"Pete Biggs" <pbiggmellon{remove_fruit}
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Richard Goodman wrote:
>
> > You have to draw a line somewhere
>
> Exactly. If you keep on coming back with bids to outbid a competitor just because one more 50p/£1
> "won't make any difference" then you have not drawn a line but have Auction Fever.
>
Depends. If you keep on going up beyond any reasonable estimate of the item's true value you have
auction fever, otherwise you're just reviewing how much you really want that item.
> Where you draw the line depends on how keen you are on the item. That line should be right at the
> limit of what you can afford (or even a bit over!) if you are desperate. But when just bargain
> hunting, well it doesn't really matter if someone keener/richer/cleverer than you nabs it.
>
If you're serious about wanting to win an item at the best price (or even at all), the timing of the
bid can also be important.
> > and don't necessarily want everyone else know how high you are willing to go by giving them a
> > chance to bid above you early on in the auction - at least so long as the 'fixed end time'
> > applies.
>
> But that only matters if YOU are prepared to come back and snipe other bids.
Not only. An early high bid just invites people to top it and rule you out of the bidding in
circumstances where you might have won with a different strategy.
> If you bid the most you can afford, then what does it matter at what stage others bid more?
>
It matters because not everyone follows this "max bid right from the start strategy". In fact most
people don't. So in an auction where the bidders haven't done this you stand more chance of winning,
and winning at the lowest price sufficient to defeat other bids, by withholding your true max until
the last moment.
> The "fifteen minutes" idea is interesting and maybe worth doing but it still means you'd have to
> "attend" the auction live towards the end (which may go on and on for ages*) if not using proxy
> bidding. Other bidders will!
>
I would assume doing it with proxy bidding. I don't see any reason to think it would go on
ad-infinitum, and it only goes on if the price is increasing - which I would have thought would
benefit the seller more than waiting a few minutes or maybe an hour two would inconvenience them.
I think there is an online auction which does (or did this), which is how I heard about it - I
didn't just think it up all by myself! But I don't know which. Not as successful as ebay though,
although I doubt the bidding system has anything to do with it.
Rich