"Prometheus" <
[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> This is not a troll. I just finished a century ride this weekend and heard a lot of people saying,
> "I don't like this saddle." Now, commonsense says you try them all until you find one you like,
> but surely there is some other thought behind it than having to purchase all of the ones in the
> Performance catalog. Would they even accept returns if you didn't like them? Anyway, I'm curious.
> Do "bad" saddles give you saddle sores??? Or, is it just pure discomfort? Physically debilitating?
> Mine is not overly comfortable, but I haven't tried any others.
I don't know that there's any way to predict how you'll like a saddle, and yes, I do think saddles
make a huge difference, even after all the fit issues are tweaked.
I was reasonably comfortable on many of the generic saddles, the kind that come on new bikes. Most
LBS have a bunch of them taken off new bikes for upgrades, available for $5-10. These can be a
reasonable starting point to see what you don't like in padding and shape.
Despite all efforts, saddle selection may still be a trial and error thing though. I'm a distance
rider, and needed a saddle that would be good for rides longer than 200 miles. Many distance riders
use and recommend the Brooks leather saddles. I tried 2 (Pro & B17) of the most popular models, and
had nothing but discomfort, even after trying every permutation of tilt, height and setback. I wound
up swapping the saddle with someone who had bought a new bike with a saddle they hated, in the end
we were both happy, I did a 250 mile ride with the new saddle and had no problems.
A poorly suited saddle can cause many problems: genital numbness (that may persist a while (days)
after a long ride), saddle sores (the Brooks Pro almost wiped out my summer riding season), a
feeling of being "unbalanced" (can't get comfortable, sliding back & forth, etc.), or just soreness
at the pelvic "sit bones" -- I rode a double century on a Selle Italia Flite which was pretty
comfortable for ~150 miles, then became positive torture for the last 50, I was literally yelping
with every bump in the road.
Bike saddles are a lot like shoes, and as far as I know, there's no way to predict how you'll like a
pair of shoes exactly, but most people become aware of their individual preferences, like heel/toe
width, arch support, etc. Shoe stores don't let you bring them back after a week or two either. Some
shops will, or may, with qualifications. One I asked said that they'd take it back if it was
unmarked in any way -- that's kind of a gamble.