Originally posted by davek
I've not been at my computer much these past few days hence too busy to respond, but yeah, if Ullrich ever lives up to the potential that he has shown since a very early age he could easily surpass Armstrong in any list of all-time greats. Whether or not he does live up to his potential remains to be seen. This year's TdF could be crunch time - Jan will havetime to catch up after Lance has retired but if he wants to ever be considered as greater than Lance he needs to actually beat him in a race.
I wouldn't necessarily treat the list at cyclinghalloffame.com as definitive but I think it is a reasonable rough guide to relative levels of all-time greatness. I think Lance deserves a fairly high up place. I can see where you're coming from with your complaint about him only riding the TdF but I still think that even in those circumstances winning five TdFs in a row is an awesome achievement. Of course winning a sixth and even a seventh wouldn't make him the greatest cyclist of all time, but it's only Armstrong fans (rather than cycling fans) who think that it would.
You know, Limerickman, obviously we disagree on various details about Lance's performance and achievements but I suspect we agree on far more and I'd love to do a ride with you one day and maybe afterwards retire to a hostelry and buy you a pint, over which we can discuss matters cycling.
Don't know if this Belvoir ride would be feasible for me (anyone got any dates?) but let's make a tentative plan to fix up a date if a suitable opportunity should crop up.