-Originally posted by john_childs -
DIFFERENT PEOPLE WILL APPROACH LEARNING NEW SKILLS DIFFERENTLY.
It is good that you understand people have different opinions, learning
techniques and timing.
SOME PEOPLE WILL PREFER TO JUST GO FOR IT WHILE OTHERS PREFER TO TAKE A
MORE CAREFUL APPROACH. I FALL INTO THE MORE CAREFUL APPROACH CATEGORY.
I also fall into the "careful approach" category.
I NEVER ONCE HAD A BAD FALL WHILE LEARNING TO RIDE BACKWARDS. I NEVER
WAS OUT OF CONTROL. AT ANY TIME THAT I FELT THINGS WERE BEGINNING TO GO
BADLY I COULD STOP AND RECOVER.
Sorry, I respect you and all, but I simply do not believe you never had
a UPD when you were learning that skill. The rest of us have UPDs when
we learn new skills - I would dare to add that the rest of us (barring
Coker riders) have a UPD each day we ride. Having UPDs is not a bad
thing - it comes with the territory of having one wheel to balance on.
I DON'T THINK LEARNING MY WAY SLOWED DOWN MY PROGRESS AT ALL.
Avoiding UPDs at all costs probably decreases learning speed. At the
slightest hint of being out of control, you have to quit trying and
start over. Starting over more often takes more time.
THE IDLING APPROACH GIVES CLEAR GOALS THAT KEEPS THE LEARNING FROM
GETTING FRUSTRATING. ONCE YOU GET THE 2 BACKWARDS REVOLUTIONS NAILED
THEN YOU TRY TO 2.5. WHEN YOU'VE GOT THE 2.5 BACKWARDS REVOLUTIONS
NAILED YOU TRY FOR 3. THERE IS ALWAYS A GOAL. SURE BEATS JUST GOING
FOR IT AND RIDING BACKWARDS UNTIL YOU FALL OFF, AT LEAST FOR ME.
You misunderstand how I learned. I did the same thing: I counted half
revolutions. Now you can see that you can have a "clear goal" without
making "idling" one of them. To put it clearly: I learned to go
backwards the same way as I learned to go forwards - sans idling.
AND IDLING IS HARDLY AN ADVANCED SKILL. IF YOU CAN'T IDLE WITH EITHER
FOOT DOWN SOLIDLY, YOU PROBABLY AREN'T REALLY READY TO TRY BACKWARDS
RIDING YET. IDLING IS PRETTY MUCH THE FOUNDATION FOR ANY OTHER SKILL.
IDLING DEMONSTRATES SOME CONTROL OF THE UNICYCLE. I CONSIDER IT A BASIC
SKILL.
I don't. There is a local guy who can ride better than me off-road. He
can hop higher than me. He is faster than me. He cannot idle. I believe
that he has "more control" over the unicycle because he can do these
things.
IDLING IS THE FIST SKILL YOU LEARN WHERE YOU'RE DOING SOMETHING UNIQUE
AND SPECIAL ON A UNICYCLE.
That depends on what you call "unique." First, you try to reduce idling
to being common and fundamental, then you call it unique and special. I
disagree with both ideas:
1. I do not think idling is a basic skill BECAUSE a rider can ride an
entire day without doing it.
2. I don't think it is "special" because as you have pointed out it is
"hardly an advanced skill."
THE SECOND UNIQUELY UNICYCLE SKILL THAT PEOPLE TYPICALLY LEARN IS RIDING
BACKWARDS.
I think it is hopping. It is easier to hop one time (consistenly) than
it is to idle. It didn't take me 4.5 hours to learn to hop. (I noticed
the "uniquely unicycle skill" part but ignored it. 1. Riding forward is
unique (on a unicycle). 2. Standard mounts are unique also. Further, a
rider does *not* have to learn to idle first.
THE THIRD UNIQUELY UNICYCLE SKILL MOST PEOPLE LEARN IS RIDING ONE
FOOTED.
I invoke the power of gpickett0 - he learned to one foot before he
learned to idle or go backwards.
IDLING IS REALLY A FOUNDATION TYPE SKILL THAT SHOULD COME BEFORE
BACKWARDS AND ONE FOOT.
It can. Nothing prevents the rider from learning those skills first. 🙂
By moving idling down to level 3, you just make it harder to be level 3
people. I think that all of the levels were correctly weighted - except,
I would probably move seat on stomach to Level 3 because it is almost as
hard as seat out front.
The bottom line is that if you put a poll out, I think you would find
that most people learn to go backwards without idling before each
attempt. I am currently learing to ride one footed - and it never
crossed my mind to idle into it.
Point:
I see idling, going backwards and riding with one foot as three separate
(and even branched) skills). They are all of about the same difficulty
(like Level 4 implies). Finally: It is easier each of these three skills
without executing another one of them first.
--
ChangingLINKS.com - member
Wishing you Happiness, Joy and Laughter,
Drew Brown
http://www.ChangingLINKS.com
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ChangingLINKS.com's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/5468
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/32779