General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Swimmer's shoulder

Started by Haim Guivon · · Last activity · 22 posts · 2,175 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
30 May 2004
Last activity
19 June 2004
Original author
Haim Guivon
Posts
22
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,175
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 22
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I've seen Larry Weisenthal's very learned explanation, and
    read the URL he recommended.

    However, as a non-professional, I don't quite understand how
    to translate the directives into practice. If I could see
    sketches to show me exactly how to correct my strokes, it
    would be most useful.

    I swim for about one hour and a quarter of an hour every
    day, and I switch among all the styles (except the most
    strenous butterfly). The shoulder pain appeared when I
    started swimming again after a pause of two months.

    I'll appreciate any guide, thank you.

    haim

  2. Haim Guivon said:

    I've seen Larry Weisenthal's very learned explanation, and
    read the URL he recommended.

    However, as a non-professional, I don't quite understand
    how to translate the directives into practice. If I could
    see sketches to show me exactly how to correct my strokes,
    it would be most useful.

    I swim for about one hour and a quarter of an hour every
    day, and I switch among all the styles (except the most
    strenous butterfly). The shoulder pain appeared when I
    started swimming again after a pause of two months.

    I'll appreciate any guide, thank you.

    What kind of stretching do you do for your shoulders?

  3. Quoted message said:

    If I could see sketches to show me exactly how
    to correct my strokes, it would be most useful.

    No sketch; however, one swimming author makes the research
    summary rather simple. Reaching and lifting the elbow for
    the hand scull causes shoulder problems. The solution given
    was to be sure the the hand drops down before you pressure
    for the scull.

    Gleshna - Multi-Thousandaire

    DA LAKES: Da Lake Tube:
    greatlakesurfing.compoint.jpg Da
    new Lake Movie: unsalted.tvunsalted.tv Da Bears ???????

  4. "Martin W. Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Haim Guivon said:

    I've seen Larry Weisenthal's very learned explanation,
    and read the URL


    he

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    recommended.

    However, as a non-professional, I don't quite understand
    how to translate the directives into practice. If I could
    see sketches to show me exactly


    how

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    to correct my strokes, it would be most useful.

    I swim for about one hour and a quarter of an hour every
    day, and I


    switch

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    among all the styles (except the most strenous
    butterfly). The shoulder


    pain

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    appeared when I started swimming again after a pause of
    two months.

    I'll appreciate any guide, thank you.

    What kind of stretching do you do for your shoulders?


    =======================================

    1) Holding hands behind back
    2) Pressing on elbow with arm extended sideward before
    chest.
    3) Lifting arms with hands clasped behind body.
    4) Hands above head, and stretching upwards one after the
    other while holding wrist with other hand. Same stretch
    upwards and sidewards (to the hand's opposite direction).

    All these are done before swimming. After swimming,
    several push-ups.

    So sorry for my clumsy descriptions. It is poor knowledge of
    matter and of english language.

    Thank you for answering.

    haim
    ========================================

  5. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    However, as a non-professional, I don't quite understand
    how to translate


    the directives into practice. If I could see sketches to
    show me exactly how to correct my strokes, it would be
    most useful.<<

    A couple of years back, I video'd my older daughter doing
    "bad stroke," followed by "good stroke" (shoulder friendly-
    wise) for all 4 strokes. I did this in preparation for a
    presentation I made at a swimming conference. Now that I've
    finally gotten decent video editing software, I'll try and
    digitize it, and burn it into CDs (which I'd give away for
    free) and post the clips on my website. Will doubtless take
    me some time, but, by and by, I should have them. Send me a
    private e-mail in about a month, if you are interested.
    Shorten the above e-mail address by leaving off the last 3
    letters after the "dot"

  6. Stroke modifications for sore shoulders -->

    Basically, you want to avoid internal rotation (counter-
    clockwise, right and clockwise, left) of the hand.

    You want to recover (above the water) with your thumb
    forward of the pinky and your palm facing your head. You
    want to enter the water pinky first and not thumb first. You
    want to enter just a bit wider than is classic for
    freestyle...more of a buttefly enter position. You want to
    have a bit of a diagonal inward pull (similar to butterfly)
    and not a straight back pull (which you have to have when
    your hand enters forward of the head rather than outwards a
    little bit, as in butterfly. You want to avoid internally
    rotating the hand as you descend into the catch. Maintain
    the slightly thumb forward of the pinky position as you pull
    inward and backward. You want to let your hand descend into
    the catch position before applying significant pulling
    force. You want the pulling force to be backwards and not
    downwards (which forces the head of the humerus upward,
    compressing the superior rotator cuff against the acromion
    ("car port" boney part of the shoulder blade over the head
    of the humerus). You don't want an exaggerated push back, as
    this causes a "wring out" of the blood supply to the
    superior rotator cuff.

    Say -- over and over and over -- "internal rotation is bad;
    external rotation is good."

  7. "Gleshna" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    If I could see sketches to show me exactly how
    to correct my strokes, it would be most useful.

    No sketch; however, one swimming author makes the research
    summary rather simple. Reaching and lifting the elbow for
    the hand scull causes shoulder problems. The solution
    given was to be sure the the hand drops down


    before you

    Quoted message said:

    pressure for the scull.

    Gleshna - Multi-Thousandaire

    DA LAKES: Da Lake Tube: greatlakesurfing.com-greatlakesurfing.com-
    /images/Gallery/point.jpg Da new Lake Movie:
    unsalted.tvunsalted.tv Da Bears ???????


    ===========================================

    I don't quite understand. In front crawl, during recovery,
    the elbow leaves the water first, goes high and then the
    hand follows. The hand moves forward parallel to the water
    surface, and enters the water before it is fully extended,
    thumb first. (this is how my coach tought me a long time
    ago). Is that more or less what you mean? Then I do it
    correctly.

    I want to add that I feel the pain at the start of the push
    in the water. I've discovered that it is at this moment that
    I must be careful not to lift the shoulder toward the ear,
    but on the contrary to push it toward the bottom of the
    pool. This helps, but it is difficult to remember. It is
    enough one bad stroke and the pain is back. I cannot explain
    better, sorry for my language limitations.

    It is possible that the problem originates not in front
    crawl, but in backstroke. I couldn't say, because both
    strokes are equally painful. In backstroke, the arm makes a
    full semi-circle when going backwards, and enters the water
    little finger first. When starting the push movement, is
    when I feel the pain. Here too, experiment shows me that I
    can feel less pain if I push the shoulder toward my nose
    when pushing water. This is somehow unnatural and I must be
    very aware not to forget.

    Could you translate my feelings into more accurate terms?

    thank you for answering, haim

    =============================================

  8. Please, I want to insert several notes and questions in the
    text below.
    ---------------------------------------------------------
    ----------
    "Larry Weisenthal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Stroke modifications for sore shoulders -->

    Basically, you want to avoid internal rotation (counter-
    clockwise, right


    and

    Quoted message said:

    clockwise, left) of the hand.

    You want to recover (above the water) with your thumb
    forward of the pinky


    and

    Quoted message said:

    your palm facing your head. You want to enter the water
    pinky first and


    not

    Quoted message said:

    thumb first.


    -------------------------------------------------------
    ----------
    Is that so? I was tought to enter the water thumb first.
    Moreover, an old handbook I have (The Handbook of Swimming,
    by David Wilkie & Kelvin Juba) says so. If you insist, I'll
    accept your word, because it sounds sensible, and try to
    change my habits.
    -------------------------------------------------------
    ----------

    Quoted message said:

    You want to enter just a bit wider than is classic for
    freestyle...more of a buttefly enter position. You want to
    have a bit of


    a

    Quoted message said:

    diagonal inward pull (similar to butterfly) and not a
    straight back pull


    (which

    Quoted message said:

    you have to have when your hand enters forward of the head
    rather than


    outwards

    Quoted message said:

    a little bit, as in butterfly. You want to avoid
    internally rotating the


    hand

    Quoted message said:

    as you descend into the catch.


    ------------------------------------------------------
    ----------
    Here again, we learnt to enter the water "between a line
    with the shoulder and body midline" (from the quoted book).
    You suggest the hand should enters the water more outwards
    of the body. It seems logical to me (as it will help in the
    backward push which will be diagonal inward from the side to
    the centerline of the body), but again, I am confused by the
    discrepancy.
    ------------------------------------------------------
    ----------

    Quoted message said:

    Maintain the slightly thumb forward of the pinky position
    as you pull inward and backward.


    --------------------------------------------------------
    ----------
    I don't understand this one. When I push, the hand is
    perpendicular to the water surface, thumb up. What does it
    mean "thumb forward of the pinky"?

    If the hand is at an angle the push would lose strength.
    -------------------------------------------------------
    ----------

    Quoted message said:

    You want to let your hand descend into the catch position
    before applying significant pulling force.


    You

    Quoted message said:

    want the pulling force to be backwards and not downwards
    (which forces the


    head

    Quoted message said:

    of the humerus upward, compressing the superior rotator
    cuff against the acromion ("car port" boney part of the
    shoulder blade over the head of the humerus). You don't
    want an exaggerated push back, as this causes a


    "wring

    Quoted message said:

    out" of the blood supply to the superior rotator cuff.


    -----------------------------------------------------------
    ----------
    Right, but what does it mean "an exagerated push back"?
    Too forceful?
    -----------------------------------------------------------
    ----------

    Quoted message said:


    Say -- over and over and over -- "internal rotation is
    bad; external


    rotation

    Quoted message said:

    is good."


    ====================================
    Thank for reading and for answers and comments. haim

  9. Haim Guivon said:


    "Martin W. Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Haim Guivon said:

    I've seen Larry Weisenthal's very learned explanation,
    and read the URL


    he

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    recommended.

    However, as a non-professional, I don't quite understand
    how to translate the directives into practice. If I
    could see sketches to show me exactly


    how

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    to correct my strokes, it would be most useful.

    I swim for about one hour and a quarter of an hour every
    day, and I


    switch

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    among all the styles (except the most strenous
    butterfly). The shoulder


    pain

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    appeared when I started swimming again after a pause of
    two months.

    I'll appreciate any guide, thank you.

    What kind of stretching do you do for your shoulders?


    =======================================

    1) Holding hands behind back
    2) Pressing on elbow with arm extended sideward before
    chest.
    3) Lifting arms with hands clasped behind body.
    4) Hands above head, and stretching upwards one after the
    other while holding wrist with other hand. Same stretch
    upwards and sidewards (to the hand's opposite
    direction).

    All these are done before swimming. After swimming, several
    push-ups.

    Add this one once a day, at least until you recover. Suppose
    your right shoulder is the one in pain. Dangle a small towel
    over your left shoulder from your left hand. Reach around
    behind your back with your right hand and grab the end of
    the towel. Pull up on the towel with your left hand as far
    as you can.

    martin

  10. Haim Guivon said:

    Is that so? I was tought to enter the water thumb first.
    Moreover, an old handbook I have (The Handbook of Swimming,
    by David Wilkie & Kelvin Juba) says so. ...

    Most swim books, including the latest from Maglischo and
    Colwin, show at least moderate impingement during the crawl
    stroke, and some elites swim with extreme impingement. It
    may be faster, but unfortunately, some people can't swim
    that way without injury.

    donalfagan.comshoulder.html

    Donal Fagan AIA Donal@DonalO'Fagan.com (Anglicise the name
    to reply by e-mail)

  11. "Martin W. Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "Haim Guivon" <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    What kind of stretching do you do for your shoulders?


    =======================================

    1) Holding hands behind back
    2) Pressing on elbow with arm extended sideward before
    chest.
    3) Lifting arms with hands clasped behind body.
    4) Hands above head, and stretching upwards one after the
    other while holding wrist with other hand. Same
    stretch upwards and sidewards (to the hand's opposite
    direction).

    All these are done before swimming. After swimming,
    several push-ups.

    Add this one once a day, at least until you recover.
    Suppose your right shoulder is the one in pain. Dangle a
    small towel over your left shoulder from your left hand.
    Reach around behind your back with your right hand and
    grab the end of the towel. Pull up on the towel with your
    left hand as far as you can.

    martin


    ====================================================

    I've already added it to my warming up. Thank you very much.
    It hurts at the beginning, but then it feels better.

    BTW, I've found some very good exercises in the web, and I
    do them every day. It seems to help:

    physsportsmed.comloosli.htm

    haim

  12. "Donal Fagan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Haim Guivon said:

    Is that so? I was tought to enter the water thumb first.
    Moreover, an old handbook I have (The Handbook of
    Swimming, by David Wilkie & Kelvin Juba) says so. ...

    Most swim books, including the latest from Maglischo and
    Colwin, show at least moderate impingement during the
    crawl stroke, and some elites swim with extreme
    impingement. It may be faster, but unfortunately, some
    people can't swim that way without injury.

    donalfagan.comshoulder.html

    Donal Fagan AIA Donal@DonalO'Fagan.com (Anglicise the name
    to reply by e-mail)


    ==============================================

    Thank you for your webpage. Nevertheless, let me,
    please, ask:

    In your page I read:

    "Cecil Colwin's illustration of the crawl stroke from
    Swimming Dynamics, above, shows the swimmer's reaching hand
    parallel to the surface of the the water, and his body
    perpendicular to the surface. The swimmer has internally
    rotated his leading arm about 180 degrees, so he is
    potentially causing impingement in that shoulder".

    Well, I don't get it. I thought that thumb down and pinky up
    at entry would be maximum internal rotation, like it can be
    seen in your page showing a sequence of photos of Mark
    Spitzer, and this is discouraged if one wants to avoid
    shoulder impingement.

    If palm (down) paralell to the surface of the water means
    180 degrees internal rotation, then taking the palm up would
    mean no internal rotation? This would be a very awkward
    position!. Moreover, what is "body perpendicular to the
    surface"? This would mean standing up in the water!.

    Or most probably my understanding of English is too poor.

    To resume, what would be the reccomended hand position? And
    how exactly do I define "internal rotation"?

    thanks for an answer. haim

  13. Haim Guivon said:


    "Martin W. Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "Haim Guivon" <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > What kind of stretching do you do for your shoulders?
    =======================================

    1) Holding hands behind back
    2) Pressing on elbow with arm extended sideward before
    chest.
    3) Lifting arms with hands clasped behind body.
    4) Hands above head, and stretching upwards one after
    the other while holding wrist with other hand. Same
    stretch upwards and sidewards (to the hand's opposite
    direction).

    All these are done before swimming. After swimming,
    several push-ups.

    Add this one once a day, at least until you recover.
    Suppose your right shoulder is the one in pain. Dangle a
    small towel over your left shoulder from your left hand.
    Reach around behind your back with your right hand and
    grab the end of the towel. Pull up on the towel with your
    left hand as far as you can.

    martin


    ====================================================

    I've already added it to my warming up. Thank you very
    much. It hurts at the beginning, but then it feels better.

    It was actually recommended to me by a surgeon who
    specialized in back problems. I had gone to him because of
    persistent shoulder pain of the kind you describe. After
    using this stretch for a week, the pain disappeared and has
    not returned.

  14. Haim Guivon said:

    Well, I don't get it. I thought that thumb down and pinky
    up at entry would be maximum internal rotation, like it
    can be seen in your page showing a sequence of photos of
    Mark Spitzer,

    Correct.

    Quoted message said:

    and this is discouraged if one wants to avoid shoulder
    impingement.

    Impingement *is* discouraged by some coaches, scientists
    and doctors, like Larry, who posted earlier, but
    impingement is *not* discouraged by *all* prominent
    coaches. So you will find little mention of shoulder-
    friendly technique in classic swim manuals.

    Quoted message said:

    If palm (down) paralell to the surface of the water means
    180 degrees internal rotation, then taking the palm up
    would mean no internal rotation?

    It depends on your palm's relation to your body, not to the
    water. If you are flat in the water, and your hand is flat,
    that isn't much impingement

    Quoted message said:

    This would be a very awkward position!. Moreover, what is
    "body perpendicular to the surface"? This would mean
    standing up in the water!.

    It could, or it could mean a body lying on its side instead
    of on its back or stomach. Then the Y-axis of your body
    would be perpendicular to the plane of the water.

    Donal Fagan AIA Donal@DonalO'Fagan.com (Anglicise the name
    to reply by e-mail)

  15. "Gleshna" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    "Haim Guivon"

    Quoted message said:

    I was not talking about the recovery. I was talking about
    the catch.


    That is

    Quoted message said:

    when your hand first enters the water. As I mentioned one
    author warns


    against

    Quoted message said:

    an improper catch. Also, I have had a physical therapist
    mention that an improper catch in swimming causes shoulder
    problems.

    If you push down with the arm fully extended then at least
    one physical therapist believes you may have shoulder
    problems. If you lift your elbow rather than drop your
    hand to start pulling/sculling then at least one


    author

    Quoted message said:

    suggests that you may have shoulder problems.

    For the recovery, since I swim on my side (Total Immersion
    ) I use the let


    the

    Quoted message said:

    fingers slide up the side with a high elbow. I think this
    is the least


    problem

    Quoted message said:

    for my shoulders.

    Gleshna - Multi-Thousandaire

    DA LAKES: Da Lake Tube: greatlakesurfing.com-greatlakesurfing.com-
    /images/Gallery/point.jpg Da new Lake Movie:
    unsalted.tvunsalted.tv Da Bears ???????


    ============================================

    Got it. I think that's it. Moreover, when I lift the elbow,
    I also lift the shoulder, and that was BAAD. Today I
    followed your advice, making a deliberate effort to lower
    the elbow and shoulder, and rolling downwards the pushing
    side of the body (which further helps to keep elbow and
    shoulder low), and I already feel much better.

    Thanks a lot, haim

    ============================================

  16. In article <[email hidden]>,

    (Gleshna) said:
    Quoted message said:

    "Haim Guivon"

    Quoted message said:

    The hand moves forward parallel to the water surface,
    and enters the water before it is fully extended, thumb
    first. (this is how my coach tought me a long time ago).
    Is that more or less what you mean?

    I was not talking about the recovery. I was talking about
    the catch. That is when your hand first enters the water.

    Well, that would be the "entry." I usually reserve "catch"
    for the point where the arm/hand first grabs water and
    applies force. Some swimmers descend directly to a catch
    after entry without stopping. Others glide for a few
    milliseconds with the arm extended first.

    Quoted message said:

    As I mentioned one author warns against an improper catch.
    Also, I have had a physical therapist mention that an
    improper catch in swimming causes shoulder problems.

    I fully agree with that therapist.

    Quoted message said:

    If you push down with the arm fully extended then at least
    one physical therapist believes you may have shoulder
    problems.

    I agree with that one also. Let the hand descend 8-10
    inches, and swing the elbow sideways a bit, before
    applying force.

    Quoted message said:

    If you lift your elbow rather than drop your hand to start
    pulling/sculling then at least one author suggests that
    you may have shoulder problems.

    Well, you can't just drop your hand. Most human elbows don't
    bend that direction. Your elbow has to swing a bit sideways
    at the same time.

    (This is the "high-elbow catch" that's so often spoken of,
    and sometimes confused with the "high-elbow recovery" that's
    also well spoken of.)

    Quoted message said:

    For the recovery, since I swim on my side (Total Immersion
    ) I use the let the fingers slide up the side with a high
    elbow. I think this is the least problem for my shoulders.

    That would be a fingertip drill, aka "shark fin." Lots of
    coaches use them, not just TI coaches, both to teach a high
    elbow recovery and to encourage rotating enough to get the
    shoulder out of the water.

    Ross

  17. "Ross Bogue" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    (Gleshna) said:
    Quoted message said:

    "Haim Guivon"

    Quoted message said:

    The hand moves forward parallel to the water surface,
    and enters the water before it is fully extended,
    thumb first. (this is how my coach tought me a long
    time


    ago). Is

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    that more or less what you mean?

    I was not talking about the recovery. I was talking
    about the catch.


    That

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    is when your hand first enters the water.

    Well, that would be the "entry." I usually reserve "catch"
    for the point where the arm/hand first grabs water and
    applies force. Some swimmers descend directly to a catch
    after entry without stopping. Others glide for a few
    milliseconds with the arm extended first.

    Quoted message said:

    As I mentioned one author warns against an improper
    catch. Also, I have had a physical therapist
    mention that


    an

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    improper catch in swimming causes shoulder problems.

    I fully agree with that therapist.

    Quoted message said:

    If you push down with the arm fully extended then at
    least one physical therapist believes you may have
    shoulder problems.

    I agree with that one also. Let the hand descend 8-10
    inches, and swing the elbow sideways a bit, before
    applying force.

    Quoted message said:

    If you lift your elbow rather than drop your hand to
    start pulling/sculling then at least one


    author

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    suggests that you may have shoulder problems.

    Well, you can't just drop your hand. Most human elbows
    don't bend that direction. Your elbow has to swing a bit
    sideways at the same time.

    (This is the "high-elbow catch" that's so often spoken of,
    and sometimes confused with the "high-elbow recovery"
    that's also well spoken of.)

    Quoted message said:

    For the recovery, since I swim on my side (Total
    Immersion ) I use the


    let

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    the fingers slide up the side with a high elbow. I think
    this is the least problem for my shoulders.

    That would be a fingertip drill, aka "shark fin." Lots of
    coaches use them, not just TI coaches, both to teach a
    high elbow recovery and to encourage rotating enough to
    get the shoulder out of the water.

    Ross


    =============================================
    Very enlightening remarks, thank you.

    Now a question for everybody: I've learnt a lot from this
    discussion, and I am putting the insights to work. But all
    refer to freestyle.

    I need also some remarks on the best techniques for
    backstroke. I feel a heavy burden on the shoulders at the
    entry and start of catch. Well, actually for the whole
    underwater movement. I do feel that my shoulder does not
    know how to behave.

    haim

  18. On 04 Jun 2004 05:00:38 GMT, [email hidden] (Larry Weisenthal)

    Quoted message said:

    In a nutshell, swim coaches teach techniques which they
    feel maximize performance.

    But you must remember that, at the elite level, a 2%
    difference is huge, while at the level of a fitness
    swimmer, 2% is trivial and simply isn't worth the pain and
    risk of a long term injury.

    That's a very, very good point Larry and one that all
    fitness enthusiasts, not just swimmers, should keep in mind.

    <snip>

    Quoted message said:

    Donal and I have discussed and explained all of this stuff
    at very great length over the years. You can go to Google
    Groups and enter "runnswim" and "shoulder" and/or "Donal"
    and "shoulder" and you'll have no trouble finding all
    manner of very detailed explanations and discussions.


    I have been battling swimmers shoulder for a couple of years
    and am currently not swimming due to a recent relapse.
    Caused by a too-closely fought finish at a recent master's
    event I swam in.

    I am following all this with interest. I am not able to swim
    enough at the moment to fully test your stroke change
    suggestions, but I will when I have recovered enough to
    start swimming again. In the meantime I do my rotator cuff
    exercises and squats and bide my time.

    --
    Helgi Briem hbriem AT simnet DOT is

    Never worry about anything that you see on the news.
    To get on the news it must be sufficiently rare
    that your chances of being involved are negligible!

  19. "Larry Weisenthal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Please, I want to insert several notes and questions in
    the text


    below.<<

    Quoted message said:


    Donal did a good job addressing your questions.


    ==========================================
    He did, indeed.

    But please, I need to get a better understanding of the
    actual ways to avoid "internal rotation". With practical
    examples I mean.

    I swim with a very small body rotation. In the website you
    mention in another article, I see that the swimmer lies in
    the water with the Y axis perpendicular to the water surface
    during the pause stage. I don't. I lie with with the Y
    access almost parallel to the water surface, with a very
    small body rotation during catch and start of push. In this
    position (which I am too old to want to change), how should
    the position of each hand be to avoid internal rotation?

    I think that I understood your guides for the catch and pull
    stages, but it all depends on the best hand position during
    the entry. And that I don't quite get.

    Thanks, haim

    PS: I'll follow your advice about the Google search on Donal
    or Runswim and Shoulder. Thanks.
    ==========================================

    Quoted message said:


    In a nutshell, swim coaches teach techniques which they
    feel maximize performance.

    But you must remember that, at the elite level, a 2%
    difference is huge,


    while

    Quoted message said:

    at the level of a fitness swimmer, 2% is trivial and
    simply isn't worth


    the

    Quoted message said:

    pain and risk of a long term injury.

    The most important "rule," to repeat, is to avoid internal
    rotation. With external rotation, the vulnerable
    supraspinatus (superior rotator) tendon


    is

    Quoted message said:

    rotated out from underneath the coracoacromial ligament
    and acromium,


    which

    Quoted message said:

    form the "roof" of the "carport" which covers the rotator
    cuff. When you internally rotate, in contrast, you place
    this tendon in the location


    where

    Quoted message said:

    there is the least amount of room and the greatest amount
    of impingement. Swimmer's shoulder is almost always an
    impingement injury and not an


    overuse

    Quoted message said:

    injury.

    Rotator cuff exercises are also helpful, in that they
    strengthen the


    so-called

    Quoted message said:

    "active stabilizers," which are the rotator cuff muscles
    themselves. With


    good

    Quoted message said:

    rotator muscle tone, the head of the humerus is held in
    place better and


    is

    Quoted message said:

    less prone to migrate upward and produce impingement.

    When I talked about entering a little wider and pulling in
    slightly


    diagonally,

    Quoted message said:

    with the thumb forward (relative to the direction of
    travel) of the pinky,


    I am

    Quoted message said:

    just describing how to maintain a position of external
    rotation throughout


    the

    Quoted message said:

    stroke.

    Donal and I have discussed and explained all of this stuff
    at very great


    length

    Quoted message said:

    over the years. You can go to Google Groups and enter
    "runnswim" and "shoulder" and/or "Donal" and "shoulder"
    and you'll have no trouble


    finding all

    Quoted message said:

    manner of very detailed explanations and discussions.

  20. Quoted message said:

    Rotator cuff exercises are also helpful, in that they
    strengthen the


    so-called "active stabilizers," which are the rotator cuff
    muscles themselves. With good rotator muscle tone, the head
    of the humerus is held in place better and is less prone to
    migrate upward and produce impingement.

    From reading all of this, I am getting the idea that my
    shoulder pain is not what y'all would call tendinits. My
    pain is in the area of the scapula under the posterior
    deltoid muscle, I believe. Is the typical swimmer's shoulder
    up higher on the tip of the shoulder joint? I haven't
    changed anything for months and yet all of a sudden I have
    this pain in my left shoulder.

    Pat in TX

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.