las Vegas, but possible.
    2) Buy a junker there. More likely findable, less reliable and no on to
    complain to if it falls apart half-way to your convention.
    3) Buy a folding bike before you go. Those usually go as luggage, and
    some are sold with a box. Do this if you want to travel with a bike
    often. Money is obviously the limitation with this option.

    --

    David L. Johnson

    __o | As far as the laws of mathematics refer to reality, they are not
    _`\(,_ | certain, and as far as they are certain, they do not refer to
    (_)/ (_) | reality. -- Albert Einstein

  3. I know some airlines will let you take a bike for free without counting
    towards your two bag limit. I'm not sure, but I think they might even
    give you a bike box to pack it in.
    Your bike should be fine in one of those special boxes. I've had my new
    bike shipped across Canada in one and it was perfectly fine. You'll
    have to disassemble it a little though.

  4. (clip)Your bike should be fine in one of those special boxes. (clip)
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    Won't an LBS give you a shipping carton? They must throw away lots of 'em.
    I like the suggestion of buying a folder. I use my Dahon a lot, because it
    fits in my car. I drop my wife near the entrance of whatever (fair,
    festival, concert, etc.) She gets in line while I drive a mile or two to
    park the car free. In some cases, the decision to go or not go has been
    influenced by the ease and cost of parking.

  5. Dr. Richard E. Hawkins said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll


    be

    Quoted message said:

    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    It's nothign spectalar; just for commuting a couple of miles each


    day.

    Quoted message said:

    A Trek 4300 or some such that was the back to school sale a couple of
    years ago; fairly generic mountain bike with quick release front &


    back.

    Quoted message said:


    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive?


    I've

    Quoted message said:

    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is


    close

    Quoted message said:

    to disposable . . .

    A luggage would also have to be transported, which would be an issue.
    If I could pack the bike this way, I could just pack in my old seabag
    and wear it aas a backpack . . .

    hawk

    If you bring a bicycle on a plane, don't expect to get it back in good
    condition unless you put it in cast iron and then put the cast iron in
    cement. Do you see how things are handled and stored on a plane? My
    son is a snowboarder. I bought him the best, absolute best storage
    case for his snowboard. Well, it was a great case but the snowboard
    ended up "LOST." He finally got the snowboard back but the next time
    he traveled he rented equipment when he arrived. Saves alot of
    headache. When we travel to Tahoe, we have to take a connecting
    flight. No direct flights from Jersey to the Reno airport. We have
    learned to travel light. One carry on and a big purse. I can't tell you
    how many times our luggage was lost during the change in planes. I am
    going out there again in May, and it will be one carry on and a large
    purse. I have 20 minutes to make my connection. There is no way my
    luggage will NOT be lost. I think bringing a bike on a plane trip is
    just not worth it. But that's just my opinion. Plus storage for those
    items like golf clubs, skis, snowboards etc. is ridiculous. And it
    takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE. I love that word
    DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.
    All Good Things,
    Maggie

    Quoted message said:

    --
    Richard E. Hawkins, Asst. Prof. of Economics /"\ ASCII ribbon


    campaign

    Quoted message said:

    [email hidden] 111 Hiller (814) 375-4846 \ / against HTML


    mail

    Quoted message said:

    Find commentary on law, economics, and X and postings.
    other issues of the day at dochawk.org! / \

  6. Maggie said:
    Dr. Richard E. Hawkins said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll


    be

    Quoted message said:

    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as


    transportation.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    It's nothign spectalar; just for commuting a couple of miles each


    day.

    Quoted message said:

    A Trek 4300 or some such that was the back to school sale a couple


    of

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    years ago; fairly generic mountain bike with quick release front &


    back.

    Quoted message said:


    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive?


    I've

    Quoted message said:

    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is


    close

    Quoted message said:

    to disposable . . .

    A luggage would also have to be transported, which would be an


    issue.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    If I could pack the bike this way, I could just pack in my old


    seabag

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    and wear it aas a backpack . . .

    hawk

    If you bring a bicycle on a plane, don't expect to get it back in


    good

    Quoted message said:

    condition unless you put it in cast iron and then put the cast iron


    in

    Quoted message said:

    cement. Do you see how things are handled and stored on a plane? My
    son is a snowboarder. I bought him the best, absolute best storage
    case for his snowboard. Well, it was a great case but the snowboard
    ended up "LOST." He finally got the snowboard back but the next time
    he traveled he rented equipment when he arrived. Saves alot of
    headache. When we travel to Tahoe, we have to take a connecting
    flight. No direct flights from Jersey to the Reno airport. We have
    learned to travel light. One carry on and a big purse. I can't tell


    you

    Quoted message said:

    how many times our luggage was lost during the change in planes. I am
    going out there again in May, and it will be one carry on and a large
    purse. I have 20 minutes to make my connection. There is no way my
    luggage will NOT be lost. I think bringing a bike on a plane trip is
    just not worth it. But that's just my opinion. Plus storage for


    those

    Quoted message said:

    items like golf clubs, skis, snowboards etc. is ridiculous. And it
    takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE. I love that word
    DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.
    All Good Things,
    Maggie

    Quoted message said:

    --
    Richard E. Hawkins, Asst. Prof. of Economics /"\ ASCII ribbon


    campaign

    Quoted message said:

    [email hidden] 111 Hiller (814) 375-4846 \ / against HTML


    mail

    Quoted message said:

    Find commentary on law, economics, and X and postings.
    other issues of the day at dochawk.org! / \

    Well I've heard this a lot but have had very difernt experiences. I
    traveled for business for 25 years. My flight miles were well over 1
    million. I always checked bags. I never lost a bag- ever. I never had
    the contents of a bag damaged in any way. I did have bags miss
    connecting flights but they were always delivered to my hotel or home
    within 24 hours. The late arriving bag thng happened only 4 times out
    of some 2000 flights. That means that 99.8% of the time everything
    worked the way it should.

    Specifically about shipping bikes. I've done it with both bike boxes
    and the special transport cases. Both worked fine.

    My only caveat is that with the new rules about not being able to lock
    your luggage I think there is a much greater risk of stuff going
    missing.

  7. Dr. Richard E. Hawkins said:

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    Great website with the information you need:

    http://www.bikeaccess.net/BikeAccess/default.cfm

    --
    Bob Kastigar; [email hidden]
    Home: http://www.neiu.edu/~rkastiga Work: http://www.wgntv.com
    School: http://www.neiu.edu Play: http://www.neiu.edu/~stagectr
    Union: http://www.ibew1220.org (Chicago, IL USA)

    "Sweet Old Bob" (or just the initials)


  8. Quoted message said:

    And it takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE.
    I love that word DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.
    All Good Things,
    Maggie

    You're absolutely right, DE-PLANE is just about the stupidest word there
    is.

  9. Jim said:
    Quoted message said:

    And it takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE.
    I love that word DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.
    All Good Things,
    Maggie

    You're absolutely right, DE-PLANE is just about the stupidest word
    there is.

    Not to Tattoo.

  10. : Won't an LBS give you a shipping carton? They must throw away lots of
    'em.
    : I like the suggestion of buying a folder. I use my Dahon a lot, because
    it
    : fits in my car. I drop my wife near the entrance of whatever (fair,
    : festival, concert, etc.) She gets in line while I drive a mile or two to
    : park the car free. In some cases, the decision to go or not go has been
    : influenced by the ease and cost of parking.

    Excellent idea, Smithers! Do you mind if I use this excuse, too? What do
    you do with the Dahon after you ride back to the festival?

    Pat in TX
    :
    :

  11. ::
    : Specifically about shipping bikes. I've done it with both bike boxes
    : and the special transport cases. Both worked fine.
    :
    : My only caveat is that with the new rules about not being able to lock
    : your luggage I think there is a much greater risk of stuff going
    : missing.

    I just got back from traveling to Charlotte and back to DFW. In the
    Charlotte airport, Brookstone had several different locks for sale that are
    TSA approved. It seems they have a special key to open these locks without
    having to know the code. If you use a TSA approved lock, everything ought
    to be fine.

    Pat in TX
    :

  12. Bill Sornson said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    And it takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE. I love
    that word DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    You're absolutely right, DE-PLANE is just about the stupidest word
    there is.

    Quoted message said:

    Not to Tattoo.

    I guess we owe that to the days of traveling by ship where you
    embarked and debarked or even disembarked. Merriam-Webster OnLine
    believes embark and debark are appropriate for air travel although
    travel agents apparently like the specific term "plane" never having
    gotten on a sailing ship for travel.

    [email hidden]

  13. :
    : I guess we owe that to the days of traveling by ship where you
    : embarked and debarked or even disembarked. Merriam-Webster OnLine
    : believes embark and debark are appropriate for air travel although
    : travel agents apparently like the specific term "plane" never having
    : gotten on a sailing ship for travel.
    :
    : [email hidden]

    And, that debarked probably came from the ship called a Barque.....

    Pat in TX

  14. I took my bike to Alaska recently and I used the same box it was shipped to
    me in when it was new. Just a factory shipping box. I did reinforce the
    box with some thin sheets of plastic styrofoam corrugated stuff (Like they
    make signs with) just for extra protection.

    Going to Alaska, American airlines charged me $80 and the bike was checked
    through to the destination (I did change airlines). On the return trip,
    Alaska airlines charged me $50 and again it was checked through to my
    destination (again I did change airlines). Far as I can tell the only way
    you can substitute a bike for one of your regular checked bags is if it
    meets their size and weight requirement for a checked bag. Most bike boxes
    are too big. Ergo, the extra charge. My bike came through unscathed both
    flights, but the box took a pretty good beating. I was glad I had
    reinforced the box with the plastic sheets.

    That was my experience. I also looked into renting a bike, but some places
    wanted $30-50 per day and they didn't even have the kind of bike I wanted.

    Sid

    "Dr. Richard E. Hawkins" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll be
    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    It's nothign spectalar; just for commuting a couple of miles each day.
    A Trek 4300 or some such that was the back to school sale a couple of
    years ago; fairly generic mountain bike with quick release front & back.

    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive? I've
    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is close
    to disposable . . .

    A luggage would also have to be transported, which would be an issue.
    If I could pack the bike this way, I could just pack in my old seabag
    and wear it aas a backpack . . .

    hawk
    --
    Richard E. Hawkins, Asst. Prof. of Economics /"\ ASCII ribbon
    campaign
    [email hidden] 111 Hiller (814) 375-4846 \ / against HTML mail
    Find commentary on law, economics, and X and postings.
    other issues of the day at dochawk.org! / \

  15. Quoted message said:

    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive? I've
    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is close
    to disposable . . .

    Some LBS's rent bike cases, if you're interested.

    Chris Neary
    [email hidden]

    "Science, freedom, beauty, adventure: what more could
    you ask of life? Bicycling combined all the elements I
    loved" - Adapted from a quotation by Charles Lindbergh

  16. Dr. Richard E. Hawkins said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll


    be

    Quoted message said:

    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    It's nothign spectalar; just for commuting a couple of miles each


    day.

    Quoted message said:

    A Trek 4300 or some such that was the back to school sale a couple of
    years ago; fairly generic mountain bike with quick release front &


    back.

    Quoted message said:


    If I simply wrap it in a cardboard box, is it likely to survive?


    I've

    Quoted message said:

    seen the case, but they all cost more than the bicycle, which is


    close

    Quoted message said:

    to disposable . . .

    We've traveled overseas, taking our bikes on flights. We didn't rent
    or buy, because for a long bike tour, we wanted to use our own nice
    touring bikes.

    We got standard bike cartons - the ones new bikes arrive in - from our
    LBS. Disassembly and reassembly were a bit tedious (what with racks,
    fenders, etc. for touring).

    The bikes survived, despite astonishingly bad treatment. We witnessed
    our "This End UP!" bike cartons laid on their side on the roof of a
    luggage truck. We watched as the "Fragile!" cartons were pushed from
    that height directly to the ground. Pack well!

    If I had it to do over again with those bikes, I'd add wheels or
    casters to one corner of the box; the cartons are large and unwieldy.

    For a couple day trip with little riding, I'd consider borrowing,
    renting or buying a junker. (You say Vegas is "home." Do you have
    friends there who can scare up a bike for you?)

    If I made such trips frequently, I'd get a folding bike.

  17. Quoted message said:
    Bill Sornson said:
    Quoted message said:

    > And it takes longer to get the items when you DEPLANE. I love
    > that word DE-PLANE. It's so stupid.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    You're absolutely right, DE-PLANE is just about the stupidest word
    there is.

    Quoted message said:

    Not to Tattoo.

    I guess we owe that to the days of traveling by ship where you
    embarked and debarked or even disembarked. Merriam-Webster OnLine
    believes embark and debark are appropriate for air travel although
    travel agents apparently like the specific term "plane" never having
    gotten on a sailing ship for travel.

    Not sure why you replied to me since you in no way addressed what I wrote,
    but...

    Debarked is what happens to a tree in a big dog's yard. (Eventually.)

    De-Usenetting now, BS

  18. <[email hidden]> wrote: (clip)Merriam-Webster OnLine
    believes embark and debark are appropriate (clip)
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    If I say "debark," my friends assume I am talking about wood.

  19. "Pat" wrote: (clip) What do you do with the Dahon after you ride back to the
    festival?
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    I'm glad you asked. Depends on the event. At the state fair in Sacramento,
    I kept it with me, and used it whenever I had to go back to the car, for
    food, etc. At the Scottish Games in Pleasanton, I cabled it to a post,
    within sight of a security guard. At an indoor concert, I fold it and take
    it inside. One time I stashed it in the aisle of a university classroom.
    Sometimes, at a flea market I'll bungee a carton to the rack, and use it as
    my shopping cart.

  20. "Dr. Richard E. Hawkins" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I have a conference at home (Las Vegas) in a couple of weeks. I'll be
    there an extra couple of days.

    I've had the odd idea to bring the bicycle with me as transportation.

    Why not rent while you're in Vegas?

    See: http://www.vegasbikeclub.org/faq.htm

    --
    Warm Regards,

    Claire Petersky
    Home of the meditative cyclist:
    http://home.earthlink.net/~cpetersky/Welcome.htm
    Personal page: http://www.geocities.com/cpetersky/
    See the books I've set free at:
    http://bookcrossing.com/referral/Cpetersky

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.