apusapus <
[email protected]> wrote:
> "Dave Andersen" <
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
>> > Dave, you're an idiot.
>
>> Please, oh babbling font of wisdom, tell me why I'm wrong.
>
> Oh, you thought I was talking about swimming? No, David, I was referring to your allegations of
> racism. Made in another thread, I know, but can't you draw the dots for yourself?
>
> I wrote a 9K answer based on my experiences in my country - Rhodesia - over the past four decades,
> which I then decided to spare you on two grounds. One, you wouldn't understand. Two, it wouldn't
> change a thing if you did. So I cut to the chase - which is:
>
> Dave, you're an idiot.
Fair enough. I'll confess that the issue isn't nearly as (agh) black and white as I appeared to
claim in my earlier post, but do note that I wasn't alleging the racism on your part -- I was
alleging it on the part of the poster you so seem to admire.
(So, perhaps I was claiming you're racist, if you and she are one in the same).
Is it racist to say, "There are clear socioeconimic differences in the rate of childbirthing?"
Heck no. It's true. Is it racist to say, "Ethnic group X has a higher birthrate in the US than
ethnic group Y?" I'm not that stupid. What I _said_, if you'll read my post a bit more carefully,
is that I believe Elizabeth is very deliberately making comments that (s)he knows damn well could
be interpreted as racist. I think that's stooping kind of low for a troll - there are more
challenging things to get people in a.s.c.f. fired up about, but in the US, at least, race is such
an easy button to push that it seems like a cop-out for a troll of obvious talent.
In reality, I think Elizabeth is concocting a nice mix of mostly truths to lead her readers to
come to unwarranted conclusions about the cause and effect of what she's describing. She's not
stating those conclusions herself, for which I give her credit, but she's definitely making the
implication.
But she does have a nice way of using the phrase "terminal rectocranial impaction."
-Dave
--
work: dga - at - lcs.mit.edu me: angio - at - pobox.com MIT Laboratory for Computer Science
http://www.angio.net/ (note that my reply-to address is vaguely despammed...) bulk emailers: I do
not accept unsolicited email. Do not mail me.