On 24 May 2005 08:12:31 -0700, "Maggie" <[email hidden]>
Quoted message said:
Jeff Starr said:You are missing the point, you are not posting an audio clip of the
song. You are posting the lyrics. So the attribution should go to the
writer, or as Lokey suggested, making a reference to the version.
And in your case, if you are altering the lyrics, it would be fair to
make a note of that.
My dear sweet Jeff who is the same age as me.... ;-)
No, I'm not, you are older than me;-)
Quoted message said:
I love music as well. I think you can tell. I love the music of the
sixties. I respect the writer and the performer. I am a writer myself.
Don't you think I respect the person who actually wrote the song as
well as the person who performed the song?
I alter the lyrics only to shorten and use as a closing. I take out
certain lines and keep others. I don't change the words. Do you want me
to post the whole song as a sig?
I would not alter the amazing poetry of Jim Morrison. I would not
destroy the lyrics written by John Lennon, Billy Joel, Joni Mitchell or
Carol King. To me the lyrics are more important than the music. I am
all about the lyrics. I love words. I love poetry. I love books.
Words are everything to me.
Did you ever hear that old saying...."You are the words and I am the
music...Together we are the SONG!!!" The song is the thing, no matter
who sings it, who renders it differently or who hears it.
Well duh! If it is the song and not the performer, then give credit
to the writer of the song. As per your example, Janis didn't write the
song, Kris did.
Quoted message said:
The song is the beauty. Beauty is not to be picked apart. Just
enjoyed. Enjoy the song Jeff. Life is too short to pick it apart.
Sometimes you have to shut down the logical side of yourself and just
feel and enjoy. 🙂
Nobody is picking the songs apart, you are missing the point. All I'm
saying is give the credit where it is due. It is very simple. And to
be honest, I sort of resent you telling me how to listen to music. You
know nothing of how I listen to music. Anyway, we are not listening,
we are discussing music.
Quoted message said:
Love,
Maggie
Life is Good!
Jeff