J
Jake
Guest
On Mon, 22 Dec 2003 16:38:12 -0600, "SumBuny"
<[email protected]> wrote:
>
>"jake" <[email protected]> wrote in message news:[email protected]...
>> On Mon, 22 Dec 2003 13:36:28 -0600, "SumBuny" <[email protected]> wrote:
>> > "jake" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> > news[email protected]...
>> > >there are no medical tests for ADHD. It is not a medical condition.
>> >
>>
>> >What are the "medical tests" for near-sightedness? Far-sightedness?
>Pain?
>> >Autism? Sensory integration disorder? If you cannot state any, does
>that
>> >mean that these are not medical conditions? That they should/can not be treated? That they are
>> >not real?
>> >
>> >Try to spend some time volunteering in special education classes with students who do not have
>> >"medical conditions" because the tests for them
>are
>> >not truly objective...and whil you are at it, insist that everyone remove their prescription
>> >lenses, because that too is subjective, not
>objectively
>> >tested...
>>
>> >
>> >Until then, do not tell me that my family is not dealing with disabling conditions, such as
>> >ADHD, autism, sid, pain....
>> >
>>
>> I am not aware that pointing out that diabetes is nothing like ADHD is telling you and family
>> anything..or that I have ever suggested such a thing..
>>
>
>It was not your pointing out diabetes is "nothing like ADHD" that I was commenting on, but the
>comment of "there are no medical tests for ADHD.
there are not..
>It is not a medical condition"
I am by no means alone in holding this view as I am sure you are aware this is what seems to make
you angry..
>that I was...and you conveniently snipped both that and my explanatory comments...your comment was
>"telling my family" that our ADHD, autism, sid, pain issues are not "medical conditions"...
I said nothing as to whether autism,sid,or chronic pain were medical conditions..
The snipping was not "convenient"..I simply focussed on where I was being blatantly misinterpreted
and traduced..
I was asked what I thought the difference was and IMO the difference is that ADHD is not a disease
or an identifiable medical condition..
I am entitled to hold this view without being accused of telling your family that autism ..SID ..and
chronic pain are not medical conditions..am I not?
<[email protected]> wrote:
>
>"jake" <[email protected]> wrote in message news:[email protected]...
>> On Mon, 22 Dec 2003 13:36:28 -0600, "SumBuny" <[email protected]> wrote:
>> > "jake" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> > news[email protected]...
>> > >there are no medical tests for ADHD. It is not a medical condition.
>> >
>>
>> >What are the "medical tests" for near-sightedness? Far-sightedness?
>Pain?
>> >Autism? Sensory integration disorder? If you cannot state any, does
>that
>> >mean that these are not medical conditions? That they should/can not be treated? That they are
>> >not real?
>> >
>> >Try to spend some time volunteering in special education classes with students who do not have
>> >"medical conditions" because the tests for them
>are
>> >not truly objective...and whil you are at it, insist that everyone remove their prescription
>> >lenses, because that too is subjective, not
>objectively
>> >tested...
>>
>> >
>> >Until then, do not tell me that my family is not dealing with disabling conditions, such as
>> >ADHD, autism, sid, pain....
>> >
>>
>> I am not aware that pointing out that diabetes is nothing like ADHD is telling you and family
>> anything..or that I have ever suggested such a thing..
>>
>
>It was not your pointing out diabetes is "nothing like ADHD" that I was commenting on, but the
>comment of "there are no medical tests for ADHD.
there are not..
>It is not a medical condition"
I am by no means alone in holding this view as I am sure you are aware this is what seems to make
you angry..
>that I was...and you conveniently snipped both that and my explanatory comments...your comment was
>"telling my family" that our ADHD, autism, sid, pain issues are not "medical conditions"...
I said nothing as to whether autism,sid,or chronic pain were medical conditions..
The snipping was not "convenient"..I simply focussed on where I was being blatantly misinterpreted
and traduced..
I was asked what I thought the difference was and IMO the difference is that ADHD is not a disease
or an identifiable medical condition..
I am entitled to hold this view without being accused of telling your family that autism ..SID ..and
chronic pain are not medical conditions..am I not?